GLASGOW, SCOTLAND - DECEMBER 03: Celtic Interim Manager Martin O'Neill (L) and Interim Coach Shaun Maloney at full time during a William Hill Premiership match between Celtic and Dundee at Cetlic Park, on December 03, 2025, in Glasgow, Scotland. (Photo by Craig Foy/SNS Group via Getty Images)
What the hell is happening at Celtic, and specifically with Martin O’Neill?
That is the question more and more of us seem to be asking ourselves just now, and the reason we are asking it is simple enough. Something does not feel right.
I do not mean one failed transfer or one silly rumour that will be forgotten in a week. I mean something deeper than that. Something is unsettled. Something that keeps tugging at the back of your mind no matter how hard you try to dismiss it.
You know the feeling. The one you tell yourself is probably nothing. The one you try to brush aside. The one that keeps coming back anyway.
And when your instincts keep whispering the same thing over and over again, eventually you have to stop and listen.
Perhaps that is my Ginger Witch side speaking. Perhaps years of following Celtic have sharpened those instincts. Whatever it is, I cannot shake the feeling that there is more going on behind the scenes at Celtic Park than any of us are being told.
The latest speculation around Martin O’Neill has only deepened that feeling.
Now, before anyone starts, I know rumours are rumours. Football is full of whispers, half-truths and stories that vanish as quickly as they appear. But the latest one feels different, and it feels different because it did not come from some random account on social media chasing clicks. It did not come from a bloke in the pub saying his pal knows someone who once delivered a parcel to Celtic Park.
It came from Graham Spiers.
That matters.
Spiers knows Martin O’Neill personally. He understands how he thinks. He has known him for years. So, when someone like that suggests O’Neill could potentially walk away from his role because of issues involving Shaun Maloney, Mark Fotheringham and perhaps other things we know nothing about, every Celtic supporter is going to pay attention.
And every Celtic supporter is going to ask the same question.
What the hell is happening at Celtic?
Because if Martin O’Neill is genuinely unhappy, before any of the hard work of this summer has even begun, then this is not some minor detail to be brushed aside.
This is Martin O’Neill we are talking about. The man who rescued Celtic last season. The man who gave us one of the greatest modern title wins in the club’s history. The man who brought belief roaring back into Paradise.
He is not just another football figure. He is a massive part of Celtic’s story. Part of Celtic’s soul. He is a club icon.
So, if somebody with that level of affection for the club is supposedly considering walking away because of internal issues, supporters have every right to be worried.
Deeply worried.
Because people do not just walk away from Celtic. Not people like Martin O’Neill. Not unless something has gone badly wrong.
What makes all this more troubling is that it does not exist in isolation.
That is the thing that keeps bothering me. It is never just one story. Never just one departure. Never just one disagreement. When enough odd things start happening around a football club, eventually you have to stop looking at them one by one and start seeing them as part of a bigger picture.
Take Gavin Strachan. His departure surprised a lot of supporters. Maybe it was purely career-related. Maybe he simply felt it was time for a new challenge. That happens in football. But when I place it beside everything else that has happened recently, I cannot help wondering whether there was more to it.
Then I think about John Kennedy. A man who gave years of his life to Celtic. A loyal servant. Somebody who practically grew up inside the club. He moved on too. Again, that may be entirely understandable in itself. But when long-serving football people keep disappearing from the building, surely it is reasonable to ask why.
Not accuse. Not invent conspiracies. Just ask. “Why?”
What is changing inside Celtic? What atmosphere exists behind closed doors? What conversations are taking place that supporters know nothing about? Because here is the truth. We know almost nothing.
That is not a small part of the problem. It is a huge part of the problem.
Celtic supporters live in a near-permanent information blackout when it comes to the running of our football club.
Michael Nicholson remains one of the most invisible chief executives I can remember. Honestly, when was the last time supporters heard him openly discuss the direction of the club? When was the last substantial interview? When was the last time he spoke directly to supporters and explained what the actual vision is?
I genuinely struggle to answer those questions.
Then there is Dermot Desmond. The major power broker behind Celtic. The man whose influence stretches across everything. Yet supporters hear very little from him too. Almost nothing, in fact. Silence. Always silence.
That silence may be comfortable for those inside the boardroom, but outside it creates frustration, suspicion and unease.
Football supporters are not mushrooms. We do not enjoy being kept in the dark. We do not enjoy having to piece together fragments and rumours and second-hand suggestions just to form some idea of what might be happening at our own club.
We invest too much for that.
We travel across the country and across continents. We spend money we probably should not spend. We organise our weekends, our holidays and our moods around Celtic. So, when uncertainty begins to gather around the club, supporters deserve something more than vague silence and nervous guesswork.
Instead, we are left trying to build a picture from scraps. A rumour here. A departure there. Another report somewhere else.
And slowly an uncomfortable mood takes shape.
Not necessarily a full-blown crisis. Not panic stations. But something unsettling all the same. My Ginger Witch instincts keep coming back to the same thought. Something feels off.
