I’m not going to sit here and pretend that I think John Brown is anything other than a goon. I’m not going to sit here and act like his comments on the Ibrox internal TV channel, commentating on the weekend’s game, weren’t beyond embarrassing.
I’m not going to sit here and defend John Brown — not in this lifetime, not ever. And I’m not going to sit here and claim that I don’t believe that if the SFA does investigate him, and finds him guilty of something, that he shouldn’t be punished, and that his club shouldn’t be punished too. Because I agree with all of that, and especially in light of their demented statement which came out earlier today.
I may cover that in more detail tomorrow.
But my acceptance that Brown should be punished — and would deserve to be punished — and my belief that, if there really is going to be a proper investigation, and if it’s serious, that he and his club should be held accountable… none of that has anything to do with what I’m about to write.
Because I think the very act of sanctioning him and the club for his comments would be an embarrassing incident in its own right. I don’t think it would represent anything other than a token gesture, because people in this game have done much, much worse and got away with it.
Let’s take just one example: Steven Gerrard.
He wasn’t even in the Ibrox dugout five minutes before he was spouting spurious allegations against all manner of people. Following his very first game in charge, he made comments that were severely critical — not only of the match officials, but of the SFA as a whole.
The suggestion that the organisation was biased against his club was so blatant that I was one of many who expected the axe to fall — and fall hard.
Nothing was ever done about it.
It wasn’t the first time an Ibrox manager had made such comments and, of course, it wouldn’t be the last. The club itself has specifically targeted certain officials — as good as called them corrupt — and even went further, speaking to their fan organisations and asking their fan blogs to put pressure on them.
I think those things are far greater breaches of the SFA and SPFL protocols than anything Brown said. But no-one ever paid the price for them.
We’re not even three weeks on from a match that was characterised by objects being thrown at our players and by a full 90-minute sectarian bigot-fest. A banner was unfurled during that game which was profoundly disturbing, and for which the club itself issued an aggressive and angry statement — against its own fans.
Everyone knows what happened that day was lamentable. Everyone knows it should have been punishable. But it never was, and it never will be.
These are the facts of the case, and they are undisputed.
So what is this really about?
They’re going to go after John Brown — who is every critical thing we’ve ever said about him or written about him on this blog and others. He is every bit as stupid, as backward, as close to the perfect parody of a redneck shit-kicker as you could hope to find. Because he said things that only confirm what we’ve always suspected — that the worms have been eating his brain for years?
Brown is a classic example of the West of Scotland bigot in all his gory glory. Keevins, that desperate excuse for a hack, once told a story — which I’m sure he thought was somehow endearing — about how Brown snarled at him for suggesting he eat a plate of green jelly at a function. I don’t know what picture Keevins was trying to paint of Brown, but it was a pretty awful one that emerged.
It was not a surprise either. Nobody even pretends not to know what John Brown is. Everyone knows exactly what he is. His comments were exactly the kind of comments you’d expect from that snarling eejit. So we’re punishing him for what? For being true to his nature? For being who — and what — he is?
Let me repeat what I said at the start: I have no issue with the idea that those comments crossed a line. I have no issue with the idea that they should be punished, and that the club should be punished too, since they employ him.
But it all has something of the squirrel about it, doesn’t it?
Something of the “look over there because we don’t want you looking over here” element. Because if the SFA and SPFL come down hard on this guy, maybe we’ll forget that the club itself has escaped sanction for the behaviour of its fans. Maybe we’ll forget that Vaclav Cerney got a slap on the wrist for spraying our supporters with water at our ground after they’d just scored in the last minute.
Nobody’s saying that Brown did nothing wrong.
But we’re entitled to ask why those who did far worse aren’t being investigated and weren’t sanctioned. We’re entitled to wonder how we’ve ended up in a place where crass, stupid, idiotic comments made on the club’s internal TV channel — to the club’s own fans — words that can do no real harm except to feed a paranoia that’s already rampant, are somehow seen as worse for football, and for Scotland, than all the other actions that have gone unpunished for as long as some of us can remember.
The truth is, Brown is an easy target. And it’s an easy sanction to apply. Put him on notice. Give him a warning. A slap on the wrist. A small fine. Something that can be brushed off. Something that does no damage.
It’s not going to spark a major outcry except from their club is foaming at the mouth over it, creating its own spectacle for the Americans.
But, unlike what they’ve alleged in their latest moronic communique, it’s not even going to distract from the front-page criticism being levelled at referees or our absolutely dire version of VAR — which they’ve been moaning about all weekend and will probably still be moaning about in 10 years. As though that one decision would’ve had momentous consequences had it gone the other way.
