Some Celtic Fans Must Stop Defending The Indefensible.

Image for Some Celtic Fans Must Stop Defending The Indefensible.

Yesterday I posted one of those pieces that I knew was going to annoy some people. I did it anyway because I don’t do this job worrying ever about how what I write is going to be received.

The minute you start doing that in this gig you’re finished.

Our club is not perfect. The people who work insides its walls are not perfect.

It’s supporters are not perfect.

I am a lifelong Celtic fan.

This club was my first great love and it will be the longest and most enduring of my life. I come from a family steeped in this club. Because I love Celtic I will defend Celtic, even from those who represent it,, when they fall below its standards.

We call this club an institution.

We say that it’s more than just a football club.

I have heard critics of Celtic decry those things. I have heard them do it even as they acclaim another club in the same city as ours. I don’t worry about what they think of the notion of Celtic as the thing at the centre of so many of our lives; they don’t get it and they never will.

As an institution, I think there are certain things which define us. I think Celtic is a genuine force for good in the Scottish game and in Scottish society. I am an internationalist, pro-European, pro-freedom and profoundly left wing. Those things did not bring me to Celtic, although I understand how they might have. I can only conclude that in some ways – and I can clearly define some of them – that Celtic brought me at least partly towards those outlooks.

Our club represents so many of the things that I care about. Its roots, its founding, its values, its social charter … when the directors fall below those standards, or the fans do, or the players, it is the duty of those of us who care about Celtic to comment on that and condemn it. I will never hesitate to do so, and as I do I’m fully aware that I do so through the prism of what I believe, personally, that those standards should be.

I do not claim to speak for anyone else.

There have been occasions on which I’ve posted stuff and got strong reactions to it where I’ve been accused of looking at issues which are quite complex in a binary, black and white way; I would dispute that at least some of the time. Even when I’m writing about the board and their lack of vision and imagination, I try to acknowledge that they run this club competently and that we only have to look across town to see what happens when directors don’t.

But there are issues I write about which are black and white. Issues which really don’t require nuance. There was an instance of this last week – one I didn’t write about because I thought that the journalist who did was engaging in a bit of attention seeking – where Celtic fans at Ross County were accused of singing horrific songs about deceased Ibrox staff and players.

Did it happen? Yeah I’m almost certain that it did happen; I didn’t refrain from writing about it because I thought Andrew Smith of The Scotsman lied about it, but because by his own admission it was, at most, “a few dozen fans” out of thousands …those guttersnipes aren’t representative of our support and he tried to make this our problem.

But I’ll tell you this; we do need to remove these people from our ranks, and I’ve written that before. As far as I’m concerned, these troglodytes don’t belong in the Celtic fan-base any more than right wing Nazi salute making fascists do, and I don’t believe there should be any more debate over that than there is over whether the earth is flat or round.

They don’t represent our values. They are not who we’re supposed to be. I’m sick of these people, sick writing about them, sick of knowing they self-define as part of our ranks, sick and tired of their flat refusal to get with the program as part of the human race.

And yet every time I write about that I get stick from certain people accusing me of doing the work of the enemy for them. Ridiculous. Shameful. Pig ignorance writ large. Those who respond like that are no better than those doing the chanting.

To me, there’s just no point in debating people like that at all. That they can’t see that something like that is just plain wrong, pure and simple, with no defence for it … it’s genuinely astonishing to me.

Astonishing. I won’t even try to see their “point of view.”

Yesterday’s article was a little more nuanced but not by much, because really, what nuance is required? If, as has been reported, our new left back got behind the wheel of his car drunk then what’s there to do but condemn that in the strongest terms?

But instead of that, people want to have a go at me? For stating the obvious?

Which is that Celtic will throw the proverbial book at this guy, and he’ll find it that much tougher to impress a manager who himself insists on the higher standards of behaviour on and off the pitch?

None of that ought to be controversial, far less to provoke outrage.

Outrage I can just about take, because there’s a section of our fan-base which does respond to every criticism of the club, no matter how slight, well aimed or deserved, as though it were the act of a heretic.

You can tell them by the way their whole method of debate is represented in insults and highly personal language. I don’t bother with them.

If that were all the negative response that piece yesterday got, there would be no need for this one. I’ve been getting that stuff since I posted my first article over a decade ago now.

