19 thoughts on “GUEST BLOG: A GUIDE TO BEING A CELTIC FAN ONLINE

  1. You MUST be talking about CQN, a site that has become so cliqueish introverted and up itself that it has become a self parody and outlived its usefulness.
    There is a small coterie of posters who only;

    Talk to and respond to each other

    Suck up to Paul 67

    Glory in being holier than thou

    Constantly pat themselves and each other on the back

    Boast about their ,usually, middle class lifestyles

    Only acknowledge contributions from one of the chosen few.

    As a result many people who have posted in the past, including myself, have stopped doing so, due to the site being tedious, boring, but mostly clannish.

    I do check in and “lurk” from time to time but I’m afraid it’s a case of same old same old.

    1. Spot on mate, the online Celtic community is one massive ‘circle-jerk’ it’s weird and it’s unhealthy.

      Nothing wrong with a good debate, we don’t all have to agree all the time, that’d be boring.

      (I wasn’t specifically referring to CQN, it was more of a general point.)

    2. Although I do go on to CQN I normally scroll down to see the comments and then it ‘podium’ or ‘how did you and your good lady get on on holiday?’ Etc. just pish.

      I registered with them and it took around 7 months to actually get a log in. By this point I realised there was no point actually commenting. Dobbers.

  2. This is a nasty misrepresentation but skillfully done. You have taken views that some people do in fact subscribe to and listed them as unquestionable facts. This is a very dishonest thing to do but particularly so since you are inferring that you are an ‘insider’ and really know what the ‘Celtic Family’ believe

    I presume that the purpose of your article is to get web site hits which generate income so well done. In the worst traditions of journalism – ‘never let the facts get in the way of a good story’.

    1. Well you appear to have missed both the tone and the intended context of the piece. At no point do I claim or infer that I am an insider in the CelticFamily (it’s not a real family for one).

      This is not my site and I do not get paid for my contribution so there is no financial motivation behind my choice of subject matter.

      I was merely trying to illustrate that there is a prominent group of Celtic fans that quash any meaningful debate about the club before it starts and I think that’s ridiculous.

      Anyway “skillfully done”? No-one’s ever called me skillful before, I’m going to print this comment and frame it. Thanks!

      1. Cool glad you like it but before you frame it don’t forget the key words ‘misrepresentation’ and ‘dishonest’. You’ll go far.

        Incidentally I think that the tendencies you identify are indeed present on Celtic sites and that it is good to see them being criticised. I just wish you weren’t generalising so wildly

  3. CQN was once a great site/blog but has now fallen foul of several of the above rules, especially the hierarchy rule. Pathetic how several posters round on others on that site.

    1. I just get pissed off at the idea that we all have to sing from the same hymn sheet and anyone who doesn’t isn’t a real Tim. Debate and differing opinions are good things, we should embrace them.

    1. Strachan got fair bit of stick when he was manager (much of it deserved by the way) I don’t have a massive problem with him but find the revisionism surrounding his reign a bit bizarre.

      There is a section of the Celtic support who are determined to be hostile toward the SFA and therefore the national side, that is who I was aiming that particular jibe at.

      Might be wrong though, I often am.

      1. He did get a bit of stick but I wouldn’t say he was disliked. I didn’t like the football wee played under him – very boring. If I didn’t like a Celtic manager then it was Mowbray!

        The scottish Celtic fans who don’t support Scotland just because they don’t like the sfa are idiots IMO (the same for those daft Huns that hate Scotland). But each to their own I suppose. I get slagged off many of my pals cos I support Scotland! No wonder people don’t understand the west of Scotland!

        1. Hmm I always felt there was an element who were very anti-Strachan and whenever anything went wrong people were on his back very quickly, oh and the football got progressively worse under him!

          Can’t really be arsed with Scotland these days but that’s got nothing to do with Celtic or the SFA (International football is just so boring the now!)

  4. fantastic article.are you really a tim?you speak too much sense.
    great points about the rangers,super ally,strachan etc.
    you must feel like the odd man out.
    mourinho is the special one.
    fair play to you.
    county down zombie king

    1. Cheers bud, yeah I really am a tim (a self loathing tim maybe?!) glad you enjoyed the piece and whilst I’m not quite the odd one out, our merry band is pretty severely outnumbered!

  5. Hi,
    Great piece! Nail on the head. I hoped you would cover the difference made between ‘fans’ and ‘supporters’. Both follow the team but only one truly contributes anything of note whether its vocal or financial. I find twitter awash with fans who spend their whole time trying to influence supporters. Usually negatively. Extremes made up example ‘footballs pish, it’s over priced and its boring why do you even go, I gave up years ago’
    Well why you still banging on about it – you gave up, we didn’t, give it a rest!
    The Celtic Family comment really made me laugh. As did the biting comment about it. It’s up there with the ‘real Celtic fans never rip each other off’ sure! I know Rangers fans I would trust a lot sooner than some Celtic fans.
    As someone who previously had a neutral account on twitter I am well aware of the nonsense it attracts and encourages. The use of ‘Old Firm’ once had me called a ‘Orange Bastard’ as ‘Celtic fans don’t use that phrase and we all know that, that’s how I know you’re a Hun’ – hmmm quite!
    Away to laugh some more at your article! And everything that is wrong with society in general!

    1. Cheers for the kind words mate, really appreciated. Aye your point about the difference between fans and supporters is spot on.

      The idea that all Celtic fans are inherently good and decent individuals just because of who they support is barking. I know plenty of Celtic fans who are utter wallopers!

      Oh aye you can’t use the OF label without accusations of being ‘one of them’ getting throw about 🙂

      Thanks for taking the time to read and comment.

Comments are closed.