Articles & Features

Adam Idah continues to grow as a player. Celtic will reap the benefits of that.

|
Image for Adam Idah continues to grow as a player. Celtic will reap the benefits of that.

I thought that Adam Idah’s comments in the aftermath of the Irish game last night were absolutely spot on.

This is a guy who’s had to endure an almost unbelievable level of criticism for his performances for both Celtic and Ireland. But this is a player who is coming into his own, little by little, bit by bit, and proving what a talent he is.

Idah has got 14 goals this season in a Celtic shirt. That’s actually a very decent return for a striker who’s just making his name—especially one who hasn’t been a first-choice player for the club. He is capable, though, and we all know it.

He is capable of stepping up and doing a job for us.

The only reason we don’t see more of him in the team is the outstanding performances of Daizen Maeda since Kyogo left in January.

He doesn’t have to carry the heavyweight burden of that transfer fee. That weight was never his to carry. It’s not his cross to bear.

He’s not the one who paid the £9 million—our board of directors did. And they did so because the manager finally forced their hand on it. They would have dragged their feet for even more months, and the price we paid would have been even higher had we left it until the last week of the window before trying to get the business done.

Because the board of directors were forced to pay more for Idah than we would have if we’d just negotiated in good faith and got him at the start of the window—as everyone was urging us to do—he now has to carry that transfer fee around with him. That’s not fair to the player, nor does it justify the criticism that he’s not worth it.

Adam’s finest hour in a Celtic shirt came with his cup final goal last season against the Ibrox club. That proves he can play on the big stage, in the big games, when it matters. A last-minute winner in a Glasgow derby and a cup final—you cannot ask for more complete verification that a player has what it takes than that.

But I actually think his finest performance, by a considerable distance, was the one he put in south of the border against Aston Villa in the Champions League.

That night, as far as I’m concerned, we saw the £9 million footballer—a footballer who was worth that kind of money, a footballer who could justify that kind of transfer fee… not that he has to.

That night, he looked like a Premiership-level footballer. That’s two goals in the Champions League against a top team. He got three overall in the competition, which is a very decent return for the second-string striker.

He’s got enough goals this season to make it his most successful one in his career so far. He’s 24 years old and has already scored more goals for Celtic in one and a half campaigns than he did during his entire time at Norwich. This is a guy who is getting better and better, and now he’s started to strut his stuff on the national stage. He now has five international goals for Ireland, and there will be more.

I can’t ask the media to get off this guy’s back. They won’t. But I would ask some of our fans to try and show the boy some support.

He’s going to have to be a very big player for us next season, and he is perfectly capable of doing so. He didn’t just have a pop at his critics last night; he also said that Brendan Rodgers has restored his love for football. That’s a player talking who’s had a very tough time of it at his former club.

Before this season ends, I expect him to hit 20 goals.

There are enough games left for him to get there, and if he does, I trust that some of the people who have been criticising him have the good grace to admit that they were wrong.

We are seeing the emergence of a very big player for us.

If it’s taken longer than some people would have liked, I should think they’d benefit from being a bit more patient in future.

Share this article

James Forrest has been the editor of The CelticBlog for 13 years. Prior to that, he was the editor of several digital magazines on subjects as diverse as Scottish music, true crime, politics and football. He ran the Scottish football site On Fields of Green and, during the independence referendum, the Scottish politics site Comment Isn't Free. He's the author of one novel, one book of short stories and one novella. He lives in Glasgow.

3 comments

  • woodyiom says:

    Sorry James but I just don’t see it. The fee is not his fault I agree and no-one should be using it as a stick to beat him with BUT using the argument that he’s got a decent return for a second string striker is the wrong way round – he’s the second string striker BECAUSE he’s only got a decent return. Brendan was forced into playing Maeda in the middle because Adam wasn’t scoring when he was starting striker following Kyogo’s transfer.

    His first touch is poor meaning he isn’t able to hold the ball in and bring other players in to the game so he’s not a target man like Sutton or BBJ were and we don’t ping crosses in the box early enough to utilise his height. He does make some really good runs at times but a lot of them he’s offside as he doesn’t work hard enough to get back onside before starting them.

    For me he’s more of an impact substitute (just as he was in the Cup Final and as he was last night for Ireland) but whether we paid £9million or could have got him for ca. £6million is irrelevant – we should be getting a far more complete striker at 24years old (compare him with Dembele, Edouard etc – I don’t see him ever hitting their sort of numbers). I truly hope I’m wrong (and will happily be the first on here to admit I was) but I don’t think he’s got enough to be be our main striker.

  • Clachnacuddin and the Hoops says:

    He brings something different…

    Hopefully beats Igamane in the scoring charts or we’ll never hear the fuckin end of it !

  • micmac says:

    Idah is definitely a work in progress, can’t make my mind up about him, he shows glimpses of a natural striker and I think we could see the best of him next season. Time will tell.

Comments are closed.

×