65 thoughts on “Celtic Is In Serious Danger Of Ending Up With The JD Vance Transfer Window.”

  1. Ive always been a conspiracy theorist…we looked nailed on for 10IAR but inexplicably its the only lge we’ve lost…this season would be 55 and we know what that means…I just think its deffo stage managed to keep them relevant and probably prevent some considerable social unrest, cos I could see that happening all too easily.

  2. What the hell are they doing James ? What do they know that they are not telling us ? What’s coming down the road towards us that prevents genuine transfer business ? Something stinks to high heaven.

  3. Don’t yi see what trump was doin when he appointed JD Vance as his VP?
    He’s assassination insurance. No coincidence he named him immediately after they tried ti murder him, so that if they try again, his ideas and policies will continue.
    Like him or loathe him, but that was a bit of political genius from trump

    1. I, like others am quite curious why your last post is removed. I really enjoy many of your posts James but don’t enjoy reading the comparisons with political events and politicians to get to the crux of your point concerning Celtic. Celtic to me and I think to many others is a vehicle to get away from reality like work and politics, a release from all that stuff

  4. Simple question. Were you threatened and had to pull the pin on the previous post by Celtic. Aka the fat bastard.

    If so its time to call night night on the lot of them. Arrive an hour early stay in grounds an hour later flying banners and tifos. Make sure its all ovver the tv

  5. Like JD Vance, I too have had sex with a sofa, of the burst couch variety.
    But I am a mere 72 years of age and willing to learn.?
    Brendan Rodgers knew his targets the minute last season ended, it’s the board under the questionable leadership of Lawwell who is at fault here, absolutely nobody else.

    1. James. It’s becoming an obsession with you now. We have enough to see us through August. If by the end of August we haven’t signed up decent players then I’ll jump into the camp of negativity on the Celtic board. Have patience and let’s see how this next 4 weeks go. Chill out and enjoy the football season starting again

  6. Don’t know why you removed your previous blog James, I personally thought it was a great piece and an insight into what
    can be happening inside the walls of parkhead, no one is privvy to that .
    Considering the time, effort and thoughts you put into it your entitled to your opinions, if others disagree again that’s their opinion.
    Would have left it up but closed the comments.
    Until they construct their own blogs they don’t realise how hard the opinions of others are, your not here to appease, keep up the great work James, thoroughly enjoy your comments whether I fully agree or not.

    1. I don’t think you will get an answer to your question as money talks aswell as privileges. I.E. want extra chips ? then shut it. James has and fully respect him has annoyed someone who can tell him to stop, word it differently use americano as a way of confusing the supporting fans of the blog and hey free sauce ? or he has been told his ticket will be cancelled, who knows (only James) I still believe in that crystal ? I found ?

  7. The Celtic board have four weeks to put things right, I understand why a large section of the support are worried at the lack of incomings, let’s face it historically the people in charge at Celtic Park have shown no ambition to break out of the narrow confines of Scottish Football and the “Old Firm” label. They can deny it all they want, but anytime we’ve had the chance to leave the club from Ibrox far behind they’ve shied away from pushing home the advantage we’ve had, seemingly worried that our support would lose interest if we are too far ahead of the team playing out of Ibrox.
    What they don’t seem to realise is that our support would soon forget about the Ibrox mob if our ambition was to look to become a reasonable European club, by that I mean qualifying regularly for the knockout stages of the Champions League. The last time we were in a position to leave the successor club at Ibrox far behind and the Old Firm a distant memory we bottled it. Ronny Deila was brought to the club and our signings were pretty uninspiring. Lawwell and the board then seemed to think that because the original Rangers weren’t in the league a sizeable number of our support didn’t buy season tickets, when the real reason was the supporters could smell the lack of ambition coming from the boardroom.
    I’ll hold back my verdict on this transfer window until midnight on the 30th August, I do think that the supporters and podcasts have to keep up the pressure on the board, as they have let us down time and time again.

