GLASGOW, SCOTLAND - FEBRUARY 17: Celtic's Cameron Carter-Vickers (L) suffers an injury after a collision with Bodo's Nikita Haikin during a UEFA Conference League Last 32 first leg match between Celtic and Bodo/Glimt at Celtic Park, on February 17, 2022, in Glasgow, Scotland. (Photo by Craig Williamson/SNS Group via Getty Images)
I’ve been thinking about this more and more lately. How can a club as big as Celtic F.C., with its history, support, finances and global recognition, still feel like it is searching for its football identity instead of confidently defining it?
This is not criticism for the sake of it.
Rather, it comes from frustration and from knowing exactly what this club could be. As this season has gone on, I find myself asking the same question again and again. Why does the football structure not match the stature? What, exactly, is not working at Celtic?
Celtic is the most successful club in Scotland, with significant money in the bank. Yet without proper management, clear ambition or a coherent structure, nothing works as it should. Even the transfer windows, which too often feel chaotic or reactive, bring us back to the same question every year. Why does this keep happening?
In theory, Celtic should be a model club, a clear example of a world-class system and high-calibre recruitment. So why doesn’t it look that way?
Perhaps building a modern system at a club of Celtic’s size is more difficult than it appears, especially with a board that often seems distant or cautious. Even so, imagine a club run with a simple guiding principle: Celtic first, everything else second.
From a squad perspective, there are still obvious gaps.
Even setting aside loan departures, the team needs reinforcements in a number of areas. After all, competition improves performance and protects the squad from injuries or loss of form. One of the most common complaints is that the side needs a true ball-winner, someone who breaks up play, gives the attacking midfielders freedom and adds physical presence when games become scrappy. At times, we simply look too easy to play through.
The deeper issue, however, is planning. Too often, Celtic feel like a club operating year to year rather than building for the long term. Recruitment should focus on quality and longevity, not short-term fixes. Ideally, the squad should combine experience with carefully integrated younger players on longer deals, supported by a genuine and functioning pathway from the academy.
There is also a wider structural question to consider.
At present, Celtic lack a consistent football identity that exists independently of whoever happens to be the manager. Recruitment, analytics and organisation should follow a clear philosophy. Fewer gambles. More targeted signings. Less short-term thinking and more ambition. Above all, the club needs an institutional mindset that matches supporter expectations and treats fans as stakeholders rather than an inconvenience.
If Celtic fully embraced that kind of long-term thinking, the ceiling would rise significantly. Domestic dominance would become more secure. European campaigns would carry greater credibility. In time, the club’s global standing would grow.
There is, in fact, a useful example of this in Norway.
In a small town called Bodø, FK Bodø/Glimt have built something impressive. At first glance, some people assume their success comes from a brilliant manager or a golden generation. In reality, however, it comes from something more powerful. A system.
They play with intensity, aggressive pressing, quick transitions and attacking full-backs. Their style demands physical and mental commitment. More importantly, though, it belongs to the club, not just the coach. As a result, the identity survives changes in personnel.
What stands out most is the alignment. Coaching philosophy, recruitment, conditioning, analytics and youth development all move in the same direction. That is system thinking. And, in my view, it is an area where Celtic still have work to do.
The foundations, of course, are already there.
Financial strength relative to the domestic league. A huge global fanbase. Modern training facilities. One of the strongest brands in football. Given all of that, the question becomes obvious. Why not use those advantages to build something fully coherent?
Now imagine Celtic with that clarity.
Recruitment aligned with a defined playing philosophy. A football identity embedded from academy to first team. Management fully synchronised with football operations. Long-term planning replacing emergency fixes.
Then imagine greater ambition in the transfer market. Stronger communication with supporters. Leadership focused on football strategy as well as financial stability. A club aiming for real European progress alongside domestic success.
Of course, that would not guarantee instant continental trophies. Realism still matters. However, it would make Celtic consistently competitive, widely respected and tactically mature.
Bodø/Glimt themselves have produced some astonishing results in recent years. Most recently, they delivered a major shock to Italian giants Inter Milan. Not long before that, they dismantled a José Mourinho Roma side in a result that sent shockwaves around Europe.
The Norwegian example proves something important. You do not need to be the biggest club to be the most coherent. And if a small club with limited resources can build that kind of clarity, Celtic certainly have the capacity to do it at a much higher level.
For me, this is not criticism. It is expectation.
More than that, it comes with belief. If Celtic ever fully align ambition with structure, the potential is enormous. Domestically dominant without the yearly drama. Far more credible in Europe. A club that sets the standard instead of searching for it.
The resources are already there.
What Celtic need now is the system to match them.

It won’t happen at our club under the present people runnin it. Too much greed over ambition. End of.
And they’re doing it with average home gates of 7,000. Would our executive team like to comment?
Good article Paulina, It all comes down to the elephant in the room and that is sevco, this board wants to keep them relevant , and until this board are relieved of their duties then the club will not move forward. this corrupt board are up to their necks in the 5 way agreement.
fresh forward thinking young dynamic minds are what is need to prise away the future of the club from these trough eating dinosaurs.
Many of the fans keep them relevant. All Im hearing is we should ditch europa league and concentrate on Sevco!
We had a fresh young dynamic mind in Dominic McKay and look what happened there Tez…
Driven away by dinasours…
Death is the only fuckin thing that will see these bastards outta Parkhead unfortunately…
They won’t walk and continue to stink the place our North, South, East and West !
A good article Paulina and a good question. There is no easy answer. Man U. a far bigger club than us have struggled with this. Liverpool also having many issues over the last 30 years.
Bodo have many advantages over us. The biggest advantage is their league set up. They beat us 5-1 in 2022, they didnt even win the league that year. They are not the current champions of Norway.
They play in a competitive environment.
The season Bodo taught us how to play football at CP we won the league and we have won it every season since. Whether we like to admit it or not the league is set up in Scotland so that no one other than us or Basket Case FC can win it. Nobody else will win it in many current Celtic fans entire life time. Thats the reality. Would we accept winning only 2 of the last 4 titles to be as good as Bodo?
Right now a significant amount of the support are wanting to sacrifice europe because the Ibrox entity might win the league or the scottish cup ffs!
I think JF was suggesting this in some articles also but maybe wrong.
No ambition, but not just from the board!
MoN will be all in tonight though.
If ya think Celtic FC are winning The Europa League Mr Mojorisin then can I get some of the good gear that gives you those thoughts…
Not a fuckin snowballs chance in hell Sir !
You need to raise yer ambitions Clach. Basket Case FC got to within penalties of winning the fucking thing recently.
We dont belong in UCL and never will, we are just there for the fanfare and making up the numbers. This is where we can make an impression instead of shitting ourselves about losing the annual one horse race!
Paulina, fans all over Europe look on at Bodo Glimt with envy and they all wonder why their own clubs cannot do the same. However, they are really quite unique, a one off that will not happen very often, they have a sprinkling of magic dust that has blessed them for some reason, but anyone trying to emulate them is onto plums. I am reminded of the Leicester City fairytale victory against all the odds when winning the EPL. It hasn’t happened since and it probably will not happen again.
We need to create our own magic, but that is looking very unlikely under our present regime.
Mr Mojorisin @ 8.56pm…
I think we’d have a chance in The Europa Conference League…
But not the other two as it stands !