It’s the rationalisations I find most troubling. It’s the whatabouttery, its the excuses … they bother me because this is a serious matter and it troubles me to see that some folk don’t seem to have grasped that in their rush to defend him simply because he’s one of our players.

First off, let me deal with the allegation that I’ve jumped the gun and this is all about innocent until proven guilty.

This isn’t going to a jury trial; this is going in front of a judge to decide the level of punishment and that’s all it is.

This a road traffic offence; whether that’s drunk driving, reckless driving, speeding or whatever it is your guilt is established the minute you are pulled over and found to be behind the wheel.

Folks might occasionally offer a mitigation argument but “not me guv, you’re looking for someone else” isn’t sustainable in the least. A defence of “I did nothing wrong” is doomed in an era of speed-guns, dash-cam and breathalysers.

He was taken into custody, which means he’s bang to rights.

As to the nature of the charge, I think we can take that one to the bank as well. I’ve been active in politics and I’ve been studying that arena even longer than I’ve been doing this and the first rule of reputation management is that you correct – immediately – anything in the public record which you are able to contest. What do people think footballer’s agents do? This is part of their job, and so if this wasn’t what every outlet is reporting that would have been challenged and refuted before now.

You don’t get taken into custody for speeding.

There are things that were in some of those articles which had no business being in there, innuendos instead of specific allegations, and I said in my piece that not only should we ignore all of them but that nobody should be allowed to get away with spreading them.

So if I’ve rushed to judgement I’ve stopped somewhat short of digging a hole before a funeral.

Like I said, I’ve been doing this a while. Mistakes are one thing, but I like to think I am more sensible than to resort to tabloidesque condemnation without cause.

I’ve also refuted any suggestion that Celtic should tear up his contract or any of that other nonsense.

This was an incredibly irresponsible and stupid act … but let’s try, at least, to give the guy a chance to own it, and make amends.

That only leaves us with what all the accounts suggest happened here, which is that this guy got behind the wheel somewhat worse for wear and got a pull for it.

Now, again, I can take those who shout me down for “not waiting for the full facts.” I get that argument, I accept that argument, but I’ve laid out my reasons why I don’t think it is valid.

I think we have the facts we need to make a judgement.

Other arguments … no, I don’t accept those at all.

“He’s a kid in a new country,” is a familiar one, and really?

Those are mitigating factors? His age and his nationality?

In what countries around the world is it no big deal to drive whilst pissed? Even if there were dozens and Argentina was one of them, he lives here now … and in this one a glass of wine is considered over the limit and you still get done for it.

He posted a social media image of himself outside a pub hours before he got pulled over by the cops … who also, by the way, need a damned good reason to pull you over and give you a breath-test in the first place. See my point?

I shouldn’t even need to debate the point about his age, because if we don’t know stories about people younger than him – but old enough to get behind the wheel legally – who’ve actually killed people doing what he’s done here then I suggest that some folk have short memories and should refresh them right quick.

What he did was not just reckless and embarrassing to this club, it was staggeringly, mind-bendingly dangerous not just to himself but to other people.

What more needs to be said? Those in charge of our club know this very well and I would expect that someone from our HR department had a long chat with this guy earlier in the week and clued him into a few things, and if that wasn’t the most sobering – no pun intended – discussion of his life then I dread to think of what else he’s heard in it.

The law classes Bernabei as an adult, because he is. And he knows right from wrong as well as anyone reading this article, and I find it pathetic that some would treat this as if it were the act of a child who simply doesn’t know any better.

Age and “lack of experience” is used as an excuse these days for everything from this stuff to outright racism. Nothing time and a little “education” won’t sort out, some folk, and in particular on the other side of the city, would have you believe.

But I’m with Ange. How much education do you need to not be an arsehole? To be a good and decent person? To not hate someone on the basis of their religion or their skin colour? And since it’s very much on point, how old do you have to be to not do what anyone wet behind the ears knows is stupid and dangerous shit?

A footballer does not put on a halo the minute he poses for a snap-shot as a new signing in a Celtic strip, any more than a person becomes a better human being the minute they drape a Celtic scarf around their neck.

