GLASGOW, SCOTLAND - DECEMBER 11: A General Stadium View during a UEFA Europa League 2025/26 League Phase MD6 match between Celtic and AS Roma at Celtic Park, on December 11, 2025, in Glasgow, Scotland. (Photo by Rob Casey/SNS Group via Getty Images)
All week long, one bizarre story has dominated the Scottish sports media. The one about Askou, the manager of Motherwell, and the link with Celtic. Most people know how I feel about it. I do not want this guy as the next boss of Celtic. It would be a dire decision.
Let me say this at the outset, because it matters. This is not about the Motherwell manager as a person. It’s not even about whether he’s a good coach or a bad one. It’s not about his character, his work ethic or his potential.
This is about something much bigger than that.
This is about what it would say about Celtic if we appointed him.
Because right now his name is being spoken about in the same conversations as managers who have operated at the highest levels of the game. And that, in itself, should make people stop and think.
There are basically two types of managerial candidate.
There are proven, high-level operators. These are people who have worked in major leagues. People who have managed under pressure. People who have dealt with expectation, scrutiny and the need to deliver immediately.
And then there are project managers. Coaches with promise and ideas. Coaches who might become something in time. What Celtic cannot afford to do is pretend those two things are the same. Because they are not.
And right now, the Askou conversation feels like the club convincing itself that potential equals pedigree. It doesn’t.
Let’s be blunt about the reality of the situation.
If Celtic appoint this manager, they will be doing so on the back of a handful of months in Scottish football. That’s it. He has no deeper body of work which would justify such a mad call. We all know there are better qualified candidates out there and that is where the conversation should both start and stop.
There is no evidence that he has the experience to manage a big club operating under this kind of pressure.
There is no track record of handling a dressing room full of high-value players.
He has no experience of his winning things in the full glare of media scrutiny.
There is no proof he can operate under the conditions required for this job.
Every game matters and every result is analysed. Every decision is questioned and every transfer is scrutinised. At Celtic every dropped point becomes a crisis.
This is not a development role. This is not a learning environment. Celtic is one of the most demanding managerial jobs in European football.
Now ask yourself the obvious question.
Why would Celtic take that risk? Because this is where the real concern lies. Not the candidate. The thinking of our own club.
Because we’re tight. Because he’s “obvious”. The media narrative around him is already all pointing towards this and that’s a concern to me. This club has often looked for “value” where it should be looking for obvious quality. It has treated the most important football decisions as if they were standing in a casino.
That approach might work when you’re signing a winger from Scandinavia. It does not work when you’re appointing the manager. We’ve seen the evidence of that this season. It is bonkers to me that there are people talking seriously about another gamble on that level.
This summer is already shaping up to be one of the most important in the club’s modern history. We may finish outside the top two and heading into Conference League qualifiers. We need a rebuild. Players out and players in on a scale few of us have ever seen before. Additionally, we need a new structure.
We need authority and above all, we need credibility. Because the next manager has to walk into that dressing room and command it from day one. He has to convince players to stay and new players to come. He has to convince supporters that there is a plan.
And he has to do all of that immediately.
That is not a job for potential. That requires presence and this is where the comparison with someone like Roberto Martínez becomes instructive. You don’t have to believe he will come. You don’t even have to think he’s the right appointment. But the gap between a manager who has led national teams at major tournaments and a manager whose only recent top-level experience amounts to a short spell at Motherwell is enormous.
Those two names do not belong in the same conversation, and the fact they are being discussed together tells you everything about the uncertainty around Celtic’s thinking right now. Because this is what it comes down to.
Big clubs don’t make hopeful appointments after difficult seasons. Big clubs make statements. They send a message. They show strength and ambition. When they go out to make an appointment they shoot for certainty.
If Celtic come out of this summer with a manager whose appointment feels like a gamble, then the message to the rest of Scottish football will be clear. The club is still thinking small, and that, more than any individual result, should worry supporters.
