Skip to content
The Celtic Blog

The Celtic Blog

Primary Menu
  • Celtic F.C.
  • News
  • Bonus Codes
  • Match Reports
  • Podcast
  • Articles & Features
  • Opinions

Neil McCann’s Stupidity And Arrogance Has Cost Dundee A Small Fortune Over Scott Bain.

James Forrest May 12, 2018
Add us as a preferred Google source
SNS-13506770-MOTHERWELL-v-DUNDEE.jpg-e1493911307260-900x540

Scott Bain was doing a little gloating yesterday, and he was fully entitled to. Scott Bain is a happy man and I can easily understand why. He has got the move of his life, the one he must have been dreaming about for years. He is at Celtic and on the brink of competing in a Scottish Cup Final. Next year, a title winners medal and Champions League football beckons.

Scott has come a long way in the space of a year.

He was a great servant to Dundee, playing over 100 times for them. But that all changed when Neil McCann came in as manager. Something happened between them, and nobody is sure to this day what it was, but the PFA later backed Bain in the case and he left the club on loan.

Bain had less than year left on his deal, but he had signed a one year extension prior to all the hassle and it’s not really in doubt that he would have wanted the club to get something for him. His contract would have seen him through to the end of this season, and he would almost certainly have left the club for a fee.

McCann’s arrogance has almost certainly cost the club a small fortune. The fact Bain has ended up at Parkhead makes it clear that he was, and remained, a saleable asset. The magnitude of this screw-up cannot be over-exaggerated.

In deciding to treat one of his players with such appalling disdain, Neil McCann has torn up a sizeable cheque.

His board appear to be happy with his performance because he didn’t get the club relegated. Their position is not materially worse than it was last season, but nor is it better. They are a club in a poor state, one seemingly content to meander along.

Like most SPL clubs, they rely on prize money, TV cash and whatever they can bring in for players.

They cannot afford to let prize assets leave for free, but here in a battle involving Neil McCann’s ego there was only going to be winner. At least in his eyes. I hope he’s satisfied. It gave him a momentary ego boost, and Celtic have a superb player for nothing.

I’m just not sure what Dundee got out of the transaction.

Everyone reading should check out the new version of Celtic News Now, available for IPhones and from Google Play. These guys make an invaluable contribution to the work the bloggers do. Please support them.

Join the best Celtic Facebook Group there is right here.

Like our Facebook page and comment on and share the articles by clicking here.

You can also follow us on Twitter at @The_Celtic_Blog

Add us as a preferred Google source

What do you feel about this?

  • Articles
  • Articles & Features
  • Blogs
  • Celtic
  • Celtic F.C.
  • Media
  • News
  • Opinions & Rants
  • Players & Staff
  • SPL
  • The Good

Post navigation

Previous: Sevco’s Previous Auditor Quit Because Of Threats. That’s What We’re Up Against.
Next: Sevco’s Bling Obsession Is Why We’ll Never Need To Worry About Them.

Related Stories

ltKDH7EwaZUk
7 minutes read
  • Articles

The CSA and The Trust go public as the Celtic fan’s patience snaps.

James Forrest July 19, 2026 7
XhXPh9HwOaLo
6 minutes read
  • Articles

Michael Nicholson, it’s time to go.

Paulina Jaczek July 19, 2026 8
prsiv8Y9378R
7 minutes read
  • Articles

Celtic fans are not stupid, nor easily scared.

James Forrest July 19, 2026 9
prsiXqHJf1Dk
10 minutes read
  • Articles

Peter Lawwell is not the answer.

James Forrest July 18, 2026 7
prsiSJqzi7rF
7 minutes read
  • Articles

An empty Celtic Park stands testament to fan anger as the team returns home.

James Forrest July 18, 2026 11
XhXPE8jwq7ul
9 minutes read
  • Articles

The situation at Celtic is untenable. Real damage is being done now.

James Forrest July 18, 2026 46

Trending Now

The CSA and The Trust go public as the Celtic fan’s patience snaps. ltKDH7EwaZUk 1

The CSA and The Trust go public as the Celtic fan’s patience snaps.

July 19, 2026 7
Michael Nicholson, it’s time to go. XhXPh9HwOaLo 2

Michael Nicholson, it’s time to go.

July 19, 2026 8
Celtic fans are not stupid, nor easily scared. prsiv8Y9378R 3

Celtic fans are not stupid, nor easily scared.

July 19, 2026 9
Peter Lawwell is not the answer. prsiXqHJf1Dk 4

Peter Lawwell is not the answer.

July 18, 2026 7
Celtic FC News
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy
  • Contact Us
  • Editorial Policy
  • About
Copyright © 2026 All rights reserved.