Aberdeen Fans Wanted A Proper Response From Their Board. They Did Not Get One.

Image for Aberdeen Fans Wanted A Proper Response From Their Board. They Did Not Get One.

Aberdeen has tonight released an incredible statement backing Jim Goodwin to remain in the dugout, but emphasising that they expect results. The only results they are going to get are further embarrassments and humiliations and this time they will not be the fault of Goodwin alone, they will be the shared responsibility of everyone who kept him in post.

This was the scenario when our directors failed to sack Neil Lennon in the aftermath of the Ross County debacle.

This site and others pointed out that from that moment on the responsibility for whatever went wrong was shared equally between the boardroom and the dugout and in the end it precipitated major changes at the club, although not major enough.

The Aberdeen board has tonight abrogated its own responsibilities, but that does not mean that they are able to hide. I

t means that the disgrace of Goodwin’s management is now their disgrace.

It means that every future reversal is down to them as much as him, because he’s shown himself completely unfit to be the manager of their club and they have shown themselves to be completely unfit to be in charge of it, and I feel terrible for Aberdeen fans tonight.

They required a real show of leadership from their club and they have not got it.

Instead the board has left in post a manager responsible for the biggest shock in Scottish Cup history, an unsurvivable result, a man who everyone knows has no authority left and in spite of their claims to the contrary cannot possibly have the confidence of the squad.

But more importantly, as I said the other day, he does not have the support in the stands where the only people who matter have made their own position absolutely clear-cut. This is a sterling example of what happens when owners far away from the action mistake their custodian status for the authority to deny the supporters their voice.

And this is a decision that will be reversed sooner rather than later, as Aberdeen fans will not accept it and nor should they be expected to. This is a gutless decision from a board which has forfeited its own right to claim it acts in the club’s best interests.

Those interests can only be served by reacting, forcefully, to the most humiliating night in the history of their club and making clear that they still believe in standards. Jim Goodwin will be fired in due course, because there’s no turning this around, and that their board of directors is evidently blind to this fact, or unable to act in the face of It, should worry the supporters of that club more than any run of bad results ever could.

Aberdeen FC is in a very bad place tonight, and what this episode makes crystal clear is that the manager is far from being their only problem. Indeed, he might not even be their biggest problem, and this matters to Celtic fans and indeed to the supporters of any club who care about the standard of our league and the level of competition in it.

I make no apology whatsoever for discussing this issue tonight; I’ve long reminded people that in spite of the name this is not merely a “Celtic site”, but a Scottish football site written from a Celtic perspective. These issues matter to us. 

Share this article


  • James Ward says:

    A great piece of writing.Jim Goodwin should have been looking for another club tonight but like our board of director’s two year’s ago the Aberdeen fan’s are being short-changed.

  • Fat mike says:

    With the level of legitimate money invested in the squad, decent scouting and quality in the squad they literally should be celtics biggest challengers. Hearts are doing well whilst being functional rather than attractive to watch and hibs are trying to be leeds under bielsa and failing miserably at it.. they need a man with a clear tactical idea and how to maximise duk and mioski, not just sign a waning ex player to shout on the field. Time to get innovative aberdeen and not start the interview with “aye I seen you done well down the road so…”

  • Neil Smith says:

    Looking at upcoming fixtures for Aberdeen it’s a dead men walking match Saturday… But that and the next 2 are winnable for them. Will see. Next one however is us at home. Terrible results of late but look at the likely replacements Lambert Ross Lennon unless (unlikely) they think outside the box, any difference likely with such candidates.

  • Geoff says:

    wtf has things to with Celtic past,present or future?

    • Seppington says:

      Goodwin is an ex-Celt.

    • Roonsa says:

      Geoffrey, old fruit. Read the article. The similarities between how Aberdeen are treating Goodwin and how Celtic let Lennon get away with murder for so long are very noticeable.

  • Jack says:

    Aberdeen parked the bus against us in our last game against them at Pittodrie. That performance showed them to be a club that has lost it’s soul. A complete clear out is required if they want to remain a Premier League club.

  • Nick66 says:

    Unsure of what the actual FCk, Jim Goodwank’s Dons tenure is relevant to our current situation. Maybe just your spleen venting re our board, ( not forgotten), but in truth?

  • Eldraco says:

    Darvel to be perfectly frank on the day in question would have given Celtic a good run for our money and possibly have beaten most of the rest.

    There is money in juniors, ex SPFL players sick of corruption and that pitch put Celtic park to shame. And on that note, just why is our pitch an absolute disgrace JF? , why not get onto this and ask JP why the richest club is Scottish football has a turnip field as a pitch.

    The blight? Surely not!

    • Roonsa says:

      I don’t know anything about Darvel or the pitch they normally play on. But I can guarantee you 100%, the pitch they played Aberdeen on in Monday night’s game does not get played on as much as Celtic Park does.

  • Effarr says:

    Have a wee bit of compassion for a young man with a family trying to do his job. I can`t understand people shouting for a
    person`s head while hoping their own jobs will always be secure.

    At least every result Aberdeen get until the end of time will be better than the Darvel one and he managed to put the Inverness v Celtic result into second place.

Comments are closed.