7 thoughts on “As the last accounting day looms, Celtic needs to spend. Ibrox needs to sell.

  1. I’m sure the chartered accountants at the club and on the board will be aware of the tax laws and how to best protect Celtic’s money. Financial prudence is what they do after all.

  2. You can say with the same absolute surity that Sevco will always be cheats that if the boot was on the other foot that they would spend the whole fuckin lot for sure to stay ahead…

    The dead club did it year after year after year…

    It’s a sensible strategy getting the balance right of course…

    But £10.999 million going to a tramp like that Butchers Apron loving Labour one Reeves from Celtic is sickening…

    As it would be for Butchers Apron loving chancellors of Tories, Liberal Democrat’s And Reform ones as well in the interest of But hers Apron Political neturility !

  3. This board have tae spend now and strengthen. If they fail tae deliver, it’ll be an out and out scandal. Just for starters, our mid badly needs an enforcer. We need another striker and ah’ve seen nothin from Kenny that’s encouragin. If they stick with the squad we have with minimum addition, or neglect key positions that need attention, we’re askin for trouble. Every fkn season we go through this. Last season the signs were clearly there. Teams are realising how tae play us. Is this goin tae be another board gamble ?

  4. I really don’t understand what the Celtic board have been playing at the last few years when Celtic fc has made substantial profits every year . The board are supposed to be the serious money men ( accountants) .
    We are a 2 man building contractors myself and my old man ,every year we look at the books about 2 months before the end of the tax year if it looks like we have made a decent profit we will purchase a mixer or scaffold or a new truck if serious profits . You don’t spend the lot but you make sure you still have enough left to pay taxes and a small rainy day fund ,our accountant encourages us to do this.
    Why would celtic want to pay colossal tax bills ( must be 40% at least ) . Surely player purchases or infrastructure improvements makes more sense than giving HMRC millions more,e than you have to . ABSOLUTELY CRAZY.

  5. If Celtic bought a player this evening for £20m it wouldn’t move the needle on the profit for the year (either accounting or tax profit) nor on the amount of tax we would be required to pay. It would of course impact our ability to pay those taxes if we had spent £20m on a player.
    It’s too simple an analysis to make and requires a more detailed analysis of the profit and loss account before conclusions can be drawn.

  6. Hi James probably one the easiest article you have written all year. You wrote a very similar one in July 2024,and Aug 2023. Depressingly familiar about our penny wise pound foolish board who would rather give money to HMRC than spend the profits on reinvesting to make more profit which I thought was the purpose of businesses? Still on the upside we will never be accused of tax avoidance !

  7. James – as a Chartered Accountant of over 30years I can assure you we could spend £100m on one player today and it would not materially alter our profits (accounting or tax) – player acquisitions in essence affect our balance sheet only.

    Selling a player might well affect our tax as it may generate gain on sale which is taxable hence why we will wait until 1st July onwards to sell Khun etc as that profit will be banked in the 25-26 accounts and not result in the tax being due/payable until 1st April 2027.

    The issue re the cash balances being too large is that we are not generating the level of return we could do if they were invested elsewhere which is why the board should be considering returning some cash to shareholders if they have no intention on spending it – as a PLC they are obligated to ensure shareholders are getting maximum returns for their investment which currently they are not.

Comments are closed.