Articles & Features

It’s not the reaction of the Celtic fans that should worry Russell Martin.

|
Image for It’s not the reaction of the Celtic fans that should worry Russell Martin.

Yesterday, some in the media went on the offensive. This is their default response when they’ve been made to look foolish.

For weeks now, they were pushing determinedly the idea that Gerrard would be appointed as the Ibrox boss, and that he’d bring a slew of talent with him. Then it was Ancelotti who was supposedly going to bring all the talent.

All the while, the club was briefing certain people in the press – but not everyone – that they were most impressed with Russell Martin. Tom English gave the game away in a podcast last weekend.

Having been made to look flat-footed and foolish, and then having to recalibrate all their coverage to sell the idea that Russell Martin is an elite-level manager – although they had never mentioned him in that context before – they decided that it might be appropriate and smart to attack the Celtic fans for curtain-twitching and sniggering at the decision.

Let’s take the “curtain-twitching” first. The club across the city is obsessed with ours. Obsessed with copying everything we do, with supplanting us in any way they can. And when I say any way, the history proves they’re willing to burn rules, regulations, and even the law of the land if that’s what it takes. So it would be very foolish for us not to take an active interest in what’s going on over there.

It’s our default response to just about anything that happens across the city. We’ve grown used to seeing them trip over their own feet. I said in the piece yesterday that Martin might not be a disaster, and our club has to remain alert. But I’m also saying that his win record is not impressive. He talks very well, I’m sure. But talk is cheap. Fans want to see results on the pitch, and that’s easier said than done.

It’s also been pointed out by Celtic fan media outlets that the club has already started preparing their fans for a rough summer in terms of the budget.

Martin himself has gone on record saying he only expects one or two players in before the Champions League qualifiers, because he’s been told he has to see what he can get out of the current squad before he starts to dismantle it. This is nothing unexpected. This blog predicted exactly that.

But the media take on this is wholeheartedly dishonest.

And what else is new? I talked about them gaslighting the Ibrox fans yesterday morning – and that is self-evident. But I really don’t know who they’re trying to convince with some of these articles about how we should feel or react, or more to the point, how we shouldn’t react to the Russell Martin appointment.

We’re told we risk looking silly because he might turn out to be an Ange Postecoglou – an idea so ridiculous I’ve already taken several shots at it since it started doing the rounds.

There’s also a narrative doing the rounds that he might be another Brendan Rodgers, because Rodgers was at Swansea and his win ratio in the lower leagues wasn’t all that impressive. It was impressive enough, though, to get him the Liverpool job – one of the biggest in the country – and his work there was impressive enough that when it came time for us to hire a head coach, he was far and away the outstanding candidate.

Rodgers has been regarded as an elite-level coach for well over a decade. So again, this comparison doesn’t stand up to the slightest scrutiny.

I think these attempts to compare Martin to Rodgers and Ange – and whoever else’s name they can come up with – are in fact a form of gaslighting, as I mentioned earlier. It’s another attempt to warp the Ibrox fans’ perception of reality.

And the fact that some of them are going along with it is hardly surprising. They tend to go along with most of this stuff. That’s why I’m convinced those articles that mention the Celtic fans aren’t really intended for us at all.

Because if you actually look at some of the social media commentary on Russell Martin, it’s quite clear that Celtic fans are laughing more at the club, its supporters, and the media than they are at Martin himself.

Martin does provide his own level of entertainment – there’s no question about that – but most of us are being very wary of going over the top. We can see there’s an articulate, smart guy there, although, as I’ve said, that doesn’t necessarily make him a good football manager.

But as I wrote in the “killing kings” piece, you never underestimate the new man on the throne. Some of these people do surprise you.

Still, the real target audience for all those pieces yesterday – the ones allegedly aimed at us – were actually aimed at the Ibrox fans as a form of feel-good propaganda.

Because if you actually take the time to look, the most critical, the most vocal, the most scornful and contemptuous commentary on Russell Martin isn’t coming from us at all. It’s coming from the people he most needs on his side.

It’s coming from the Ibrox support themselves.

That’s dangerous to him. That’s why efforts are being made to find some silver lining in the appointment, to spin it as something other than what it is.

Because if he starts off with a significant body of his own support already against him and waiting for him to fail, any negative result is going to send much of that fanbase off the deep end almost immediately.

And that’s one hell of a lot of pressure to be carrying into your first campaign. That’s a hell of a burden to have on your shoulders.

