ABERDEEN, SCOTLAND - MAY 14: Celtic's Johnny Kenny celebrates scoring to make it 4-1 during a William Hill Premieship match between Aberdeen and Celtic at Pittodrie Stadium, on May 14, 2025, in Aberdeen, Scotland. (Photo by Craig Williamson/SNS Group via Getty Images)
The other day, Johnny Kenny spoke to the media about his hopes of signing a new Celtic deal. The manager has expressed his own desire to see that happen, and now Kenny has confirmed that he wants to stay. That is a highly significant development because Celtic do see Kenny as a player for the future—and the only way that future was going to be realised was by getting him out on loan, having him play games, and come back a better, more rounded footballer.
Johnny Kenny is one of those guys who’s well past the point of featuring in the Lowland League. That level does him no good whatsoever. It’s frankly atrocious that we’ve had so many players waste so much time in that horror of an environment.
One of the clearest takeaways from the second half against Cork was how limited some of the young players looked—and it wasn’t down to a lack of talent, but a lack of proper development. The problem isn’t the players. The problem is where we’re asking them to play.
Kenny’s willingness to sign a new deal—and to trust Celtic, the manager, and the process—is refreshing. He’s not the first player in recent years to be offered those terms. A virtually identical deal was offered to Rocco Vata, who turned it down; to Daniel Kelly, who turned it down; and more recently, and regrettably, to Daniel Cummings—now at West Ham—who’s made a lot of noise since leaving, not all of it flattering to Celtic. But he too was offered the chance to sign a deal, be part of the first team squad, and have the club analyse the next step in his development.
Rightly or wrongly—and that’s a matter of hot debate, I understand—none of those three players trusted the club or the system. You could argue they had good reason. You could argue all of them have benefited from going elsewhere and playing regular football. But the fact is, had they signed those deals, they’d almost certainly have been sent out on loan and playing first team football anyway—but with a genuine shot at returning to Celtic Park and making it as pros.
Kenny does trust the system. He trusts the manager. He’s willing to take a chance that we’re serious when we say he has a future here.
The thing about Kenny is that he’s already seen the development pathway in action. He was sent out to Ireland for a season—to play regularly, to grow, to improve. And that’s exactly what he did. He played in Europe. He faced big teams, played against experienced players, and scored important goals. His development has been excellent. And if he’s not quite ready yet, that’s something we can fix easily by sending him back out on loan—as long as he intends to return.
It’s a well-known fact that Vata, Kelly and Cummings were all offered new Celtic contracts. Each was told they’d be joining the first team squad. Each was told the club would assess the right next step—loan or otherwise. They all knew the pattern. They all knew the plan. None of them wanted to stay. If Kenny does, then that is a very welcome change of pace.
None of those three were ready for regular first team football. That’s the truth. That’s the fact. None of them was ready to step up and play week in, week out, for a team under constant pressure to win every single game.
The pressure at Celtic is enormous. The expectation level is through the roof. Some players simply shouldn’t be put under that weight until they’re truly ready. Now, I do get the argument that some need to be tested by that pressure in order to grow into it—but it crushes more than it elevates. If the club is reluctant to take that risk—if Brendan is reluctant to take that risk—I understand. I see both sides. It’s a hard needle to thread.
But Kenny, at least, has seen the value in sticking with the plan. He’s now part of the first team setup. He trusts the coaching staff. He knows they rate him. And he believes that with a little more polish, he can break through. Waiting that little bit longer until he’s truly ready benefits both him and the club. And even if he ends up elsewhere, playing first team football in the meantime ensures that his career options will be far stronger than they are today.
This is forward planning. This is strategy. Maybe this is Tisdale and Rodgers working together for the greater good, putting in place what’s needed to make sure more of our players escape the hellish Lowland League and instead go into proper football environments where they can grow.
What’s most important here is that it shows some of these guys do recognise what it takes. It takes faith in the club. Faith in what Rodgers is trying to do. Faith in the process. And when that faith is shown, maybe good things will happen.
Time will tell. But Kenny’s got a better chance of making it at Celtic than those who rejected the pathway—because he chose loyalty. And it shows commitment on the part of both player and club. That’s the kind of partnership that brings footballers through to the first team that little bit quicker.

Good on him if he thinks he’s good enough to eventually challenge and hold down a place, but I fear for his faith in both Celtic and himself. I watched him in both the games he’s played in pre-season and, at this stage of his development, he should really be standing out, he didn’t, and in fact was pretty anonymous most of the time. The other problem for him now is that the queue for a strikers place at Celtic is getting longer. With Osman and Yamada’s arrival his task has just got that bit harder. As I said, I wish him all the best, but a move elsewhere might probably be better for him.
I hope everyone is shouting on Taylor Fritz in the Wimbledon semi finals against Alcaraz today. He’s a good Celtic man.
Fritz a grand old team….. 🙂
Fritz sure is….
I’m a fan of Kenny. His work rate is excellent and he looks to link up with his team mates. I felt he was unlucky not to get some more game time last season.
I like him but he should be scoring more. Perhaps he is too passive in the box, awaiting for the ball to fall to him, instead of getting into a clear scoring position.
Stating that all three players mentioned have arguably benefitted from going elsewhere and playing regular football is difficult to support in two cases. its yet to be seen what opportunities Cummings will get, while Kelly appears to have had very little game time over the past season. To date there is no real evidence of any great advances being made by players in career progression by making an early departure from Celtic. An article with more research and substance on what has happened over a number of years in this respect would be helpful rather than assumptions of greater opportunity of game time and development because players choose (after many years of support and investment) to imagine the grass must be greener in England.
I see the Kuhn transfer has been done and dusted, that’s him definitely offski. And for those who say we haven’t replaced him yet, no we haven’t, but he will not be hard to replace, at least not the pale imitation of Kuhn who went through the motions in the second half of the season. Jamesy Forrest at his age would be much preferable to that version of Kuhn.
Kenny’s attitude is refreshing, it’ll be tough for him to get in the team but like any other good Celtic supporter, he’s excited to get a new deal. It’d be tough anywhere but the rewards at Celtic, if you make it, is better than the English championship. Good lad.
It’s definitely unmatchable at Celtic when it comes to the best supporters for sure Brattbakk…
Definitely better getting to top European competitions also…
But The SPFL Premier League is definitely nowhere near as competitive as The EFL Championship for sure…
That Championship is truly a brutal, competitive and unforgiving environment for sure where anyone can beat anyone and you never know who is gonna win it or be relegated either…
I know as an unfashionable club that I follow down there were in it a while back and I used to be down twice a season to see it all unfold…
I still go down but miss The EFL Championship badly !
Glad he was farmed out to Shamrock Rovers for sure it’d be a good grounding there…
Even minnows like Home Farm and Finn Harps would be a bloody step up from The Lowland League !