DUNDEE, SCOTLAND - DECEMBER 29: Referee John Beaton consults the VAR monitor before overturning the penalty decision as the ball appears to strike Aberdeen's Nicky Devlin's arm during a William Hill Premiership match between Dundee United and Aberdeen at The CalForth Construction Arena at Tannadice Park, on December 29, 2024, in Dundee, Scotland. (Photo by Paul Devlin/SNS Group via Getty Images)
Today at Falkirk we saw another one of those VAR moments that shames this game and proves, yet again, that this is a footballing banana republic. This is not a pro-Celtic, anti-Ibrox rant. It is not about the fairness or unfairness of the decision that went the Ibrox club’s way at the end of the first half.
This is a clear case showing up an amateurish technical system and the equally dreadful officials we have in this league of ours.
Towards the end of the first half, the Ibrox club scored after the ball appeared to go out. The Falkirk players stopped and waited for the decision. It never came. The incident was allegedly reviewed by VAR, but according to the BBC, VAR did not have a camera angle that could prove it one way or the other. Convenient as that sounds, it also sounds true, because we know that VAR systems in Scotland are not worth a damn.
What we have here is a cheaply cobbled-together version of VAR that is absolutely useless a lot of the time, and clubs are paying for it.
Falkirk are one of the clubs paying for it.
They are entitled to expect a system that actually does what it is supposed to do. For the governing body to be forced to admit that it did not have a camera angle on that particular moment is shocking. It means VAR cannot be relied upon in that part of the ground at all. So, Falkirk are entitled to ask why they are paying for a system that does not work.
Last week FIFA published the officials list for the coming World Cup, and one of the more interesting things to come out of that list was the fact that there was not a single SFA official on it. It is no damn wonder.
For all the so-called innovations, for all the supposed leaps forward, for all the people hailing Willie Collum for coming on television and explaining certain decisions, this is still a frighteningly amateurish association run by fourth-rate individuals and tolerating what we have long been aware is a third-rate VAR system at best.
The officials cannot walk away from this either.
Where was the linesman’s flag? The Falkirk players clearly thought the ball was out, so why did the official not? This is a joke.
I am not alleging bias here. I am not alleging that the Ibrox club got some massive favour from the brethren, although when you look at the guy who refereed the game and when you look at the guy in the VAR room, you do not exactly see friends of Celtic. But FIFA tsays we have incompetent officials, and this surely offers more proof of exactly that.
VAR is supposed to be the great insurance policy against decisions that are blatantly wrong. For the governing body to have to say that our version of it cannot always tell right from wrong is appalling. It is embarrassing. It heaps further humiliation on an association already weighed down by it after the FIFA announcement.
What world football’s governing body says, essentially, in denying Scottish officials any place at the World Cup, is that we are one of the worst-officiated countries in Europe, and quite possibly in the world itself. That is a staggering verdict from the very top of football, but it is not an unexpected one.
This will continue to happen as long as clubs tolerate it.
Falkirk should be raising nine kinds of hell over that decision. More than that, they should be raising nine kinds of hell over the fact that they have essentially pissed their money away on something that has not delivered, on something that is incapable of delivering.
That is the real problem here.
It is not just that the system got a decision wrong. It is not just that the officials got a decision wrong. It is the fact that they were unable even to make a decision because of the substandard nature of our version of the technology.
If you bought a brand-new car on the promise that it had an elite-level safety system, and then found out that what had actually been installed was a cheap knock-off version, one full of blind spots and tech failures that left you dangerously exposed, you would be pretty damned angry. That is assuming, of course, that you were lucky enough to survive a major incident before finding that out.
When all the fancy equipment was being set up and tested today, did anybody bother to tell Falkirk that it did not cover in a certain part of the ground?
Did anybody tell them that the system was inaccurate or inefficient? I will say it again. It is embarrassing that our national association has stuck us with the football equivalent of Betamax in the era of Blu-ray.
I do not know how much longer clubs will continue to pay for this low-tech farce.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

It’s a third rate system for third rate officials.
Aye! Not one single Scottish official selected for the World Cup. And all of this under Wee Willie Collum’s watch.
Its not only VAR. Everything from top down is antiquated and sub-standard- the SFA, SPFL, Hampden etc the guys in ties and their secret societies who run Scottish football. The only good thing about Scottish football is the fans who are being fucked over.
Although the ibrox 1st goal was farcical. The main fact here is, they have goal scorers and we haven’t. There’s no way we’re goin to keep winnin these remainin games. The blame for this impendin catastrophe, lies with this board. Who couldnae do any better, if they just delivered the league trophy tae ibrox theirselves and handed them 40 million while they were at it. Get them fuckin out. Now !
They could easily have had two players sent off as well as the wind blowing Raskin’s cross back onto the field of play unseen by the linesman.
Regardless of the VAR fiasco Ibrox has firepower we don’t. We would never come back against anyone at 2 nil down.
@ tommyr. Exactly.
I don’t disagree, although oddly enough we came back against them from 2-0 down. Our lack of goals is a terrible indictment of the board.
I’d be inclined to freshen up our midfield next week to see if that can deliver a more dynamic performance. And that would include benching McGregor – whether through tiredness or habit he isn’t providing the drive needed in the middle of the park.
Regardless of the VAR fiasco Ibrox has firepower we don’t. We would never come back against anyone at 2 nil down.
Robbie Keane will sort it out for next season.
It’s a question of for how much longer will Scottish football put up with an inferior VAR system and a hopelessly inferior SFA? The answers lie with the teams themselves, particularly the two with the most clout, Celtic and Rangers. Are we to believe that they are perfectly happy with VAR and the SFA? If so, they should be ashamed of themselves because they are doing Scottish football a grave disservice and they really need to pull their weight and get things sorted out! I’m pretty confident that the rest of Scottish football would support them in this respect, so stop letting the SFA making us a laughing stock in the game and start taking some action!
When it comes to VAR and our referees, the SFA refuse to be shamed. Looking at the list for the World Cup and the European contingent, there are refs from Slovenia, Slovakia and Romania – all countries with considerably less resources than Scotland.
After our disallowed goal against Hibs last season (when deemed that Maeda didn’t keep the ball in), with available camera angle for VAR to rely on, you would have thought a camera on the goal lines would have been introduced…
The son of the official who got sacked for being a bigot on VAR helping them out again
Don’t blame the stand side assistant, he failed to spot the ball crossing his touch line a number of times in the second half. Should have gone to Specsavers.
Broony @ 4.22pm…
‘Rangers’ canny have any clout as ‘Rangers’ are dead !
Officials have won Sevco the league this year !
Nobody has mentioned the main stand linesman in the sevco game was Douglas Dross . No way he’s going to put his flag up. Tyrant.