Articles

Celtic must extend the invitation for the Palestinian nation team.

|
Image for Celtic must extend the invitation for the Palestinian nation team.
Photo by ANP via Getty Images

Yesterday, one of those stories broke that is so multifaceted, I thought it might take a couple of articles to get through all the various elements and aspects of it.

But in truth, this is a very simple article to write because the concept itself is so clear and obvious—such a no-brainer—that any attempt to complicate it only plays into the hands of people who would try to put obstacles in the way.

In my view, those people should not be part of the discussion at all.

The story that broke yesterday was the one about the Palestinian national team’s head coach saying that he would love it if they played a glamour friendly against Celtic. Now, we play glamour friendlies all the time, but this would be on a whole other level.

This would be in another planetary solar system of positivity, good publicity, and growing the global brand. You want to extend Celtic’s reach beyond these borders? This is one way to do it—and a big way at that. A very big way indeed.

It’s a good thing our club didn’t specify which of the banners put up at games recently they had the biggest issue with, because if they’d said the anti-Israel banner, this idea would have been dead in the water before it even got off the ground.

I’m not saying you have to be anti-Israel to be pro-Palestinian. There are plenty of people across the world who manage to see both the Israeli and the Palestinian perspectives at the same time. I myself understand that Israel has security needs, and that those needs have to be met, whilst also believing that what they’re doing in Palestine is an unconscionable crime.

But our club came very close to taking a position it is desperately trying not to take.

That’s why I think there could be some resistance to the idea of playing against the Palestinian national team—because there are members of our board who wouldn’t want to rock the boat, who wouldn’t want to promote the Palestinian cause too much, even though that ship has sailed and our club is irrevocably connected to it, whether they like it or not.

Our supporters would flock to such a game. Fundraising would go through the roof. It would raise enormous sums of money for the cause of the Palestinian people—a just cause, let’s not forget. Their main cities have been smashed beyond recognition, and they are still being preyed upon by vultures all over the world.

Like Trump, who wants to turn Gaza into his own private resort.

And to hell with what those people think or want or need.

It would send a clear message to the world about which side we are on—the side of oppressed people and their hopes for their nation to grow and stand tall. About basic human dignity. About basic human rights.

If this is really on offer—and it clearly is—we have to take it. We must do this. There is an imperative to do this. There are a million and one reasons to do it. I can’t think of a single reason not to.

Invite them to Celtic Park so we can have the biggest possible crowd at the game. Watch as all of Scottish football—save for a handful, and we know which handful—rallies to be part of it. We’ll see how many clubs send delegations. We’ll see how many wish them well. We’ll see how many people throughout this land—parliamentarians, writers, academics, people in the arts—send their best wishes to the Palestinian national team as it sets foot on these shores.

We can call it whatever we like. We can call it a promotion of peace. That, after all, is what we want in the region. It’s what everyone wants in the region. We can affirm that we believe in the United Nations Charter and the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination. They are already a recognised country at the UN, even if they are not yet a full member. But numerous European nations and countries around the world have already granted them full diplomatic recognition and status.

And these are the reasons to do it simply if you want to look good to the rest of the world. If you want to come across as a progressive, open club, which takes an active interest in the goings-on in the wider world.

But there are financial reasons to do it too. There are reasons beyond being good little boys and girls on the world stage. You want to grow Celtic’s footprint across parts of the world where everyone watches the game and wants to wear an English Premier League kit? Forget about that; we can make a whole generation want to follow nothing but Celtic.

I cannot think of a single reason—not one—why this is not a good idea.

Sure, there are complicated politics involved. But how and where does that impact us? So the Daily Telegraph won’t like it. Who gives a shit what the Daily Telegraph likes and doesn’t like? They don’t like us anyway.

They’re not going to be sending their reporters to write nice things about us, no matter what we do. They know who we are. They know what we are. Their closed little minds are already made up.

There’s not going to be any big outcry from the Jewish lobby either. And I can say that with complete confidence. The Palestinian cause is supported by plenty of Jewish people. If the Palestinian cause didn’t have a core body of support within Israel itself—within its Jewish population—that cause would have been extinguished a long time ago.

If it wasn’t for Jewish academics, politicians, writers, and broadcasters all across the world—determined to point out to the country they love what its limitations are, where it has gone wrong, and how it has betrayed some of its most fundamental founding principles in treating the Palestinians the way their forefathers and forebears were treated all across the world, throughout recorded history, but especially here in Europe—then the Palestinian cause would not have some of its loudest voices now.

