GLASGOW, SCOTLAND - FEBRUARY 05: Brendan Rodgers, Manager of Celtic, looks on prior to during the William Hill Premiership match between Celtic FC and Dundee FC at Celtic Park on February 05, 2025 in Glasgow, Scotland. (Photo by Ian MacNicol/Getty Images)
What brass neck some of the people surrounding Celtic have. What brazenness some inside our club have too.
Today, Celtic itself is celebrating that moment at Hampden nine years ago, when Tom Rogic put the ball in the net to win us the Invincible Treble.
It is worth contemplating properly, and in full, what Rogic’s late goal actually completed. It finished something that had never been done before in Scottish football: a clean sweep of all domestic honours without losing a single game.
That was extraordinary. That was historic. That was immortal. And the man who delivered it, of course, was Brendan Rodgers.
It is inconceivable that any other manager would have propelled that team to such an achievement. The changes he brought in, stylistically, tactically and mentally, made the difference. They were enormous in helping this club reach a level it had never reached before.
Still, Rodgers has not just critics. He has poisonous critics.
Even within our own support, there are people who refuse to acknowledge that he lifted this club to an entirely different place. Without him, there would have been no Invincible Treble, no Double Treble, no foundation for the quadruple treble, no long run of titles in the same way, no 14 from 15, no doubles and trebles piled on top of one another to the point where the trophy cabinet is bursting at the seams.
We have even overtaken the lies our rivals tell themselves.
That we have people within our own support, within our own ranks, dedicated to denigrating this guy with every breath they can muster is genuinely amazing to me.
Some of his fiercest critics acknowledge the success, but then tell us that it was not built to last. Well, we will never know, will we?
He has been at the club as manager twice, and twice he has left midway through his third season because people were doing end-runs around him. Whatever actually happened inside Celtic, one thing cannot be denied.
Rodgers brought us unparalleled levels of success.
The man knows how to build a winning team.
The number of hoops some people have to jump through to convince themselves he was some ruinous presence at Celtic Park defies belief.
Does he get credit for transfer successes? No. But failures in a transfer strategy he himself objected to? Those get laid at his door.
There are certain Celtic sites where this is now their stated version of events: last summer’s fiasco was not the fault of the board of directors, but Rodgers himself. It is a lie fit only for consumption by those with a loathing of Rodgers brimming in their hearts which is greater than their love for Celtic itself.
So that window is blamed on Rodgers when he railed against it. The window before that, which brought us to within an ace of a domestic treble, which helped get us out of the Champions League group stage and nearly past Bayern Munich, is described by those same people as a failure because Rodgers was fully in control of it, and we allegedly overpaid for our three marquee signings.
All three played a significant role in that campaign. Two of them, Auston Trusty and Arne Engels, were pivotal to the double we have just won.
We are told Rodgers did no real development of players, which will come as a great shock to Matt O’Riley and Nicolas Kuhn, amongst others; two players Rodgers got more out of than anyone before him or since.
We are told Rodgers only picks and chooses the players he wants to work with. Well, that is usually what happens when you throw rubbish at a manager and tell him to work with it. He knows exactly what has been dumped on his lap.
The idea that Rodgers will only work with the players he personally signs or personally picks, and that he spits the dummy out over all others, is absolute nonsense. The last few transfer windows have conclusively proved that.
We are told he did nothing to develop Oh Hyeon-gyu.
Absolute rubbish. Oh was signed by Ange, but Rodgers gave him more game time. We are told Rodgers binned every single player from the transfer window the year he came back. Not true. The only one of those players who was worth a damn was Yang, and Rodgers did his best to turn him into a credible footballer.
In fact, without Rodgers and his coaching team, Yang would not be a player worth keeping at this club at all. People can reject that all they want. It remains true.
Benjamin Nygren signed last summer, at a time when there was not a whole lot of quality being brought in. Did Rodgers automatically reject him?
No. He played him. Why?
Because he was capable of playing a part, and Brendan Rodgers will always work with players who are capable of playing a part.
