Articles & Features

Celtic has opened the transfer window by delivering another hammer blow to Ibrox.

|
Image for Celtic has opened the transfer window by delivering another hammer blow to Ibrox.

News today that Celtic is on the brink of selling Alexandro Bernabei and getting around $7 million (about £5 million) for the guy. It’s incredible. That means we’re going to post a modest profit on a player who has barely featured over the last couple of years. And this comes at a time when the Ibrox club is desperately trying to conduct a fire sale to scrape together a modest January transfer budget.

There are so many ways in which we are miles ahead of them, and this is yet another example. The fact that we stand to bring in so much cash for a player who is miles off making our first-team squad must make them absolutely sick. They keep talking about adopting a transfer strategy similar to ours, but they are light-years away from being able to do what we now do regularly.

Almost everything we do these days delivers some sort of seismic shock to them, and this is a particularly fine example. We’re not even thinking about them here—we’re just doing what’s in our own best interests—but it casts a huge shadow over their club all the same. Because we know they measure themselves against our standards, even though they never live up to them.

Bernabei was one of the early Mark Lawwell signings, and we should have known then that things might unravel a bit because he never looked as though he belonged in the Scottish Premiership. I’ve always had an issue with signing players from South and Central America, as very few of those deals have ever worked out for us. Asia, as it turns out, has been a much better hunting ground for players, and North America certainly shows great potential too.

Still, it’s obvious that Bernabei isn’t a bad footballer—he simply wasn’t suited either to Scottish football or Celtic’s style of play. If he was a bad footballer, we wouldn’t be getting anything for him. Let’s be honest about that. Our people know what they’re doing. Even Mark Lawwell is not a complete fool; he has an eye for a player, just not necessarily an eye for a player that our manager can use. And that’s why you don’t let these people build teams—they don’t know how to do it.

It amazes me how frequently we do this. We buy a player for a couple of million pounds, it doesn’t work out, and yet we’re able to move him on for even more money. That takes real skill and talent. Credit has to go to the people behind the scenes at our club who negotiate these deals—they’re exceptionally good at what they do. That’s why we can get value for players when the club across the city cannot.

Don’t underestimate the trust factor either.

Clubs believe in what Celtic does. They’ve seen how well we develop players, our good eye for spotting talent, and how players we’ve sold often move on again for even bigger fees, generating fantastic profits for everyone involved. There’s a general view out there that we know what we’re doing when it comes to this stuff.

Contrast this with Nathan Patterson, who signed for Everton for big money after a lot of hysterical hype from the Scottish media. That hype was never justified in my view, and he has been a huge flop. He’s now likely to be available for next to nothing in this window, which is why there are so many stories that the Ibrox club wants to try to bring him back. Personally, I hope they do—it wouldn’t progress them one millimetre.

We are also in negotiations, of course, to sell Luis Palma, and probably a couple more players. Thiago Holm is set to go out on loan, giving us a real chance to recoup the money we paid for him if he does well in the U.S. And I genuinely hope he does well over there. These moves mark the final stages of rebuilding the squad the manager inherited. So far, the signings we’ve made under him have been excellent, and if we can maintain that standard, we’ll be in great shape next season to compete in the Champions League and defend our trophies.

Across town, they also have a squad to rebuild. But the way we’ve managed to rebuild ours over the last couple of years has been by consistently balancing spending with sales. Ange Postecoglou’s first two windows were funded by the sales of Edouard and Ajer. Brendan Rodgers’ most recent transfer window, similarly, was built on the sale of Matt O’Riley. The books have always balanced—and it’s served us well.

Beyond the Bernabei sale and the possible departures of Luis Palma and others, we may finally see the sell-on clause we’ve been waiting for from Jeremie Frimpong’s move. That would add even more to our cash reserves, leaving us well-positioned to spend big in January if needed.

This is a solid start to the January window because, as we know, bringing players in often requires moving players out. We don’t want to overinflate the squad. UEFA regulations are something we need to monitor carefully, and I’m sure everyone at Celtic is doing exactly that. We can’t afford to test those limits, so it’s crucial to keep the squad size manageable while maintaining quality.

Having players like Palma in the squad without contributing, or guys like Holm and Bernabei hanging around the training ground as drains on resources, simply isn’t sustainable. These players edge us closer to that line, and it’s clear they need to move on.

Whether this will be a revenue-neutral window remains to be seen, but it’s certainly shaping up to be one where we don’t do any significant damage to the bank balance. That’s great news because we have the flexibility to spend a little if needed while still keeping everything in order. If we can balance the books and emerge from January with a stronger squad, that’s the ideal outcome.

On the other side of Glasgow, things look grim.

They have no major saleable assets they can cash in on to fund their rebuild. While we get stronger, they remain static—if they’re lucky. This disparity in positions between the two clubs is stark, and it highlights why this is such a promising start to the January window for us, and such a dire one for them.

Our fifth podcast episode, The Back Of The Net, is out. Please like, share and enjoy.

Share this article

James Forrest has been the editor of The CelticBlog for 13 years. Prior to that, he was the editor of several digital magazines on subjects as diverse as Scottish music, true crime, politics and football. He ran the Scottish football site On Fields of Green and, during the independence referendum, the Scottish politics site Comment Isn't Free. He's the author of one novel, one book of short stories and one novella. He lives in Glasgow.

5 comments

  • Johnny Green says:

    We have gotten lucky with Bernbei for he should never have been signed in the first place. Not because of him being South American, but because as a defender he is vertically challenged, and at 5′-7″ he is the proverbial smout. Same as Greg Taylor, a short man who is worse than a man short. I do hope Celtic have learned a lesson and start buying full backs with the right skillset, but who are tall enough to win aerial duels when required to do so, particularly at corners and set pieces.

    Bernabei was just a mistake that we got away with.

  • TonyB says:

    Ahh Mark Lawwell. Got the job by nepotism, (which is motivated by entitlement,please note Mr Brennan on CQN), and rightly got binned for his uselessness, finally albeit accidentally, got something right.

    Broken clock theory.

    Time for his old man to push off as well.

    • Clachnacuddin and the Hoops says:

      I’m not so bothered by ‘daddy’ nowadays Tony as long as he leaves Brendan in full charge of football operations…

      Which going by St. Brendan’s comments the other day is very much the case…

      ‘Sonny’ (Lawwell) though was an unmitigated DISASTER in his tenure at Celtic FC !

  • JimBhoyback says:

    Wouldn’t be surprised to see Butland go, they could get £2-3m for him I suppose.

    They are trying their best to lose Dessers, who would be a better player in a better team but nearly 30 commanding a big sal, so I couldn’t see them make any more that £1m on him max.

    Supposed to have other players linked with other teams but I doubt they will move many on tbh. No player is going to move to receive a pay cut when they can ride out their contract and move for free on a good deal.

    Rangers could incetivise some deals though, this would be their only options for most moves and hence would eat into any profit. Of course they will have a rangers narrative in the media suggesting they were bringing in jillions with sparkly add on bits.

    Mon the Hoops… 2 nil today.

  • JT says:

    You could say the same about Kieran Tierney. Was he not sold for lots of money and is now available for next to nothing.

Comments are closed.

×