Living up to the standards this club deserves sometimes requires a bit of self awareness and the willingness to moderate your worst impulses. Some can do it. Some fall below those standards and feel enormous regret for it.

Some don’t give a shit either way.

I expect that our new boy is going to be one of those people who, once some facts are made known to him, once he gets a little local history, he’ll get it instantly and wise up faster than at any other point in his life, just as happened to Callum McGregor when he did the same thing.

For him, it was a formative experience because he felt that shame, and took the right lesson from it.

Callum would have been personally offended by anyone trying to rationalise what he did or put it down to high-jinx and boys will be boys.

His realisation was real precisely because he didn’t let anyone do that or to minimise what had happened or – God forbid – what might have.

If you read my piece earlier in the week about how Scottish football hasn’t learned from the Ibrox war with the SPFL because it’s not done any specific harm yet you might remember the analogy in there from a statistician who worked on the US government’s response to swine flu, and saw all sorts of reasons to be scared by the right’s assertion that it hadn’t been a real crisis because very few people actually died of it.

He framed it as a lesson about dangerous driving, namely someone looking at their phone whilst behind the wheel of a car.

Imagine you do that and you lose concentration for a moment and drift towards the hard shoulder.

Wow. You correct your mistake and drive on.

There are no consequences.

Imagine instead though you veer off the road and hit something, and dent your car.

A different experience, one you’re more likely to take something away from.

Imagine instead though you run slap bang into a tree or a wall and that seriously damages your car and perhaps you walk away with a modest injury.

Different consequences, different experience, and your response to it would certainly not be the same as if no harm was done and you walked away without a scratch on either you or your sweet ride.

Imagine instead of that you’d hit a person.

Injuries. Perhaps death to another human being.

Would you even get behind the wheel of a car again, provided you even had the choice to?

You know what the guy’s point was?

The lesson is the same.

The fundamental error, the utterly stupid act, is the same one no matter which of those scenarios unfolds.

Move on, yes, and we will … this club, this support, this player.

But before we do we ought to condemn, just so that there are consequences, just so the lesson is learned.

That’s what Callum grasped and took from his experience.

It’ almost certainly what Bernabei will.

Some of our fans should think that over and do the same, and stop defending the indefensible.

Share this article


  • mark B says:

    The young lad made a mistake it looks like, a big one. He gets one more chance in my book. like most footballers he does not know how lucky he is to be here.
    The chants are a disgrace. The Sad Orange B******* one i have heard tens of thousands sing at Celtic Park. its a disgrace. Also Dirty Orange B******* often directed at referees by tens of thousands. Roamin in the Gloaming, Oh Ah Up the ‘RA, need i go on, its every week!!!!. Do not shirk from this its a giant sore at the heart of our support. Just like Billy boys is for others. Its the mirror image, cant people see that????????????
    And to say “some” sectarian chanting is offensive is in itself offensive. ALL SECTARIAN, RACIST type chants are a disgrace. IRA ones too. At away matches its thousands not a minority. Lets accept its awful – then we have a chance of dealing with it.

    • Roonsa says:

      Mark B. Gonnae shut the fuck up about IRA songs? You clearly don’t know what you are talking about which immediately makes me wonder why you are on here. If you are here to troll, you are not making a very good job of it.

  • REBELLIOUS says:

    Excellent James, thanks.

    And for me your bang on, I voluntarily gave up my driving license because my hands started to spasm up occasionally into a fist and a few times it happened with both hands simultaneously; I then have to pull my fingers apart one by one, I use my teeth to start with.

    Can you imagine what might’ve happened if I was behind the wheel when that occurred?

    I could and spoke to my doctor who said ‘there’s not many would be so forthright about declaring that; knowing there would be consequences and possibly even losing their license’
    I said ’I simply couldn’t live with myself if anything happened and I’d caused it’

    I got a bus pass the following week and I really don’t miss driving at all, especially with fuel prices atm. TAXI!


  • Hans says:

    The singing about dead Ibrox players is a disgrace. And it’s not just a few bampots singing. A lot of people are involved and you’re right to call it out.

    • Kevan McKeown says:

      It’s disgustin. Scumbags singin vile songs about a tragedy. These morons should try, just for once, givin their brain a chance, but maybe that’s askin too much, beyond their mentality. Too fuckin stupid tae feel ashamed. Just whit exactly are they tryin tae prove wi this, dae they think it’s showin any kind of ‘allegiance’ tae our club. They’re a fuckin disgrace and an embarrassment.