Where are the examples of genuine talent signed in the last three windows whom Rodgers refused to give a chance, who then went on to bigger and better things?
Nobody can point to them.
The board apologist poster boy is Kwon Hyeok-kyu; he was supposedly not given a proper chance. Well, what has Kwon done since to suggest he deserved one? Shin Yamada was an embarrassing signing; where is he?
Certain people got very excited because Kwon had a handful of good games in France, and suddenly there was a suggestion we had lost out on some mercurial talent because Rodgers did not put in the work. Where is Kwon playing at the moment?
Karlsruher, in Germany’s second tier. The same league as Yamada’s on-loan club ended up playing in.
These are not players Rodgers binned for no reason.
Inamura is another one who we signed and were told Rodgers rejected without giving him an opportunity; he’s back on loan in Japan after a single Celtic appearance and it was not Rodgers who made that call. He will probably never play for Celtic’s first team again.
There is precisely zero evidence to suggest we have missed out on some stunning talents because Rodgers decided not to utilise people properly. It is proof that some people are far too desperate to build a case against the manager.
Even today, as the club celebrates the unique achievement for which Rodgers was largely responsible, without ever mentioning his name in the official release, the most anti-Rodgers of all the Celtic fan sites is running yet another article denigrating him as a failure and some kind of disaster that hit the club.
To be frank, these people should be thoroughly ashamed.
Because it is nonsense.
They sound an awful lot like Ryan Stevenson did when he preached how embarrassed Celtic should be after winning the title, describing it as a dark day for the club because some fans were on the pitch.
I don’t know about you, but my first thought upon reading that was simple.
We’ll take dark days like that all the time. I hope we have a lot more of these dark days.
I would say the same to the dwindling band of nutcases in our own support who label Brendan Rodgers a failure. A failure? With eleven trophies? I hope we have many more failures like him far into the future.
Nobody is saying Rodgers is beyond criticism. Nobody is saying every decision he made was perfect. Nobody is saying supporters have to forget how either spell ended, or the frustrations that surrounded both departures. But I choose to look at events in context and ask myself; who was vindicated in either case?
And the answer is Rodgers. We saw an equally shambolic transfer window in January this year as we did last summer; nobody blames it on Martin O’Neill.
So there is criticism, and then there is revisionism. There is criticism, and then there is poison. There is criticism, and then there is pretending that one of the most successful managers in Celtic history somehow harmed the club more than he helped it.
That is absurd. It is beneath serious people.
And it is beneath Celtic.
Celebrate Tom Rogic’s goal. Celebrate the Invincible Treble. Celebrate that perfect, impossible domestic season when Celtic swept everything before them and did it without losing once. But do not pretend it happened by magic. Do not pretend the manager was incidental. Do not pretend Brendan Rodgers was not central to it.
To celebrate the Invincible Treble without acknowledging Rodgers’ role in it, and thanking him for it, is not just petty.
It is embarrassing.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

Brendan will forever be imbued in the beauty and success of Celtic FC…
I could of course be wrong but I simply cannot see that SENSATIONAL season being matched certainly not in ma time left on this planet for sure…
THANK YOU BRENDAN RODGERS !
Thank you for the memories of that season and giving me loads more ammunition of Celtic FC records to shoot down The Sevco Hun Hoards with forever more !
Clach, I honestly think Rodgers is overrated. The current board put him in place twice and they are supposed to be the most incompetent of incompetents. So that’s a catch 22 for starters.
He was average in europe where the opponents fight back.
At Liverpool he was there for 3 years, and in that category, their worst manager in living memory. Good cup win at Leicester but again sacked.
Yeah he is OK and can rip it up in the SPFL where there is extremely limited opposition.
He is finished in top level football in England which is obviously where he really wants to be, and now pockets the sportswashing dollars in a country of severe oppression, which was always the plan I guess.
Never a Celt. Always a fraud.
“At Liverpool… their worst manager in living memory” ??
Aye maybe if you’re 14.
Brendan won zero trophies in 3 full seasons Brattbakk and he then got sacked. You have to go back pre Shankly to find that sort of stats.
