ISTANBUL, TURKIYE - NOVEMBER 27: Ferencvaros head coach Robbie Keane speaks during the post-match press conference after the UEFA Europa League week 5 match between Fenerbahce and Ferencvaros at Chobani Stadium in Istanbul, Turkiye, on November 27, 2025. (Photo by Oguz Yeter/Anadolu via Getty Images)
Dermot Desmond, alone on the Celtic board, appears to be the one driving the Robbie Keane decision.
That is what the reporting suggests. Desmond has held talks with Keane, and all the major outlets have reported that Celtic’s largest shareholder has narrowed the shortlist to Keane and Martin O’Neill. Desmond is due to meet both O’Neill and Keane as the managerial process reaches its decisive stage.
So let us be clear about what is happening here.
If Robbie Keane is appointed, this will not be some broad, carefully considered, institution-wide strategic decision. It will not be the product of a modern football department, a rigorous international search, a properly defined recruitment process or a board demonstrating collective imagination.
It will be Dermot Desmond’s call. And everyone else will be expected to live with it.
That is the problem.
Because Desmond does not have to live with it in the way others will. He sits in Ireland, insulated from the daily flak, insulated from the fury, insulated from the supporters outside Celtic Park, insulated from the demonstrations, the banners, the statements, the poisoned atmosphere and the long, cold grind of another civil war inside the club.
The rest of the Celtic board will not be so lucky. They are here. They will have to own this. They will have to sit in the directors’ box. They will have to walk through the front door. They will have to face the meetings, the questions, the protests, the supporter groups and the consequences of a decision which may not even be theirs in any meaningful sense.
That is why anyone inside Celtic Park with a shred of self-preservation should be trying to stop this now. Not tomorrow. Not after the announcement. Not when the banners go up. Now. Because once this appointment is made, there may be no putting the fire out.
I have written already about why Robbie Keane should think very carefully before taking this job. I meant it. He would be the one on the touchline. He would be the one catching the lightning. He would be the one trying to manage a club where a significant part of the support did not want him before he took his first training session.
But this is not only a warning to Keane, who should be smart enough to know this. He is the wrong moral fit for this club, and for the assorted dickheads who have asked me a question on that in the last few days, there’s your answer.
Yes, the Celtic job is a position that should not go to someone who has made questionable personal choices of his sort. Celtic is not just another football club. The morality of the man who takes that job matters because it reflects on all of us who that person is. And working in Israel for a pro-regime club is bad enough; his second job was with a club run by one of the cabinet ministers of Viktor Orban’s government.
I cannot put it more bluntly than this; hiring him would be a moral disgrace.
So this piece is a warning to the board.
If they allow Desmond to push this through, they are strapping themselves in for the nuclear detonation, and they will be well inside the blast radius. The principal shareholder may make the call, but they will carry the consequences.
And what consequences they could be.
There are appointments that disappoint people. There are appointments that split opinion. There are appointments that cause arguments for a few days and then fade once football begins. This is not that. This is not a normal football disagreement about tactics, CVs, style of play or whether someone knows the league.
This has a moral dimension which the board seems determined either to ignore or underestimate. Fan groups have already made their objections plain, with banners and statements targeting both Keane and the Desmond’s.
So, nobody can say they were not warned. Nobody can pretend they did not know. Nobody can stand there later, wide-eyed and wounded, wondering why the reaction was so fierce.
This is the extraordinary thing about Celtic now.
The club spent the last part of the season telling supporters it was listening. It allowed people to believe change was coming. It talked, in that vague corporate way, about lessons learned and relationships to be rebuilt.
Then the season ended. What followed?
Renewed action against Green Brigade members. A managerial shortlist apparently built around familiar names. Shaun Maloney interviewed for a major football-operations role. Now Robbie Keane potentially being pushed by Desmond despite the obvious backlash.
If these people wanted to convince supporters that “listening mode” was a cynical joke, they could hardly have designed a better sequence of events.
This is not listening. This is provocation.
It may not be intended that way. Perhaps that is the truly frightening part. Perhaps these people genuinely do not understand what they are doing. Perhaps they have sat in the same rooms, spoken to the same people, listened to the same advisers and convinced themselves that this will all blow over once the team wins a few games.
That would be a catastrophic misreading of the moment.
Because trust is already broken. The relationship between board and support is already toxic. The Green Brigade situation has already poured petrol on embers that were still glowing. The communication vacuum has already allowed suspicion to harden. The managerial search has already confirmed the suspicion that Celtic are trapped in the same old closed circle. Keane would not arrive into a calm club.
He would arrive into a thermonuclear shitstorm.
And if the board thinks the answer is simply to let the manager carry that storm alone, then it is even more contemptible than I thought. Because that is exactly what will not happen.