  • Bhoy4life says:

    We live in a society where there is no personal responsibility and also full of apologists.
    Its always someone else’s fault.
    Also generally, high earning ballers get a longer leash than most.
    Personally I would throw the book at him, he hasn’t exactly been setting the heather alight on the park, so he hasn’t even got the irreplaceable tag for an excuse.

  • Paul Conner says:

    Well said. Agree 100%. Keep up the good work.

  • Jim says:

    James, can’t believe you are trying to justify your disgraceful article the other day with another.
    I made the first comment on it and stand by it.
    None of us have a clue yet as to the degree of the road traffic offence and the level, if any, of excess alcohol in his system. My personal view is if you’re driving it should always be zero but that’s not the current law
    As for your comment “ He was taken into custody, which means he’s bang to rights.”
    Remember the notorious Thugs and Thieves episode?
    Three of our players were in custody and we all know how guilty they were.

    In my book another disgraceful article trying to justify your rush to judgement.

    As for your comment “He was taken into custody, which means he’s bang to rights.“

    • Johnny Green says:

      Personally, I think by this time, if Bernabei had committed a minor offence, that Celtic would have made a statement accordingly in order to quash any damaging rumours that may have been circulating.

      I’m not sure what their silence is telling us.

  • Brian Comerford says:

    With you all the way.

  • Mick says:

    James, I don’t normally comment on any article but felt I had to yesterday. I shall only focus on the content of my reply yesterday which surrounds the lynch mod mentality you applied surrounding a young celtic player who was taken into custody for a alleged offence. If the alleged offence was drink driving related and a breath test had showed a positive result then regardless who the person was they would be taken into custody to have a blood test taken to confirm if alcohol is in the blood stream, this being carried out by a police doctor. Your article yesterday called for the young man to be hung, drawn and quartered which is bad enough but compounded by your article being based on hearsay rather than fact was poor judgement on your part. If he is found to have broken the law then he has to own up to what he has done and should be prepared to make amends. The juditory and Celtic will also deal with there respective duties of law enforcement and employer. What isn’t required is gossip mongering and shit stirring before the incident runs it’s course. I mentioned yesterday that this young man had recently moved here away from his parents, probably the first time he has travelled outwith his homeland and yes good forbid may have made a mistake, small or large it’s a mistake and something he will have to live with for the rest of his life. Celtic as a good employer should dig a bit deeper to see if he has problems settling into his new life and while not condoning his actions afford him any required support he needs. I truly hope he makes amends if proven guilty, learns from his mistake and becomes a valued member of the Celtic Family after all as you stated in your lengthy attempt at self justification response today. Celtic is a club like no other based on inclusion of
    all so we should also practice what we preach and include forgiveness as well. As Jesus said he who has not sinned cast the first stone. I’m sure none of us would be able to pick up the first stone as we have as many pointed out done things we have regretted in the past.

    • Johnny Green says:

      Lynch mob mentality, hung drawn and quartered……talk about over exaggeration, I have not read any of these so called reactions in any of the comments.

      Get a grip!

      • Mick says:

        I have a grip John and replied on what I read in both articles rather than opting to focus on the alleged offence and what could be happening as Celtic hadn’t commented as you did. My issue was the way in which the young guy was labelled and the severity of punishment that should be exacted. I stand by what I said to the word.

        You have a nice day

  • Michael Gordon says:

    I am in complete agreement with you on this, especially the totally abhorrent singing about the dead. Decent fans need to confront these wee neds as I did on a bus from the city centre heading to Celtic Park. I am in my seventies and was at the Ibrox disaster game in 1971 and when these 4 pitiful excuses for humans started singing about it I confronted them and their reaction was to shut up and slink off the bus at the next stop

  • Jim Conlon says:

    Totally agree with you about the singing of offensive songs, again at rugby Park we had the morons singing about someone being a sad orange b——, what’s that got to do with our great football club, we all know people who are sick and tired of listening to these songs, those at the top of our club completely ignore it, it needs to be addressed with a code of conduct for away fans

Comments are closed.