Because they are some of its loudest voices and greatest advocates.

Where is the downside? Where is the opposition going to come from—the meaningful opposition? Who’s going to stand up and say this is wrong? Who’s going to stand up and say we shouldn’t be doing this and give a coherent reason why?

A coherent reason. Not just scumbags on the fringes hoping they can say something absolutely scandalous and bigoted and that it chimes with people across Scotland. Of course, it will chime with some, but not with enough people.

Because most people can see who’s right and who’s wrong here.

The political class will welcome it, I assure you.

Much of liberal Scotland will applaud it to the heavens. It may draw some minor protests. I’m sure Scottish Protestants Against Discrimination can find some reason not to like it, even though it’s got nothing to do with them. I’m sure they’ll find some way to tie it into the Grand Conspiracy Of The Unseen Fenian hand. I care not.

Tell me why this isn’t something we should embrace.

Tell me where it goes against our club’s cultural ethos.

We’re not making an anti-Israeli point. We’re not making some anti-Semite point—although we will certainly be accused of that by the brainless and by those seeking to score a few cheap and nasty points.

But it’s none of those things. This is a statement that says we recognise the rights and the plight of the Palestinian people. That we have sympathy for the place they find themselves in and the circumstances they’re in.

And respect for their courage and strength in the face of it.

There’s no statement in there about Israeli government policy.

It’s got nothing to do with Israeli government policy.

I defy anyone to say that playing the Palestinian national team at Celtic Park would make some statement on Israeli government policy. But so what if it did? Faced with this opportunity, are we honestly going to say as a club that we have a problem with that? Are we honestly going to say that, as an institution, it’s none of our concern?

This is more than just a national team coach making a suggestion or a request. This is, in its own way, either a metaphorical cry for help or a call to arms.

They need support from around the world. And that support cannot be invisible.

It has to be upfront and clear. Are we really going to say no? Are we going to turn our faces away?

Don’t they read their Bible? The Good Samaritan?

Do we really want to pass by on the other side, or are we going to do what’s morally right?

They’ve extended the invitation, but what they’re really doing is asking for one. And we must not let them down. If there was ever an idea whose time has come, and which would be supported right across our fan base, it is this one.

And I hope we have the courage and integrity to make it real.

(NP | Hollandse Hoogte | BART STOUTJESDIJK Photo by ANP via Getty Images)

Our latest podcast, Hampden Here We Come, is up now.

Share this article

James Forrest has been the editor of The CelticBlog for 13 years. Prior to that, he was the editor of several digital magazines on subjects as diverse as Scottish music, true crime, politics and football. He ran the Scottish football site On Fields of Green and, during the independence referendum, the Scottish politics site Comment Isn't Free. He's the author of one novel, one book of short stories and one novella. He lives in Glasgow.

12 comments

  • Clachnacuddin and the Hoops says:

    Wouldn’t know enough about this conflict to hugely comment…

    But the first bastard on the anti Celtic blower and on to ‘Daddy’ and ‘Lucan’ will be that Gregory Campbell the MP for East Derry in The Island of Ireland…

    If it pisses him off then fuckin do it Celtic !!!

    The SDLP were selfish cunt’s attempting to gain this seat knowing they had not a fuckin snowballs chance in hell of winning yet Cara Hunter took 5,260 votes of which if 198 had gone to Kathleen McGurk of Sinn Fein that cretin Campbell would have been ousted and never again be able to lie and besmirch the name of Celtic FC in The Houses of Parliament ever again…

    When you see the pacts between The DUP and The UUP not to stand in Fermanagh & South Tyrone it makes you fuckin sick to the stomach what went on up there in East Derry…

    Black burning shame on a The SDLP for standing in East Derry in 2024 !

  • ThunbergsNooNoo says:

    I’d definitely turn up and show support for this.
    With fekin bells on!

