Articles

The Ibrox board is waiting for Celtic before they make a decision on their own manager.

|
Image for The Ibrox board is waiting for Celtic before they make a decision on their own manager.
Photo by Craig Williamson/SNS Group via Getty Images

One of the more remarkable things about Scottish football right now is the way the Ibrox club seems unable to make up its mind about its manager—until he’s been beaten by Celtic. This is a hopeless, dreadful, floundering boss who’s just about clinging to the last rung of the ladder. And yet they can’t make a decision until we go there and play them.

I knew he would survive after the Spurs game. I knew they weren’t going to sack him after he got a good result there. For the axe to fall, we’d have to inflict a serious humiliation on him and his team at Hampden.

Other than that, I figured he’d just brass-neck it out.

But the fact there was even a question of whether he’d survive after the cup final shows just how much everything over there revolves around us, right down to the timing of their biggest decisions.

Put yourself in the shoes of the Ibrox board for a moment. Ask yourself this: would you need to see how the manager gets on against Celtic, in front of his own home support, before deciding on his future?

If you were the one calling the shots, what evidence would you look for beyond that match to determine whether to keep him or not?

Is there any sign at all that this guy can put together a long winning run? The answer has to be no. Is there any sign that he’s improved a single footballer under his coaching or motivational methods? Again, no. Can he be trusted with the club’s resources? Consider his deals: the £6 million impending fee for Cortes, the £4 million spent on Diomande, and the £2.5 million for Bajrami, none of whom have delivered.

Once more, the answer is surely no.

This manager has done enough to justify his sacking two or three times over. That’s my take. He’s already demonstrated that he’s not going to turn things around. He’s shown a capacity for failure and, worse, an acceptance of it. Just look at his comments in the media yesterday—they were extraordinary. He said he’s not focusing on the points gap and isn’t interested in it at all, only in his team’s performances.

He still believes they were excellent in the second half at Paisley. He doesn’t seem to grasp that they played well for about 20 minutes before falling back into the same patterns as the first 45. He seems oblivious to the fact that St Mirren created the better chances at the end, scored the second goal, and deservedly won the game. If he can’t see the obvious, how is he meant to tackle the complicated issues?

He is hopelessly out of his depth. Yet when you listen to the pro-Ibrox commentariat or read the fans’ views, you realise he isn’t even the biggest problem at that club. Their biggest problem is the permanent shadow of Celtic looming over them, influencing every decision they make. This is a perfect example of that.

Any club with genuine championship aspirations, any club with a board that wasn’t constantly looking over the fence, would have made this decision before now. It should have been independent of results against Celtic and focused solely on the gap at the top of the table. If they really are waiting to see what happens in one game at their home ground before deciding, then the banter years are far from over.

Because that’s a club waiting for Celtic’s permission to make a decision that will define its future. If this manager’s survival hinges on a single game against us, they are too obsessed with Celtic to ever be more than they are now.

Share this article

James Forrest has been the editor of The CelticBlog for 13 years. Prior to that, he was the editor of several digital magazines on subjects as diverse as Scottish music, true crime, politics and football. He ran the Scottish football site On Fields of Green and, during the independence referendum, the Scottish politics site Comment Isn't Free. He's the author of one novel, one book of short stories and one novella. He lives in Glasgow.

5 comments

  • JimBhoyback says:

    !00% on the money James, expect statement Friday next week.

    He is deflecting his targets when he needs to. After all the league is a competition and how you can write off who is leading that competition when you are next best is beyond me.

    He is improving nothing, The Spurs win and the draw with Celtic combined set the ‘improving’ narrative and only bought him a little time.

    In saying that it will be interesting to see their result tomorrow, regardless he should get the Celtic game.

    This season has been a mare for him but he now talks only about the past 2 months, moving the dial as he needs to.

    Who would want the job after him, it certainly won’t be a top name knowing the finances and the job that needs done there.

    McInnes is hardly setting the heather on fire at Killie.

  • Rio 67 says:

    Good analysis James,

    But can they afford the compensation to sack him AND give money to a new incoming manager for January window?

    I don’t think they can afford either never mind both to be honest,

    When he gets sacked they will most likely promote someone like that goon Alex Rae to save some pennies

    • Clachnacuddin and the Hoops says:

      If it was a League for Thuggery orva League for ugliness then Alex Rae would win it by the length and breadth of his beloved Britain year in year out !!!

  • davidnewton1888@gmail.com says:

    As their overlords and superiors it’s only natural for us to determine when their managers come and go.
    Brendan Rogers is not only Celtic manager and head coach, but he also heads up HR at castle grey skull. And like the facepainter he receives no wages.
    Despite them selecting which officials not only refereed on the pitch and now also off the pitch in secluded dark rooms, they’re still closer to the bottom 4 than the league leaders, Scottish champions, and recent league Cup winners.

    It’s the hope that kills them, long live the hope ??

Comments are closed.

×