Articles

Ryan Porteous Has Again Undermined Any Case For Celtic Making Him An Offer.

|
Image for Ryan Porteous Has Again Undermined Any Case For Celtic Making Him An Offer.

Last night, Ryan Porteous does what only he can.

A non-Ibrox player who has no love for them at all, in any way, shape or form, he handed them three points on a plate.

He had a good game last night, up until the moment, five minutes from full time, when he stupidly stuck his leg out in the penalty box in front of a referee so foaming at the mouth in his love for the blue club that he hesitated only to say a silent prayer of thanks before he gave the spot kick.

And in that moment I understood why some of our fans scorn any suggestion from me that Ryan Porteous should ever be considered for the Celtic shirt. Porteous is a fine footballer but he sometimes cracks under pressure, and last night he cracked big time.

He is careless. That’s something that good coaching might solve, but at the same time it might not. That might be a temperament thing and that’s nearly impossible to coach out of a player.

The thing is, we saw both his good qualities and the bad last night in that game; unfortunately, defenders don’t get to make mistakes with the frequency strikers or midfielders do … they have to be alert at all times and almost supernaturally consistent.

And he is nowhere near as good as that. Last night proved it again.

You know that Ibrox social media is going to crucify him for his gleeful end-of-match interview after the cup semi-final and he better be able to handle it; I’m sure he can.

They have turned on him so frequently and consistently over the last few years, and the reason for that is that in these massive games he does this again and again and again.

And in a Celtic strip, of course, every game would be a massive game.

I like Porteous. There is the making of a great player in that boy, but as long as he has this reckless streak, this penchant for making these huge mistakes at critical times, he’s never going to be the top footballer we all know is in there.

He certainly isn’t ready right now.

To sign him for a club like Celtic would be a momentous risk, and we would pay for it a lot of times before we’d finished paying for him. That, alone, is reason to avoid such a scenario in the first place.

Sometime down the line, if he can knock this stuff out of his game, I would take him in two seconds … until then, we should pass.

Share this article

8 comments

  • TIAR says:

    He was brilliant last night, puts his body on the line. I would sign him in an instance. Shame Hibs and Celtic were robbed by a dirty cheating ref handpicked for the occasion. Look out for more of the same tonight, they have no shame.

  • Boaby kanus says:

    Yer so dramatic, we shouldn’t sign him cause he made a mistake, should we not have signed kyogo cause he missed a sitter? I’d sign the big dumplin in a second

    • Hugh Gerard says:

      No mistake, he put his foot in for the ball and tried to pull it back, he made no attempt to foul. Kent took full advantage. Porteous must know Beatons history and that he will give a penalty when things are tight for his heroes so it was stupid to make a challenge in the box so late on. Had it been at the other end would it have been given, I doubt it. Direct free kicks used to be given when a player was tripped with intent, now they seem to be given if a player trips himself, all they have to do is fall down. The game is a joke.

      • Boaby kanus says:

        It was a penalty all day long mate, stupid tackle, if it was jota we’d be screaming for it

        • Hugh Gerard says:

          Probably would be screaming for it, doesn’t make it a penalty though. Opinions may differ but the laws of the game are clear. Penalty was accepted by the media but they would have accepted a booking for Kent for diving just the same. Shows how little they know. Beaton cheated full stop.

  • Quinny says:

    I can remember Celtic signing Gary Gillespie and he was Powderpuff , so if you had a choice what type of Defender would you sign ??

  • John S says:

    Looked like a dive, not a penalty. Check the referee’s reaction, all set to play on when it dawned this was an opportunity.

  • Sean says:

    Was a definete penalty in my opinion, seen a good few times the day. It’s a penalty everyday of the week. Porteous is far to rash, he has got previous for this. Our defending is well documented over last couple of seasons, I feel he would cost us to much. We need someone who is dependable, and commanding in that area, we have had to many calamitous defensive displays. Portrteous caused Hibs last night the points, not the ref. I am no fan of Beaton that is for sure, but he was correct to award penalty.

Comments are closed.