Martin has famously talked about how he didn’t like the pressure at Ibrox when he was there as a player. That pressure is going to be fifty times greater now he’s in the dugout. He’s the man responsible for holding the club together and their fanbase has already shown it has no tolerance for anything that takes too long to show results.

Time is the one thing he’s not going to get.

Ange managed to win most of us over before a ball was even kicked. It helped that the home performances were outstanding, so even when the away form looked like it had fallen off a cliff, there was always an inkling that things were moving in the right direction. That’s why Ange got through that tricky initial spell.

That’s why the fans kept faith with him, even though we didn’t start particularly well – either in Europe or domestically.

Because the home games were stellar, there was a clear direction of travel, and it was the right one. Fans had come on board. We liked Ange. We liked the cut of his jib and the clear progress toward a whole new way of playing.

If Martin has a similar start to the one Ange had, he’s finished before the season’s even properly underway. None of that goodwill exists for him. And those who understand that know exactly why it’s worrying.

That’s why they’re pushing this line that it’s Celtic fans who need to be careful, Celtic fans who should be wary.

They want to build this guy up as some unknown quantity, as if we don’t have his record right there to look at. As I said the other day, one of the things that sold me on Ange was when I looked beyond the surface of his record. He’d done incredible things. He’d won trophies everywhere he’d been. When you put that in context, you could see the man’s quality.

Martin has never won an honour as a manager. That’s where the comparison completely collapses.

Ange arrived at Celtic an established boss with a high reputation within the game – maybe not yet within the commentary class, but certainly within the wider sport. And it was because we recognised that, that we gave him a chance, gave him the benefit of the doubt. So when the season started and the away form was as horrible as we all remember, nobody panicked. Nobody overreacted. Nobody turned on him.

We told ourselves: once he gets his players in, once they bed into the style, then we’ll really see a show. And we did – not just that season, but the one after it too.

Martin won’t get that time.

Start like Ange and his polling numbers will drop into the single digits. He will always be one disastrous result away from real pressure and calls for his head. He will have to do something substantial, and early, to change that perception. Now, maybe he will do it. But right now, the risk to him is very, very high.

And that risk doesn’t come from Celtic fans sneering at him. It comes from those in his own house. That’s where his problems lie already, and in trying to focus on our response to it the media is trying to make people forget that.

Share this article

James Forrest has been the editor of The CelticBlog for 13 years. Prior to that, he was the editor of several digital magazines on subjects as diverse as Scottish music, true crime, politics and football. He ran the Scottish football site On Fields of Green and, during the independence referendum, the Scottish politics site Comment Isn't Free. He's the author of one novel, one book of short stories and one novella. He lives in Glasgow.

14 comments

  • TonyB says:

    More Tofu anyone?

  • Kevcelt59 says:

    Theyre all over social media, now makin up all sorts of inaccurate stats about Brendan Rodgers. Just typifies their compulsive fixation, for twistin facts and history tae suit their agendas Ffs they’re even determined, in their own special way, tae make out Rod Stewart was once an ibrox fan. RS was NEVER an ibrox fan. He took part in charity games and wore their kit and thats the reality and where it ends. Tho of course, they’ll use pictures taken at the time tae ‘prove’ their claim. It all helps their warped idealisms.

    • Clachnacuddin and the Hoops says:

      Brendan has won 12 outta 14 at Celtic FC Kevcelt59…

      That’s all the stats that count but you won’t hear that from The Sevco Hun Hoards for sure…

      I’ve not been on Wallow Wallow for a lurk since The Cup Final but maybe tomorrow now the fortnight is up…

      That said Martin might be a possession based boss like Brendan but if Martin wants to beat him all he needs to do is take a leaf outta The Fergushun Book of tatcics as Rodgers cannot seem to cope with lump the ball and the high press at all sadly !

  • JimBhoyback says:

    Martin will most likely get the honeymoon boost were players get a lift for a while, normally happens. He has at least 2 other coaches coming in and a couple going so it’s adding to the cost base now. Add a couple of new players and likely a couple going for pennies and it’s not a great start.

    If Aberdeen can start and continue as they did last season then there may be more early competition.

    Celtic need to bring in some new quality players that is for sure especially if we lose any first team player. Unfortunately history with Brendan often means a lengthy period before we get players in.

    Martin may also have a directive to reduce wage bill that will mean some players forced out with little profit.

