KILMARNOCK, SCOTLAND - MAY 15: Celtic Board members Peter Lawwell and Michael Nicholson during a cinch Premiership match between Kilmarnock and Celtic at Rugby Park, on May 15, 2024, in Glasgow, Scotland. (Photo by Craig Foy/SNS Group via Getty Images)
Every regime that has ever held power believes that it is forever. Even in democracies, parties in office operate under the assumption that if they can tilt the table just enough while they’re in charge, they’ll be returned to power again and again.
Gordon Brown famously cut his deal with Tony Blair on that basis. Before they had even won one election, Brown was talking about the end of the second term. Blair told him it was madness to be thinking like that when they had yet to take power. Brown’s reply was confident: Labour would be in power for a generation.
This belief is even more ingrained when you are essentially unchallenged. To outsiders your regime looks impenetrable. But nothing lasts forever. In the end even the harshest systems are swept away. Only in dystopian fiction like Orwell’s 1984 can a small group rule indefinitely without paying heed to the outside world.
Ask any journalist in Scotland what chance Celtic fans have of seeing off the current board of directors and they will tell you: somewhere between slim and none.
What have I said about the Scottish media time and again? They are as lacking in imagination as this Celtic board. They misunderstand historical trends. They believe power lies in shares, in money, in the strength those things supposedly give a leader. History proves otherwise. None of it matters without legitimacy.
Any leadership needs a governing mandate, one way or another.
In a dictatorship it comes from the ruling class and the military. In Russia, they call the men around Putin the siloviki — the men of power. Rome had the Palatini, the inner court of the empire, and the Praetorians — on the surface the emperor’s bodyguards, but in reality, kingmakers who decided who ruled and who died.
Legitimacy comes in many forms, but you must satisfy the people around you. Even in the most repressive regimes you are answerable to somebody, and you are only legitimate for as long as you take their needs into account.
In a democracy, legitimacy comes from the voters.
It manifests in public opinion and in election results. That is why governments do hard and fast U-turns on the basis of polling data. It is why Labour is in such a cold sweat right now, especially after the resignation of Angela Rayner.
The Celtic board has operated for years under the mistaken belief that its mandate comes from the AGM and re-election year after year. It does not.
That is a group of well-heeled friends voting for themselves. It confers no legitimacy. For these people, legitimacy comes from something else: being seen to put the club first, being seen to act in Celtic’s best interests, being seen to have a plan, a strategy, a vision with clearly identified goals and a blueprint to achieve them.
It comes from the songs sung in the stands. The banners. The ability of a board member to ride the subway with the ordinary fans without being scorned by them.
Some think it comes from the numbers buying tickets.
Yet that metric is deceptive, because the board believes that as long as season tickets sell out, fans are content. Wrong. Fans want to watch their team. That is not an expression of satisfaction with how the team is funded or how the club is run.
The Romans thought the same with their bread and circuses. But even while the plebeians cheered, imperial dynasties toppled and fell.
When legitimacy is gone, all the walls come tumbling down.
Over 400 fan organisations — supporters’ buses, fan media, and now the Celtic Supporters Association itself — have expressed their view on this board, and it damns them. It strips them of their mandate. It strips them of legitimacy.
In truth, those things expired long before the events of the weekend.
We recognise this moment. That’s the key thing. Renewal comes from recognising that change isn’t optional, it’s inevitable. It isn’t that it must come — it will come. Why were we so sure before? Why are we so sure now?
Because this board can no longer claim any right to sit in those seats.
Yes, they have power, and they can exercise that power if they so choose.
But power without legitimacy is already half-lost. It is clinging on by brute force.
Without a mandate, leaders have no moral basis on which to exercise power.
And if they do they are only delaying the inevitable and inflicting further harm on the very thing they are supposed to safeguard. If they love Celtic as much as they claim, they would not do that. But they wouldn’t have done some of the other things they’ve done this summer, like the attack on Rodgers they made at the weekend.
They can persist with the strategy as they like, but that strategy has nothing to underpin it now. There is no broad base of opinion in favour of it. It runs counter to the wishes of virtually the whole fan base.
When those in the media confidently claim that we cannot shift them, they are correct in a narrow sense because the board can decide to ignore us. All of us. The whole support. They can turn this into a trial of strength.
But our strength flows directly from our love for this club and our determination to see it renewed and restored. Spread sheets, data points, self interest and fear will never be able to withstand a force built from that.
They can proceed down the path they are currently on for as long as they can hold it together, but that kind of reactionary thinking breeds more resentment. Every act of theirs which sets its face against us only deepens our anger and strengthens our resolve.
They have no legitimacy. It is just as simple as that.
They can recognise this moment for what it is. A motion of no confidence is not a statement that says “you have a chance to change course.” It is a statement that says “pack your bags — you’re done.” It’s already over.
For the Celtic board, the Rubicon has been crossed. There is no going back. Every moment they stay in those seats is an embarrassment. Every moment they dig in with their fingernails, the harsher the verdict of history will be.
If they agree now to a phased transition of power, to renewal, to a new plan, then supporters can see their way to allowing that to happen. If they insist on ignoring the clearly expressed wishes of the vast majority of the fans, they’ll meet a different end and will depart in shame, with their reputations in ruins.
When an executive board acts directly against the best interests of the company it represents, it is finished.
It is the same as a government betraying the best interests of the country it is supposed to rule over.