  8. I had a look at my crystal ball which I found drunk on the way home, I will not win the lottery tonight but it did show me 3 numbers that might get used before the end of the month. I believe children should scream if they want, I also believe to wait until there is a reason why the work has not been finished on time, now celtic have until like brendan said the end of the transfer window ? pushing for changes causes problems try wearing last seasons sports wear this season it is the only way. ( unless it’s made by ca to e ) HH

  9. How long does it take to monitor a player and want to add him to your squad. How long does it take to prepare a bid which you know will be refused because it undervalues the player. How long does it take to prepare a second bid, which you know will get exactly the same treatment as the first.
    How long does it take for the board to sit.on their bottoms hoping the other club will change their.minds until they realise it’s not going to happen. Celtics transfer activity in a nutshell.
    How long before DD realises the board are not fit for purpose and that BR would be quite entitled to walk away because he is not valued.
    In the name of God Celtic, get real or stagnate.

  10. James why has your previous article on the club downsizing been taken down, I thought it was fantastic and you absolutely nailed it

  11. Nothing changes until Desmond, Lawell, and Nicholson are gone.

    If the punters are happy to get shafted every year, that’s up to them. Unfortunately, they’re only prolonging the downward spiral of the club.

  12. Brilliant piece James. Bang on too if the shoe was on the other foot the huns would have our face in the dirt and work even harder to make sure we stayed there. I hope we ain’t one bad hamburger away from that hahaha good stuff

  13. So the obvious question has to be; why did you pull the earlier article.

    I accept everything you’ve said in the current one 10000%. (Not a typo).

    This Board as usual are gambling on The Tribute Act being Fuxed, that the Belgian Waffler
    won’t be able to get a tune out of his eclectic ensemble, that the loss of Ibrox as home ground
    will have a permanent debilitating effect on their squad ( the contrary could be the case as the
    new recruits have never experienced the toxic cauldron of hate at the ‘building site that John Brown played for).

    The Board and their apologists should take cognisance of the Season just past to see how close we came to handing the League Flag over to Sevco.

    We had a threadbare squad filled with so many unsuitable, inexperienced recruits yet crying out for older more experienced quality additions to our squad that have been apparent as necessary for the last 2/3 seasons.

    We won that last League Title on the basis of the results against TavPen & his mates. They were a shambles then but ably assisted by their Varmen who kept them in contention. We can’t assume that ‘Gollum’s’donning the mantle as the Head of refereeing is going to eradicate that pernicious problem.

    The Board is the problem and Lawwell is included in that.
    The evidence is irrefutable and plenty.
    No way has he relinquished control. Even his presence at Celtic adds to the perception of his meddling
    in football matters.

    They ALL need chased.

  14. I think if this continues then Celtic Supporters should boycott Champions League Tickets which will be the same old embarrassing stuff, waste of money.
    That would certainly get their attention.

  15. Hi James

    Pretty depressing that you have to give a long analysis of US politics as a means of making your cogent and consistent criticisms of the lack of board leadership to match the aspirations of the fans. The very fact that you have to resort to analogies to get round ‘censorship’ is like something from samidzat writers in Czechoslovakia under the Communists. The very fact that you have to ‘self censor’ by removing an article is even more depressing. I can’t imagine you would ever write something that would actionable so it all seems fair comment. I don’t always agree with your pieces or the discursive forays into Roman history but you offer a chance for fans to know what is going on and you are holding an detached board to account on behalf of those who pay for this club. Celtic and all it stands for is eternal, the board is transient so keep the pen sharp and the eye keen

  16. More than a few of us will recall the psychological impact that top quality signing by the club playing out of Ibrox prior to Sevco, had on us over the years. We were signing Vidar Riseth when, at the same time were signing Van Bronckhorst, Numan and Kanchelskis.
    When we were signing Carl Muggleton, they signed Duncan Ferguson for a fee we could not dream of spending.
    The psychological impact on Sevco if we made a few top-quality signings would be devastating for them and their fans. We could easily bury them with our current financial strength. If the shoe were on the other foot, they would not hesitate.

  17. Another ‘Groundhog Transfer Window’

    …again. 🙁

    Regardless of the the rationale, or perceived motivations,

    the bottom line for me is that our Board is being dishonest [allegedly]

    to its own paying punters.

    “Progress in Europe” was / is just a marketing slogan for the club.

  18. It’s a sad state of affairs IF people are threatened with legal action for telling the truth….

    1. Is that why the previous piece has been taken down?

      I don’t live in Scotland anymore. I watch the games on celtic tv. I love celtic. I’m considering cancelling my subscription if this ends the way I think it will. That means nothing to the club and they won’t care but they’re making me sick to my stomach.

  19. Celtic’s policies on transfers is so irritating and frustrating. Every transfer window is the same hoping for some top quality signings only to be disappointed and rush to get players in. The sad thing is that if our noisy neighbours had our wealth they would blow us out the water guaranteed.