So, this isn’t even a deflection tactic from the SFA to stop people talking about that, because they know that’s hopeless — people are going to be talking about it, and rightly so, for a heck of a long time to come.
And whilst I think Ibrox’s reaction, and that in the media in general, has been typically hysterical and over the top, the central point — that our version of VAR is a cheap, low-rent joke — is pretty irrefutable.
And we’ve all said that ourselves.
So I ask again: what is this about? What’s the point? What’s the function it serves?
They are going to punish John Brown because he said a few choice words — stupid words, wrong words. He shouldn’t have said them. They shouldn’t have come out of his ignorant, blundering mouth.
But this is a stupid, ignorant person. What do you expect?
So punish him. Sure. Go ahead. Do it.
It’s certainly justified. It’s certainly reasonable. But don’t pretend this is the SFA getting serious. Don’t pretend it’s a crackdown, or that anyone there has suddenly grown a pair. Don’t pretend this is part of some coherent philosophy to remove this sort of poison from our game. Because it’s not.
It’s a token gesture. And that’s what makes it pathetic.
The sheer fkn laughable, nerve of brown, comin away with this. He comes from an era, where he knows how utterly entitled him and his team were. Ah think we should just all go back tae the ‘good old days’ eh ! Through decades, right up tae and beyond brown’s time, when bent officials would give the ibrox team every dodgy, bogus, decision with monotonous regularity without any real investigation and if our support, or club complained, just pull the trusted and reliable ‘paranoid’ card out. Which they always did. Sorted ! Now things have changed with var and decisions bein put under a lot more scrutiny, they’re no gettin everythin their own way and the ‘paranoid’ card used against us has become redundant, the reaction is showin spectacularly in itself. And of course, their super entitled support will lap this shit up. Ye couldnae mark his neck with a blowtorch.
Banger Brown said what he thinks, isn’t that what their tv channel pays him to do? If the SFA want to punish someone it should be the club and if the club choose to sack Brown that’s up to them. They hired him knowing what he is so if they think he’s right they should back him up. They won’t because they’re still pandering to the proposed new owners and trying to get away from the worst elements of their support although they’ll still take their money
My goodness – They’ll be a good few broken mobile phones in these Sevco supporters possessions after taking pics of that pure ugly old fuckin mugshot for sure !!!
This so called statement and his entitilment or sense of being so out of control now lends me to say that the fakeover is not there yet. The board , paddy for that matter really have no control over the base elements inside the club the statement is proof of that there are folk in that place who it appears do what they like and are throwbacks, to me its obvious we call it culture, its brown, ferguson, greig et al and the underlings throughout, i thought the yanks had cleared it out with only the brats left geez how wrong was I ?.
The SFA will do nothing as their terrified the takeover will fail and they’ll get the blame from the klanbase.
Empty the lot of the SFA sevco loving cowards.
Any fine for Brown he will wear as a badge of honour and will afford him the oxygen of publicity. An egregious horrible character.
Even a cheap version of VAR has revolutionised Scottish football, The Referees are being scrutinised like never before, the old cheating days are over. Bring on goal line technology, the more scrutiny the better, all we ever wanted was the correct decisions, all they ever wanted and got in the past were the decisions that favoured them. VAR isn’t perfect, but my goodness it has upset the Ibrox hordes who were so used to decisions by cheating refs going in their favour.
Good point indeed Micmac…
I’d say though that VAR is perfect it’s just the occasional cheat with a monitor that tries to brazenly raise their brass necks above the parapet that make it imperfect !
VAR interpretation is the problem and the stupid offside rule, that I hope is changing.
VAR rules should be simple, if it’s not “definite” it shouldn’t be a subjective call. The big toe offside rule is a joke. They should change that to clear daylight between players.
Squiggly line drawing has to be replaced with better tech and definitely goal line tech should be in play.
The weekend we could have seen a decision that stopped a club’s progress into European competition and that additional revenue stream. In theory it could costs a team the championship or a cup win. Is this what it is going to take before the message on VAR usage gets across. They hate it in the EPL also.
Either scrap it or make the rules more simple and the controllers more accountable to simplified rules, ie Don’t make it up.
The Scottish referees would love to see it scrapped, Beaton, Mclean and Dickinson with a few other of their pals could get back to awarding the Ibrox club penalties every other week. Two penalties this season must surely be an all time low for them.
Can’t see anything happening to him but just for the sheer pantomime I hope it does.
Brown is only allowed to hang around Ibrox because of the old adage “better to have him in the tent…etc.”.
The board are probably terrified of him.