Desmond will remain above the immediate fallout. The board will offer stiff silence. The manager will be sent out to talk about football, unity, ambition and moving forward. The supporters will not be in the mood for any of it.
Everyone at Celtic Park will feel the heat from this and the demonstrations of last season will be small fry compared to what this guy will get every week, and what they in turn will have to put up with every single week.
I’m going to write about the fans in more detail later, but those inside the club who still care, those who still possess some instinct for institutional survival, need to act before this becomes irreversible.
They need to tell Desmond the truth. They need to tell him this is not a normal appointment. They need to tell him this is not merely unpopular. They need to tell him this risks engulfing the whole club. Because it does.
Celtic have enough problems already.
We need a manager. We need a football structure. We need a sporting director. We need a rebuild. We need Champions League qualification. We need commercial ambition. We need governance reform. We need communication. We need unity.
We do not need an ideological war starting on day one of the new manager’s tenure. What kind of board, looking at that list, decides the missing ingredient is more division? What sort of club is this where the board considers an appointment so completely out of step with the wishes of a large part of the fan-base when they could hire almost any other manager in football and side-step this particular landmine?
What kind of leadership group, after last season, thinks Celtic can afford to begin the summer with another avoidable rupture? What kind of serious football club watches supporters warn them, clearly and repeatedly, that this road leads to fire, and keeps walking down it anyway? That is what I cannot get past.
This is avoidable. That is what makes it so unforgivable.
Nobody is forcing Celtic to appoint Robbie Keane. Nobody is holding a gun to the club’s head. Nobody is saying there are no other coaches in world football. Nobody is saying the only alternatives are Keane or no one. This is a choice.
If it happens, it will happen because the people in charge chose it. And every board member who stays silent while it happens will own it.
Not just Desmond. All of them.
That is what they need to understand. Silence is not neutrality. Going along for the ride is not innocence. Sitting there while someone else drives the club towards a cliff does not absolve you because your hands were not on the wheel.
If you are in that boardroom and you know this is wrong, say so. For God’s sake, shout it from the rooftops. Make it a resignation issue. Threaten to walk away and tell the world why. Tell the whole of Scottish football that the principal shareholder of the club has gone full-on arsonist and intends to burn the whole thing down.
If you understand the scale of the backlash, say so. If you see the damage coming, say so. If you care about Celtic more than you care about staying in the good books of the man who dominates the room, say so.
Because if they do not speak now, they should not expect sympathy later. They will deserve every hard question. Every protest. Every demand for accountability. Every accusation that they saw the danger and lacked the courage to intervene.
This is the moment for someone inside Celtic Park to show a spine.
Someone has to tell Desmond no. Preferably all of them together. They have to tell him that if he makes this decision he owns it because none of them will stand behind it.
Someone has to say that the club is bigger than one man’s preference, bigger than one billionaire’s instincts, bigger than a decision taken from a distance by someone who will not have to stand in front of the people it enrages.
Celtic is not Dermot Desmond’s private plaything.
It is not a family office project. It is not a little Irish appointment bureau where the same familiar names get recycled until the end of time. It is a football club with a global support, a volatile present and a future that requires seriousness.
This is not serious. This is reckless.
And if those around Desmond care about the club, about their own positions, about the fragile unity of the support, or even about basic self-preservation, they need to stop this before it becomes the story of the summer.
Because once it starts, it will not be contained.
The anger will not stay neatly inside one section of the support. It will bleed into everything. Every bad result. Every poor performance. Every transfer delay. Every board statement. Every silence. Every European setback.
It will become the weather. That is what they are risking. A season played under a black cloud unlike anything they’ve ever seen before. A manager starting with half the support already braced against him, and no prospect of turning them around. A board already despised deciding to stress test things until something breaks.
They can still avoid it. They can still step back. They can still choose a manager who does not arrive with this level of baggage, this level of division and this level of immediate fury.
But the clock is ticking. If they let this happen, they should not pretend later that the giant consequences of it were unforeseeable. They are entirely foreseeable.
Stop this. Whatever leverage you have, stop this now.
Before it’s too late.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

The Celtic Board will do SFA. Primarily because they are a bunch of of cowards who are afraid to stand up to DD and secondary because they are a bunch of venal nonentities who will never again obtain such a lucrative sinecure as the Celtic perk in the rest of their professional careers. They will bury their heads hoping the storm passes over and anyway DD was the lightning rod that sparked it off will be their cry. Weasels the lot of them.
James, you know just as well as all of us do, that there is no one in that boardroom with the balls to take on DD. He calls the shots and the sycophants on the board are only too ready to do his bidding.
I shake my head in despair.