    In your fab earlier blog James on the takeover suggests rangers long term future looks fekd, it may take a couple of years for this to come to light for the ultra-dim gullibillies.

    I reckon it will take 10 years before we see a new consortium pay for control of assets that are under onerous contracts with the yanks who with the blessing of the old guard and the present klan can do what they want with the business. As we have stated many times, these guys want big profits and the assets, support contracts and the gullibility mentality will ensure they get that very easily.

    The whole scenario will unwind over time and it will not be cheap to regain assets and pay off those onerous yank companies who own rangers. Hundreds of millions for sure with big numbers being drawn out of rangers over time.

    The yanks will throw them a bone now and again and as we know the klan will use any positives to show they are competing with the champs, they may even sell some players for decent money (with add-ons when they reach mars with Elon). In the end it will all be futile as ownership of everything worth anything will be with hidden entities.

    First stage may show soon if they do not get into CL group stages. This may quicken the major austerity coming their way.

    • Clachnacuddin and the Hoops says:

      A good post JimBhoybsck – But Just a wee reminder that ‘Rangers’are dead of course !

  • JimBhoyback says:

    Celts need to break the mould and get their transfer business done early.

  • Dan says:

    Got to admire your persistence that Brendan is an elite manager. He’s not even close. After the woeful league cup final performance which we were very lucky to win on penalties, he had then three cracks at the worst Rangers team I can remember and he couldn’t change a thing, each performance exactly the same. To lose the Scottish cup final to that Aberdeen side was again a dismal result given the advantage he had. Rodgers is no where near Ange, never mind in the elite bracket.

  • micmac says:

    They already had an articulate smart guy who in one year took them to a Europa League Final and and managed them to win one of the 3 trophies they’ve won since they were founded 13 years ago. His name was Van Bronckhorst a well respected footballer and manager throughout Europe. This didn’t save him from being sacked by this embarrassment of a club, I think James that it is wrong to compare Spurs with this club, The Rangers {2012} even announced the sacking of a manager [Warburton} without telling him, he didn’t know until watching the Scottish News on the telly.
    Big Ange lost his first 3 away games, if Martin starts in that fashion he’ll find out what a bunch of entitled bitter people follow follow the Ibrox team.

    • terry the tim says:

      Some Celtic players will be examining their options before committing to Celtic for next season re Taylor,Khun, Hatate and Maeda.
      So it is difficult for Celtic to line up suitable replacements especially early doors.

  • DannyGal says:

    Will the board repeat recent pre-seasons and wait to see what money they bring in for one or two players before they commit to any signings? If so we the CL play-off could be on us with players still bedding in.

  • Johnny Green says:

    Who cares what the media are spouting to the huns, and who cares what their reaction is to their new regime. It’s early days and nothing will become clear until all the players are back in training and the first of the transfer dealings are getting done. Until then rumours will abound, but it will all surely come out in the wash. In the meantime we are in for a tedious couple of weeks of frivolous rumour mongering from the boys in the press.

    • Clachnacuddin and the Hoops says:

      Not me Johnny ! – I’ll only find out on here – Happy That James exposes The Scummy Bastards and their evil anti Celtic poison !!!

  • Gerry says:

    Again, I think it’s important to focus on our club rather than what may or may not unravel over in Sevcoville!

    Do we really care about their new majority shareholders, manager and what they may bring?

    Our focus should be on what our board and management team can and should be bringing to our club in this transfer window.

    Bottom line, that’s all that matters! We are the club that’s in a position of strength and have been for so many years.

    To let that slip would be beyond negligence and an affront to all of our support who willingly and positively support Celtic, financially and spiritually!

    Whether the stockpiling of cash is for a future renovation of our main stand ( which apparently is a shambles ) or other reasons, there should always be a mission to improve every facet of our team and club, whilst we can !

    I have no interest in Sevco, other than to see us constantly be more successful than them.
    If we go about our business, in the proper manner, then that should never change !

    My concerns are clear and tangible with our board, as we’ve seen so many negative transfer windows,
    Nevertheless, they have this chance to be shaken from their narcolepsy and ensure we shall always be stronger than all our domestic opponents, especially Sevco.

    The fixation should never be at them, only our business, and that it is carried out properly and positively! HH

  • eldraco says:

    Wait till the window closes and see how celtic level out in the pre season games.

    Let the rest fall as it may

Comments are closed.

×