    1. I don’t Even get angry anymore. The Fans can Read the celtic Board like a Book.

  20. Great article, James. And I echo the views of many of the others namely if your previous post was withdrawn (i didn’t read it) because it was too close to the truth and uncomfortable for some by challenging their strategy (or lack of it) you’re obviously causing them discomfort. Keep the faith. HH

    1. Look at the problems over at bigot dome with bad planning for the future. Celtic are run by proper business men/women we all might not like how they go on when comes to transfers. But that’s how we have millions in reserve and this way will continue still a month to go before transfer window closes so plenty of time to get players in that Mr Rodgers wants.

  21. Michael Nicholson as CEO has to be held responsible for the failure to ensure the manager has been properly supported so far in the transfer window, he is the man in charge of the corporate strategy which has seen the squad weakened over the past few windows.
    It is also worth noting that Thomas Allison who controls 3.45% of the shareholding and Dermot Desmond our largest shareholder are both non-executive directors and will have had input( in Dermot’s case significant one would assume) in the clubs transfer policy as it will from part of the corporate strategy,
    James please continue to highlight the shameful way our board has failed to support the manager.
    I suggest that everyone who holds shares in the PLC should be bombarding the board with requests to explain exactly why they feel it is appropriate to hoard supporters and sponsors money in the manner they currently are. HH

  22. I’ve been reading these blogs for a while now and haven’t missed one, I missed the one that’s been taken down, I can guess from the headline what it’s about but why take it down? Even when I don’t agree with what you say, your case is always well made and worth considering, keep it up.

  23. Spot on I have been telling anyone who will listen the exact same thing , our board are toxic unfit to run our club no ambition whatsoever we need at least 3 first team players in ASAP otherwise we all know the old saying you reap what you sow.

  24. Spot on.
    The board claims that we are a world class club.
    Aye we are, shame that we don’t have a world class board to back it up.
    I am 60, have lived through so many dark times , we are going for 3 in a row. Why when my club is in the most powerful place it’s ever been amazingly I am underwhelmed, worried ect!
    Starting to believe, as has been floated, that the money men are fattening the cow for market.

  25. I totally agree, Celtic have the money to buy decent players, we’re in a worse position now than at the end of last season, we’ve sold a few, and only bought 2 goalies, which was absolutely necessary, we’ve bought one player that we had on loan, and no new blood at all!
    This has the capacity to go tots up, oh so easily, a couple of injuries, as you said, Rangers not being as bad as we thought, and we’re playing catch up all over again.
    Spend money,try to get a team that can operate at European levels, and stop embarrassing us!
    No vision at all! If Rogers is complicit he isn’t much of a manager, if he was worth his salt, he’d be telling them to get him players NOW!

  26. As I’ve stated before on Sunday the whole stadium needs to unite and leave Liewwell, Nicholson and the rest in no doubt how we feel about their disdain, arrogance and utter incompetence. Not one of them is fit for purpose but as long as they receive their bonuses and their jollies on Champions League nights they’ll stay on and continue to screw us over.
    SACK THE BOARD

  27. I don’t agree with your opinion of Kamala Harris James but your general point is spot on in my opinion. You talk about players not coming to Scotland but here is my issue. This board it seems only concern themselves with being ahead of The Rangers, nothing else matters. In my early 60s I remember well great results in Europe. That is the arena where we should belong. We have Been embarrassed there recently and that is unacceptable in my opinion. Doing well in the Champions league gets you the riches that keeps us well ahead of The other side of the city, that is fact. Sadly it seems the board don’t care. Another issue for me is that in my opinion we should be signing the best young players in Scotland. Lot of people raving about young Miller from Motherwell. He showed up well last season against us. The money recieved for OH could guarantee us at least 2 of the countries best youngsters. I know people will say they are project signings but I would say they are well worth a go.

  28. I wouldn’t be surprised if Rodgers left at the end of next season…and this time no one would blame him

  29. We all make mistakes even BR. Selling OH before an incoming better (?) striker
    was a bad decision. When Idah came in in January OH got very few minutes.
    OH was a powerful physical player who lacked the acceleration of Kyogo but he could hold the ball-up. Surely he was only going to get better with Celtic experience behind him.
    He had the makings of a Viduka type of player. Hope he excels at Gent.