This dickhead would like to know …which Board member(s) should approach Desmond with your views…’Cos that ain’t gonny happen..This dickhead would also like to know where you get your ” anti RK ” numbers from…You went from. ” “significant ” to ” half ” in your article…I’m in a group of 8 supporters …and 2 don’t want RK…the other 6 don’t mind…And finally…this dickhead would like to know…A) Who would be your managerial choice ?…and B ) Will you be giving up your ST ?
Oh my James, you don’t half come out with some incendiary and dramatic comments! But the truth of the matter is that all your histrionics will not alter the situation one iota, because the more you demonise DD, the deeper he will dig his heels in, that is his nature.
That is not to say that I don’t agree with you because I actually do. I have supported Celtic man and boy for nearly 70 years and I’ve lived through the highs and the lows, the despair and the elation, so I know that we’re now living in dangerous times with DD (Demonic Desmond) having a stranglehold on our club which he will not easily relinquish. I’ve already stated in previous posts what I think needs to happen, so it’s up to others to take up the gauntlet and challenge DD! The time for keyboard protests is over, it’s now time for direct action.
Incidentally, I do believe that you’re exaggerating the level of support against the appointment of Robbie Keane, as I don’t believe that it’s half of the support which is what you state. I am aware that it’s a large minority, of which I am one, but I don’t believe that it’s anywhere near 50%, but I stand to be corrected
I understand why fans want to renew season tickets .
But a better way to protest would be to cancel Celtic TV , you can cancel and subscribe anytime you like.
Protest made but nothing lost long term.
Dosent really affect them, the tv is hosted by a 3rd party not the club.
Can somebody educate me.
Our fans don’t want Robbie Keane.
Why!!!! Did he fight on the front line when the Israelis took Gaza?
Was he in the Israeli air force when they bombed Palestine?
To my knowledge he worked in Israel doing the only job he knows which as far as I know is well removed from war,strife and politics.
On that basis why is Tucal taking England to the world cup?why was Klopp at Liverpool?why did the same fa base who idolised Hinkel,Thomas,Kuhn etc.now demonise Keane for working in an unpopular country.
Given this,the aforementioned Germans should have been restricted to working in their own country as after all they come from the same place as Adolf Hitler.
As I said ,I would love someone to advise me on what horrific acts he was responsible during his time in Israel and Hungary.
If these reasons are valid then I will also join the anti Keane movement readily.
The bottom line is politics and football have zilch in common.
Given what has taken place in gaza, would you take the job, any job in isreal and face your family and friends on your return
Sorry James – but what comes across here is personal hatred for Keane. I agree with Terence Nova that you are seriously overestimating the anti Keane numbers in our support (and certainly so for those who share your reasons for not wanting Keane).
A better argument here would be to focus solely on the process and not the candidate. But this would also require accepting that activating a manager search had to wait until the season ended (otherwise we would almost certainly have undermined the efforts of MON).
If Keane gets the job and starts winning he will be supported. If he starts losing he will be barracked. Either way I don’t think he will ever be loved.
Countless campaigns and supporter initiatives later, and the board and Desmond are still operating exactly as they always have. If those efforts were going to produce meaningful change, we’d have seen some evidence of it by now.
The uncomfortable reality is that supporters continue to fund the club regardless of their dissatisfaction. Until that changes substantially, why would the people in charge feel compelled to change?
Given their level of renumeration they’ll hang on for years to come. The only real leverage we have is via our wallets under this regime. Desmond is a sociopathatic billionaire who holds grudges and is going nowhere unless the share price tanks.
The board members had to pass DD’s sycophancy test to obtain their coveted positions, so in what universe would they now suddenly turn against him?
Agree, they are a collection of shivers looking for a spine to run up.
Where are the rest of the shareholders? Why aren’t they involved in the appointment? Can it really be the case they are happy to let Desmond make a mistake this monumental? Their silence damns them all.
There is absolutely no way footy fans can pick a football manager not now not ever…
But boards occasionally have to show a bit of common sense as well…
Personally I just want success for CELTIC not myself, certainly not the fuckin board but as I said CELTIC FC…
If Keane delivers it that’ll do for me !
There is no way that Lucan is gonna risk his £17,000 weekly wage thieving by going against Desmond…
Nor The Butchers Apron loving Wilson who trousers around £120,000 for rocking up at three monthly board meetings…
I guess if most of had these benefits we fuckin well wouldn’t either !
We are not going to be satisfied with whatever manager that DD decides on, simply because he is his choice and not ours. However we are stuck with it, we are Celtic supporter and we will continue to support the team come what may. So, if it is Robbie Keane, then I’m prepared to give him the benefit of the doubt and hope that he can bring us success.
“ It will be Dermot Desmond’s call. And everyone else will be expected to live with it.”
And that’s it in a nutshell. He’s the boss, it’s his ball and he decides. And everyone else falls in line ( probably to tell him how wonderful he is and what a great appointment he’s made!) It’s Celtic under the Despot Dermot Desmond! That’s how it works!