History has a word for that: treason.
It is one of the few things it never forgives.
We don’t care if some of them have convinced themselves that depriving Rodgers of funds, depriving Rodgers of players, depriving the team of what it needed was somehow necessary. It was an act against Celtic’s best interests. Their mandate was gone the day they made that choice. Their legitimacy was gone the day they put it into effect.
They have ceased to govern for us. They have been governing for themselves. They have mistaken their own good for the greater good of Celtic, and whether they recognise this or not they cannot continue to govern legitimately once that line has been crossed.
That is the simple fact of it.
“When the fall is all there is,” Eleanor of Aquitaine reminds us in The Lion in Winter, “it matters.” For this Celtic board, winter has come.
The fall is all there is now. They can decide how they go.
But one way or another, they are gone.


They are done, finished all its left now is the theatre, a slow revovling door of departures for heatlh or personal reasons.
My god it was all so uneccessary.
I hope for positive change. We need a board aligned to the goals of the fans and vice versa.
If we were skint I’d see the point in looking after the pennies and even missing out on some deals but there is no excuses here.
We are unbeaten and top of the table. We need to stay there. The treatment of yang and maeda has been shocking. Not sure they will be so motivated this term.
Daniel Levy resigned at Spurs last week and he wasn’t exactly loved by their fans for the way he ran the club.Hopefully our bunch of charlatans will clear their desks,the sooner the better.
At a time like this you would expect your CEO and board to stand up and show leadership. Unfortunately the Quiet Man and Co. will do exactly that, remain quiet. The board decided to go to legacy media, and a despised title to trash the manager. This may have worked in years gone by, but we are in the generation of the Internet. They have miscalculated spectacularly the feeling the fans have towards them. If the supports sticks together then change will be forced on them.. Vive la revolution
It is not just football club board it is the PLC board must be removed James what is the timeline on this also we must keep sevco under our boot in our shadow support the players win the league as Brendan puts another sevco coach out the door at the auld hoor
Dead men walking, but as long as they cling on to power, they are damaging the club.
How do you get through to people like that?
All I would say to them is that if you go now and hand over to people with the club’s best interests at heart, you can and will salvage some of your reputation.
If not, your names will live in infamy forever.
Is that really the legacy you want to leave?
The Kelly’s and The Whyte’s are eternally damned as ‘custodians’ of Celtic…
This lot won’t care one fuckin little jot either TonyB…
The only tragedy for them is their fuckin filthy lucre that they will lose !
I wish I had your optimistic outlook James but I’m afraid I’m feeling full of pessimism at the moment. This board hold enough shares to try and ride out this storm, and they will dig in try to do this.
We could be caught in a catch 22 situation, if we go on a winning streak the unrest will dissipate, and if we go on a losing streak this board will sack the manager and attempt to carry on.
Unless there is genuine interest from would be buyers of the club, and DD decides he’s had enough and wants to sell his shares, I’m afraid I don’t see much chance of change other than one or two board members being sacrificed.
A long drawn out campaign of boycotts and refusal to buy merchandise will only damage the club, but I don’t blame the supporters if they go down that route.
As eldraco has said, “it was all so unnecessary”
JF — Not sure you are getting the basics in all of this.
The board are not one single fully aligned entity.
There is the strategic element taking a nap somewhere warm.
Then there is the active local element doing the day to day stuff — badly / thick as mince.
Finally there are the buffet munchers who turn up to nod and echo what has been done.
At the moment the “active” local element would appear to be fully engaged.
The statement language reeks of second rate property been counter strategy / third rate business brains / useless + clueless + hopeless in equal measure.
Badly run bowling club vibe where egos come first and progress is something to be feared. There is a lot of it about and the we seem to have more than our fair share.
DD is key in all of this.
Does he know what is happening / does he even care?
Time for the 26 County golf set to start winding him up?
AP leaving — Team Desmond seemed to care.
BR fragmenting — they have to be put in the spotlight.
Change has one huge advantage.
The local board really are second and third rate.
Plus DD has tissue thin skin — the barbs will hurt.
With all the fan organisations now singing from the one hymn sheet ..A letter framed by the CSA and /or reps of all the signatories to the ‘condemnation letter’ should be sent ASAP to PL demanding he and the other board members step down immediately . This should be made public and include a vote of confidence in the manager ..effectively the entire support saying GO and Go now …This isn’t sedition this is a fair , reasonable & necessary revolution . DD PL & the board have consistently failed and seriously damaged the club and no longer deserve to be in charge .
They insist that a small team go in as temporary board members eg D Low & respected others & work with Nicholson till they get a proper high quality new board CHAIR and CEO which everyone will get behind .. DD told to butt out and operations people at Parkhead mandated to ignore his instructions and simply work with BR and his team to maximise team performance . New Board will likely need to amend Articles of Association and other legal instruments in due course to control DD ( until he hopefully sells his shares) ..if he picks a fight use the tens of millions to fight him
Time for renewal indeed !
Brilliant post Charlie.
If DD really holds all the power then, with his huge ego, he may see this as an opportunity to take the higher ground and distance himself from the local board’s performance and the fans groups vote of no confidence in them (assuming he feels it doesn’t reflect on him).
This could result in a similar scenario to when other megalomaniacs throughout history decided that other members of the leadership group need to fall on their swords, starting with Nicholson.