16 thoughts on “Celtic needs players backed by the manager. After that, it doesn’t matter what they cost.”

  1. It looks like Celtic are signing Yamada from Japan for a low fee. That’s the striker situation sorted,no big signing.
    If we don’t qualify for the CL Maeda and Hatate will be sold.
    If Brendan does not sign a new contract the board will not back him.
    We will then be in danger of being overtaken by the loan Rangers.

    1. You must have been a hoot when we signed a no-name manager from Japan along with three players that we’d never heard of before for not a lot of money.

        1. So, you’d be happier with Yamada if we paid more for him? That’s a take, I suppose.

          Also, Maeda £1.5m, Hatate £1.5m, but of course they went on to have zero impact in the team and were quickly moved on…

          The idea that the price we pay for a player has any impact on their quality has always been nonsense.

  2. The uncertainty surrounding the manager is a great excuse for the board not to spend, for once I dont blame them. Why would they give him a fortune to spend for him to leave next summer and the new manager not want any players we sign now? We should never be letting a manager get to the last year of his contract without clarity.

  3. I can’t for the life of me understand why you and many Celtic fans can’t see that Maeda replaced kyogo as a forward. You describe Daizen and Idah in this article as high value forwards ?
    Jota was purchased to fill in on the left wing. Job done. So is it just a means of weaponising your ongoing assault on the club? It’s tiresome and unnecessary considering you are a man of intellect.
    This article reflects a more consensus based approach and less divisive albeit you can’t avoid stating that view on Kyogo. I realise that for some they can’t drop the hero worshipping of Kyogo particularly after those first two seasons under AP’s management but reality is he was less impactful under BR and uncommitted. Maybe it was BR that impacted negatively on him.
    Anyway I enjoyed reading this article and there’ll be more of this positivity going forward. HH

  4. I hope DD and Brendan had a good long chat about his future and that they were able to put together a plan that involved financing more quality signings and an extension to his contract even it change in substance to a 12 month rollover. I’d like to see here for teas to come yet even to stay and attempt the TIAR.
    I’m not yet convinced that he is a manager that warrants an “Elite” status but he certainly does have many positives that could turn him into a legendary figure in club history. HH

  5. Lubo and Henrik were great buys for low prices…

    Rafael Scheidht was… well… Shite for £5 million…

    Always a mixed potential is the good old transfer window for sure !

  6. Hatate did not have significantly more experience than Inamura has – and adjusting for the one year age gap, games played pretty much like for like.
    Both were playing at University/College in Japan which doesn’t count for senior football but is of a high standard. I wouldn’t fixate on the experience- let’s judge on his performances.

  7. I will keep my powder dry on any talk of Shin Yamada, just in case I end up with any pre-conceived notions regarding his talents. I am prepared to wait until I have a detailed analysis from our resident football consultant and new signings expert….Jay Green.

    Take it away Jae. 🙂

    1. Has Jae got under your skin Johnny, or is it just a wee playful dig between friends you’re having? I sense a little needle there. ?

      1. LOL Under my skin, no way Martino. You are giving him too much credit.

        I’m just having a dig and standing up for me and my ilk. 🙂

          1. Definitely not Terry

            Besides Green is my colour not surname, Jae might be one of the other 39 shades.

    2. The funny thing is you’re doing exactly what I was advocating for, so thanks. I guess you can teach an old dog new tricks.

Comments are closed.