He wasn’t cut out to be a Liverpool manager.
Totally different managing here where trophies are ten a penny mate.
That among other things is why he is unappreciated by many in the ranks.
Is that a worse record than winning zero trophies and being sacked after 7 months like Roy Hodgson at Liverpool?
Brattbakk…we will never know if Hodgson would have won something if he had been given 3 years in the job..The fact remains Rodgers had 3+ years, won nothing, got sacked.
….but I will concede he could be considered by some as the 2nd least successful manager in living memory. 🙂
Rodgers will go down in history as an historic Celtic manager because of that invincible season, nothing will take that away from him.
He needed a certain type of player to play his system and the board latterly failed to provide him with players of that calibre. Rodgers found it hard to adapt his system to suit the players available to him, In his last season he was left with a collection of unhappy and disgruntled players and limited fringe guys by a Board, who to their shame clearly wanted rid of him, but hadn’t the guts to be upfront about that.
Will the board go down in history for providing the invincible season micmac?
We really need to make our mind up if that is success or not!
I’m not sure this club could survive another calamitous appointment like Brendan Rogers…. we need more brilliant managers like Wilfried ‘trust ze programme’ Nancy, Liam ‘there’s no denying Rangers are the best team in Scotland’ Brady and Lou ‘a tenner both ways’ Macari.
Some individuals get so blinded by their own prejudices that they can’t make a rational assessment of anything…. Mmmmm – isn’t there another group of peepul at whose door we usually lay identical charges?
After Jock Stein, BR is Celtic’s most successful manager. Maybe he deserves a statue.
What’s wrong with some of the Celtic supporters? BR delivered the lot and all yous go on about is him jumping ship for the mighty Leicester, losing a cup final to a strong Aberdeen and failing to beat the European giants Almaty over 2 legs before being banished to Saudi earning tax free millions Grow up guys the man is a legend lmfao ?
God bless Brendan,a true Celtic legend , excellent article.
Board apologists can do one.
Volp…You mean the board that gave the job to Rodgers?
Either the board are a liability or they went out and employed the greatest football manager in the history of the universe.
You cant have it both ways mate.
Ffs! The green hun is talking more shite
Stop calling me hun…I’m not yer wife or your boyfriend!
Rodgers was a great Celtic manager with a great record, it went wrong at the end of his tenure twice, whether it’s fair or not he’ll split opinion because of that. Being best in Scotland isn’t guaranteed for Celtic but that’s the job and Rodgers done it very well. He has my respect.
Very fair and sensible comment Brattbakk – that’ll never catch on lol!
Winning a domestic treble without losing a match is unprecedented as was winning back to back trebles at the time (and only Lenny has done it since – with one of the trophies already secured by Brendan) so his place in our history is rightfully assured for those achievements (amongst his many others) and NO-ONE can, or should even try to, take those away from him
However, I have lost pretty much all respect for him for the way he walked out the second time around – he sat in his opening press conference on 23 June 2023 and said “I’ve signed for three years and I guarantee you I’ll be here for three years – unless I get emptied before that as they say up here” and if you make that statement you honour it come what may.
It doesn’t matter if he felt (probably rightly) that the Board weren’t backing him etc – spitting the dummy and throwing your toys out of the pram is unprofessional – all he had to do was what exactly Glasner has done at Palace – make your ire known then confirm you’ll be leaving at the end of the season. That way no-one can complain – his ego got the better of him and it does look like no club of substance wants him now which is a shame as he is undoubtedly a very talented manager.
If winning every trophy without losing a single game is now considered a non achievement by some fans, I’d question what then is an achievement in Scotland? If you can’t get joy and appreciate that, what’s the point. I personally am not a huge fan of Rodgers, I think he cuts and runs when the going gets tough, but I respect what he done as a manager for us and certainly appreciate it. Growing up during the baron years, I still remember the hurt of achieving nothing most seasons, Rodgers gave us another moment in Celtic’s long and glorious history than can get locked into the history books, you can’t take that away from him.