  • Loginagain says:

    James, I totally disagree with your post/comments. why oh why would you want to raise money for a murdering bunch of terrorists? because that where the money would go just like all the billions of £/$ donated to Gaza over the years, into the hands of the terrorist
    leaders. who are billionairs because of their theft. plus money used to build terror tunnels, instead of investing in growing Gaza. Gaza was thriving until Israel pulled out and withdrew from Gaza. Lets not forget the Rapes, murders, beheading and burning alive children and kidnapping of defenceless Israeli citizens. Hundreds of Gazan citezens also crossed the border and joined in with whese attrocities. Thousands of them lined the streets to beat the Israeli hostages dead or alive with sticks. not forgetting the treatment of the hostages, held in cages beaten, tortured, starved, just for the sake of it.
    The Mother Bibi and her two young babies who were alive a week before the hostages were due to be released. who were suddenly handed over dead. they had been strangled and then stoned to make it look like the had been killed by Israeli bombs.
    You should maybe listen to the numerous Journalist from around the world who have seen the video footage of the atrocities carried out by Hamas. Would you have advocated Celtic playing the German national team to raise funds for the German citizens during thr second world war? another point before and since the conflict thousands of Gazan’s have been treated in Israeli hospitals. even Yahya Sinwar’s sister was treated and cured of a brain tumour. How did he repay Israel? by ordering the murderous assault on the 7/10/23 against families and music festival goers of different nationalities. so for me your suggestion is a big NO.

    • ThunbergsNooNoo says:

      Have you just copied and pasted a BBC News script? Cmon, own up. Fox News script? Ye have haven’t you. Bless!

    • terry the tim says:

      Enjoy our traditions,our history and our club but stay away from politics in football.
      There are plenty of protest groups if you want to join one.

  • DannyGal says:

    It’s Palestine we’re talking about, not Hamas!

  • Wee Jock says:

    Not much more to say on this James as you’ve covered it all, but why not have two matches, a men’s and a women’s with the funds from the latter specifically directed to Palestinian womens NGOs.

  • JimmyR says:

    I think it is a great idea. Bill the match as a fundraiser to rebuild Gaza after the horrendous destruction. It could turn out to be the first of a chain of fundraisers around Europe. Just as Glasgow paved the way by awarding Nelson Mandela “Freedom of the City.” Other cities world wide followed suit and it reflected wonderfully on our city when Nelson arrived to receive the freedom not just of Glasgow but of 9 other UK cities and regions. Support the peace. Support the rebuild. Only cretins would find a way of arguing against that.

  • centenerydouble71 says:

    When Nelson Mandela was made A Freeman of th City of Glasgow, we heard exactly the same kind of naysayers protesting against the idea, and for much the same “reasons.” From Glasgow being the first, the idea rapidly spread; who was right?

  • Robbie says:

    Jewish (and Irish Catholic!) Celtic supporter here. Zero issue with the Palestinian National Football Team coming to Paradise to play a match. I think it would be class! What is a complete fantasy of mine but would be amazing to see is if both the Israeli and Palestinian teams came to play in order to raise funds and help those in need both in Palestine as well as hostage families of poverty in Israel. I’m firmly centrist in terms of wanting to see peace and explore empathy from the hurt both sides have done to each other over the last century. Even in Ireland I find myself as a Nationalist who wants to reach out and empathize with Unionists or Loyalists on the other side and continue to advocate for peace even if I disagree with some of their politics.

  • SaigonCSC says:

    No, sorry, Celtic should not extend this invitation, James, and I do not want to see this happening at all.

    I will explain why, without even getting started on the optics, logistics and security for such a game.

    As everyone knows, politics is often intertwined with our club and football and general, but we are a football club first and foremost. I would rather we focus on our sporting goals than politically symbolic gestures, regardless of the cause, and especially a hugely charged and divisive one such as what’s going on over there.

    We are a club open to all and many fans don’t want to feel pressured into taking stances on wider issues. We are not a platform for activism. For me personally, Celtic is, and always has been, an escape from all the war, division and general negativity that we are constantly blasted with on a daily basis from the media.

    I think the cons of getting ourselves needlessly involved in a Middle East nightmare vastly outweigh any potential pros. Also, where do we draw the line and how do we decide who warrants gestures and at what scale…Should we start flying flags for the Uyghurs in China, tifos for the Rohingya’s in Myanmar, banners showing solidarity for Ethiopian Tigrayans, have a solidarity game v Yemen, hand out leaflets for Iraqi Yazidi’s, do a collection for South Sudan, send food and medicine to Venezuela, make a wee song for Syrians?

    And for those reasons “I’m out” as they say.

Comments are closed.

×