  30. Brilliant piece. I agree with every word.
    It’s people like you with great strategic thinking that should be on our board.
    Don’t let Liewell’s henchmen shut you up.

  31. The recruitment team seem only able to negotiate one signing target at a time, and only move onto the next target when that’s complete. Makes me wonder if it’s a strategy of money out equals money in, without investing any of the huge profit or CL money on new players. I.e. if they receive a total of say £25m for sales including O’Riley, that’s the maximum they will spend. Having to wait for their expected amount for O’Riley could explain their delay in making signings. They’ve got Bernardo’s previously proposed fee down by almost half so does that leave a bit more for Idah? Say they get Idah for £6.5m, that would be £11m spent from the projected £25m, leaving £14m for a CB, LB, back-up CF and a replacement for O’Riley. They’re trying to get a loan signing for LB (Beck) and a possible free agent (McKenna?) for CB. If they pay £3m for Conway that would leave £11m for Matt’s replacement.

  32. Can we play transfer failure excuse bingo?

    I’ll start:

    “Nobody wanted to take our money!”

  33. No one is asking the board to spend money we don’t have,in fact no one is asking to spend all the money we do have,just to look where the manager believes we are short in cover with the right players to do that and show some sort of faith that we’re strong enough to win the league and possibly the cups and give a decent showing in Europe instead of one step ahead of you know who

  34. James, I agree with 99% of what you say but just one quibble, why do you call them tired old white guys? …. tired? maybe, old? older yes but too old for the job? and white? it’s not a crime to be white and obviously nobody can choose their skin colour so why use that as a stick to beat them with?

    1. They are old. They are guys. They are white.

      If you want me to get deeper than that, it’s a sad indictment that but for a couple of women in modest executive roles that our directors box has such a lack of diversity.

      1. James if you had put up an alternative candidate to replace any ,or even all of the board your point would have more validity, it shouldn’t matter what race, creed colour or sex they are but advocating for diversity just because you don’t want the current board, to me smacks of box ticking just for the sake of it, I’m with you on most of what you say, I can’t wait to see the back of Lawell and is ilk but because they are incompetent not because they are old or white

  35. What exactly makes you an expert in transfer negotiations and dealing with other club officials? You are not in possession of all the relevant facts in any talks with players or club representatives yet you criticise on a daily basis. Are you of the opinion that we should accept the first price that any club claims their player is worth or should we have a figure in mind(possibly suggested by BR) and negotiate? Yes there is no doubt that we require several additions to our squad, however, not at any price. There will be more arrivals, of that I am sure, so let us look forward to another successful season and back the manager and the board/ H H

      1. Is that the best you can do? Sorry, I forgot, nobody can criticise James F. How sad, I expected better.

  36. I have no idea if your comments on your Celtics are valid, but your commentary on presidential politics are more than a bit unsophisticated.

  37. What a bizarre analogy.

    Everything comes down to incentives. Celtic are a publicly traded PLC so their incentives are to maximize shareholder value. To do that they maximize earnings. And to do that it all comes down to doing as little as possible in order to win the league (stay one step above Rangers).

    Would be great to splash some cash to try to make a run in Europe, but there’s so much risk that comes with that strategy (injuries, defensive lapse at the death, players having a bad night). The upside isn’t there and the board knows it.

    Until the incentives change fundamentally, expect much of the same.

    1. Maximise shareholder value lol

      Let me tell you how that will work if they keep piling up the money and we don’t do the business on the pitch.

      It won’t.

      1. 50 odd thousands season tickets sold should come with a guarantee of seeing some new faces surely?

  38. Raiding smaller clubs who outplayed us in Europe used to be our transfer strategy, which to be fair brought us viduka and bratback. We don’t do that no more. Finding bargains in Holland like henk and big virgil served us well. We don’t do that no more. Scouring England for established players out of luck/form like Sutton, hartson, Thompson, ntcham, ledley, (OK, o reilly) We don’t do that no more. Ditto Scandinavia. Bodo glimt/ rosenborg could have been raided. Signing the best players of the rest in Scotland like Robson, hartley, brown, Caldwell. We don’t do that no more. Granted not great field but surley mckenna/shankland could do us a turn if no one else? Bringing through our own like teirney, mcmanus, donnelly, Creaney, Burchill, forrest, cal. We don’t do that no more. Probably more kids than ever playing football and no one is good enough for us apart from 3 last decade.

Comments are closed.