This isn’t about whether Askou might become a good manager one day. He might. But Celtic cannot afford to be the place where he finds that out.

I remember a guy managing Dunfermline who had no experience of high class players but we took the risk. Jock Stein led us to glory. I remember a young manager at Wycombe Wanderers that had no experience handling a dressing room of stars. MON led us to the edge of glory. I dont know if Askou is the answer but to reject him because of inexperience with stars is a bit much. Besides, all our stars are on the wane anyway and a few will go before a new manager arrives at the end of the transfer window if this board are still in place. Who ever heard of Knutsen before they beat Mourinhos Roma a couple of years ago. Come to think of it, who had heard of Ange and what experience did he have with stars. Not much, he just created them. So dont reject Askou on an experience whim. He may go on to be a great manager. Of course he could be a one season wonder. We could be dodging a bullet or missing out on the next great one
In fairness, MON had 5 seasons at Leicester before coming to Celtic, with good league finishes and a couple of cups won. He was also regarded as one of the rising managerial stars in the EPL and in high demand. That was a truly ambitious, transformative move and re-set the tone in Scotland, my favourite manager in my lifetime.
The Motherwell manager, from a distance (and I have watched a number of their games) has taken a bunch of players who, many would suggest, are not at our level, who didn’t cost much money and who he has coached to deliver the best football in the country, by a distance and so, much like you, Terry, I’m disinclined to outright reject the man. With the right people alongside him, why could he not do better with better/more resources?
If this board are not removed he’ll get the nod simply cos he’s the cheaper option , nothing else will influence them
I’m not convinced by your argument here James,not too long ago you were raving about Nancy being a great choice , even though he’d done nothing,7th best in the pishy MSL,you also thought tisdale was a great appointment,so to say the Motherwell boss isn’t good enough because all he’s done is manage in Scotland,not any worse than Nancy.I agree to an extent we should maybe try and attract a higher class o manager with a good pedigree but who in their right mind would come and work for our board and the awful desmonds, unfortunately I think the board will go cheap again,so the Motherwell guy might get the nod or it just might be Maloney,but I wouldn’t write askou off just yet.
James, why should it bother you what anyone thinks about Celtic hiring Askou in as our manager, for you have already stated that we are the laughing stock of Europe. So, would doing that not just be in line with your outsiders perceived view of us, no big deal then, all’s well, business as usual.
Personally I would rather have him than some of the fancy names that have been associated with us and whom would probably string us along until getting a better gig elsewhere, it has happened before. He might well also get a better offer elsewhere, there is no guarantee he would jump at the chance to join us, and where would that leave us?
I doubt that someone who has managed at the level Martinez has, would come to the SPFL.
For you to write off Askou so easily is foolish, and after your misplaced support for the Nancy appointment, it looks like you haven’t learned the lesson to keep a low profile for a wee while, when supporting or writing off managerial candidates.
Numerous Celtic supporters in the US, including my son told us to steer clear of Nancy , based on his very limited record in the MLS. You supported this Board in the worst appointment of a Celtic manager in our history. A wee bit of humble pie wouldn’t go amiss James. Whoever the next manager of Celtic is, he will need our support, in my opinion what Askou has done with M’well is very impressive. They play entertaining football and have the best goal difference in the League at this time, they also have the best defensive record in the League whilst playing attacking football.
To do this with the budget and squad that he has, is very impressive and I would be quite happy if he was appointed our manager.
James you have thoughts above your station. You seem to think Celtic should have in your description an “elite manager”. No way in hell will a manager in this category come to Celtic, one quick call to Brendan will end that. You are a manager snob with glitzy names impressing you. Celtic would be lucky to get Askou, as he may turn us down, we are not currently an attractive job after all
He would be off his fuckin head to come to Celtic…
Not because of our wonderful club of course…
But because of our Scummy board !
James, you were dead keen on Nancy and giving him a chance even when he was burning our season to the ground after 2 games.