What is it with our media and the Ibrox fan groups that they don’t understand very simple concepts?
Let me tell you what simple concept I have in mind—the glaringly obvious fact that the alleged new investors do not have the money the media is pretending they do.
You see this constantly in reports about the Leeds chairman and the healthcare guy. The media always talks about how much the 49ers are worth as a brand or how much money this guy’s healthcare company handles in premiums.
Both the Ibrox fan media and the mainstream press push this narrative as if that cash is just sitting in the personal bank accounts of the two figures most centrally linked to the deal.
But neither of these guys is personally worth billions. The companies they represent may be valued in the billions on paper—they at least superficially deal in numbers that start with a ‘B’—but it is grossly misleading, at best, to suggest that these funds are readily available to those individuals. That is simply not the case.
I saw one Ibrox fan site attempt an analysis of how wealthy these people are compared to Dermot Desmond. When it came to Desmond, they correctly used his personal wealth as the barometer—he’s said to be worth around £2 billion. But then they claimed these new guys “dwarf” Desmond because the 49ers are worth around £6 billion and ParetoHealth has premiums exceeding £8 billion.
Now, I don’t know if these people are just financially illiterate, stupid, or if they simply believe everything they’re told by the Daily Record, but none of that money belongs to the individuals in question.
They’re comparing apples and oranges. Desmond has personal wealth. These guys represent companies with wealth on paper. That has nothing to do with how much money they personally have in the bank or can spend at will.
You get the impression that every time Keith Jackson writes about this, his own eyes glaze over, and he starts believing in the nonsense coming out of his own pen.
Because when you put it the way they do—when you throw around these big numbers—it starts to sound like fantasy land. That’s when you get people believing in 30 or 40 million pound transfer war chests in a summer window, as if that money is just sitting there ready to be spent.
And I genuinely don’t know if Jackson and his colleagues are unaware that this is nonsense or if they are deliberately leading the Ibrox support up the garden path. Either scenario is entirely plausible.
I don’t see how this ends well for their fans. The more this myth gets pushed, the more they expect billionaire owners with tens—if not hundreds—of millions available to splash out of their own pockets. And the more ridiculous it’s all going to look when reality finally bites, and they realise that isn’t happening.
Do you think anyone in the media will accept responsibility for pushing this narrative? Of course not. Instead, they’ll turn on the new board for behaving exactly like the old one. They’ll manufacture a scandal, whip up discontent, and push for another round of sackings and upheaval. And the press, which built up all these ridiculous expectations in the first place, will be right there for the ride.
It’s exactly what happened with the new CEO, Patrick Stewart.
When he first sat down with the media and didn’t give them the usual happy-go-lucky nonsense—when he actually had the audacity to suggest there would be tough times ahead—they turned on him instantly. It was as if he’d broken promises he never even made. And that’s precisely what they’re doing here.
They are making promises on behalf of these investors.
These new guys haven’t said a single word. The media is doing all the talking for them.
Now, in some ways, that’s the fault of those trying to push through this takeover. They haven’t got in front of the story. And yet, in other ways, I completely understand why they haven’t. They’re trying to operate professionally behind the scenes. They’re dealing with due diligence, legal matters, and securing 51% of the shares. They, at least, know what their priorities should be.
But there should be some pushback against the wild expectations being whipped up by the Scottish sporting press. Because if these guys do get their feet under the table, they will regret not managing those expectations when they had the chance.
The speculation, and that’s exactly what it is, has become quite tiresome and as you rightly say James, there are a lot of dominoes to fall before anything transpires, if it ever does. I am sincerely hoping that it goes ahead, for it will be very interesting to see what happens and just how much of a grip the huns will lose on their own club as it is taken over by these American speculators. At the very least it will take years to turn things around and it will no longer be a Scottish institution as such (aka Carstairs). ‘Be careful what you wish for’ is not part of the huns philosopy and, prompted by greed and envy, they are stumbling blindly into a very unsure and possibly a very unstable future.
Go for it Williams, we are 100% behind you…..but miles in front.
I doubt Desmond has 2bn in his Bank of Ireland current account, so that’ll be a paper fortune until it can be liquidated as well.
Think you missed the point. £2b represents Desmond personal wealth which he can spend as he so wishes. The other numbers quoted are not the personal wealth of the named individuals and not their money to spend.
They truly are desperate – We all share the pubs at this bit and they are like a childlike mind that thinks they will win the Euromillions on Tuesday then when it doesn’t happen they just shrug off the disappointment and think all is well and they’ll get it on Friday…
They we be more to be pitied than to be scorned if they weren’t who they are but fuckin scorned they shall be by me !
What they, their fans and the media fail to acknowledge or understand, is not so much the wealth of the 49ers, but the fact that their approach to investing in “sleeping giants” of sport has never been about investing masses of funds into recruitment, but in changing that mindset entirely into a model that’s sustainable over time. They should be welcoming that approach with open arms, but instead they blindly see the proposed takeover as another version of the model that started with EBT’s and continued with a horrendous business model based on loans and rich benefactors throwing money at short term goals. That’s exactly the approach that the 49ers are determined to change in their aim for a long term solution. Why they fail to see that with so much cast iron evidence in front of their eyes is completely baffling to me, an absolute mystery in fact.
The lure of ‘ other peeppos money’ is too enticing a prop for them. It absolves them of their own responsibility to get the Klub on a level sustainable footing which takes time, effort and commitment as well money.
These other ‘People’ on the other hand don’t share the ‘ Entitled, Supremacist mind set of the fans. They are investors and they want a return on their investment and not just having to feed an incessantly, voracious money pit.
I hope it goes ahead because I think it will destroy the Klub. The Klan don’t have the patience for the ‘long haul’ approach. While the new owners will be setting a medium to long term plan for turning the Klub around the mob will not back it. They’ll want it ‘ALL’ and they’ll want it ‘NOW’ and they will not ‘pony up’ to fund the long road ahead.
Any ‘due diligence’ should factor in the psychological make up of the Customer Base.
This will be the crunch issue for their plans. Can we count on the fans support over the period of the project, the inevitable price hikes. Can we manage their expectations. Is the work necessary to get them on board worth our investment over the necessary timescales.
What level of resistance will there be and will it have the capacity to de-rail us?
I personally think the Yanks are trying to pull off more than they can handle. Despite yesterday’s on field reversal I don’t think the ‘ Banter Years’ are over quite yet. Bring it on.