The energy around the club feels different. The atmosphere feels different. And maybe I am not the only supporter sensing that. In fact, I suspect I am not, and that may be why stories like this spread so quickly. They tap into concerns that are already there. Concerns supporters have quietly been carrying for months.
What if the issues inside Celtic are more serious than we realise?
What if there are disagreements over structure, recruitment, influence, decision-making or power? Again, I am not claiming to know. None of us know.
That is precisely the point. We do not know.
And that lack of knowledge is fertile ground for uncertainty. The vacuum gets filled one way or another. It always does. If Celtic will not explain what is happening, then people will create their own explanations. That is human nature.
What worries me most is that Martin O’Neill’s name has now entered the conversation.
Because he is not someone who casually throws his toys out of the pram. He is not someone who craves attention. He is not someone looking for headlines. He is a serious football man, a man of standards, a man who has seen everything the game can throw at him. If someone like that becomes frustrated enough to consider walking away, then surely the people running Celtic should be asking themselves some very difficult questions.
Maybe there is nothing to this. Maybe in a few weeks the story disappears.
Maybe Martin O’Neill stays exactly where he is and everybody moves on. I sincerely hope that is what happens. But hope and certainty are two very different things.
Right now, certainty is in short supply around Celtic.
That is why supporters are uneasy. That is why the questions keep multiplying. That is why every rumour suddenly feels weightier than it should. Because when communication disappears, suspicion takes its place.
That is football. That is life.
And Celtic have allowed that uncertainty to grow.
The frustrating part is that much of this should be avoidable. A little transparency. A little engagement. A little communication. Those things go a long way. Instead, supporters are left staring into the fog and trying to work out what lies ahead.
As I sit here thinking about it all, I keep coming back to the same conclusion. Maybe there is no fire. Maybe there is only smoke.
But there is certainly smoke.
Enough smoke to make supporters nervous. Enough smoke to make them curious. Enough smoke to make them wonder whether there are serious issues inside Celtic Park that have not yet fully emerged into public view.
I hope my ginger witch instincts are wrong this time. I really do. Celtic should be entering this season from a position of strength and confidence, not from a place of uncertainty, confusion and whispers involving some of the most respected figures connected to the club.
Yet until somebody starts giving answers, the questions will keep growing. And supporters will keep asking them. Because we love this club too much not to.
For now, all any of us can do is watch, listen and trust those instincts that have served us before. Something feels unsettled at Celtic. Maybe soon we will discover there is nothing to fear. Or maybe the winds blowing around Paradise really are warning us that a bigger storm is building beyond the horizon.
—-
This week, I lost my best friend, my dog Ajsik (Ice).
He was a cute, fluffy, friendly, full of life wee gem who always cheered me up.
I loved him dearly and I will miss him terribly.
I rescued him from a shelter five years ago and tried to give him the best life I could.
If you can, and you feel like you’d like to, can I ask if you will give a wee donation to whatever is your nearest shelter, in his memory, and so other animals like Ice can have a chance at a decent life?
Thank you.
Paulina.


Dermot Desmond is the problem. He needs to go. Or we stagnate.
He’s only the tip of the iceberg mate. We need that place cleared out.
There is plenty to fear, our inability to do ANY deals says it all. This is deliberate, we are trying to throw it away again just like we did last season nearly. F them all
I already have the utmost respect for Martin O’Niell, if he chose to take a principled stance and walk away from Celtic I’d respect that also because he’s in danger of being the one sacrificed, his legacy is on the line. It might cost him some friends but if decides he has to walk then it’ll be the right call.
More likely, I think he’s using Spiers to influence the board and try to wake them up. Hopefully they’ll react and at least try to prepare for the coming season.
Last season was a test to see how incompetent we could be and still win the league, if mainstream idiots like Keevins understand the problem then maybe Desmond is the last person who doesn’t. Someone tell him in a way that he thinks he thought of it.
Ps. Sorry about Ajsik, dogs are the best.
Sorry to hear about your wee dog Paulina, that’s tragic news.
On MON, it looks as though the board are putting him in an almost impossible position. Apparently gagging him from speaking about certain issues by writing it into his contract, whilst at the same time strangling him by delaying the contracts of his backroom staff. At the same time MON will be the only person at the club wheeled out to face those very questions by the media. The stress that will cause him at this stage of his life will be unbearable, and unforgivable from the board to repay him in this way for rescuing their season.
It would be no surprise if he is thinking of walking away now, and you would think his wife will be thinking the same way.
Something stinks at Celtic Park, and we all know that it’s coming from the direction of MN,C McK DD and BW. If MON walks then it’s over, the gloves are off, and a real war is going to break out.
The Celtic support have shown loyalty to the club through a lot of bad times, but these people are disrespecting so many people connected with the club, and are stretching the support’s patience to breaking point.
I think that MON should just walk away now and leave himself free to speak out. He doesn’t need the money and at his time of life he certainly doesn’t need the aggro that seems to come with managing Celtic nowadays. Just leave Martin, and enjoy the rest of your life and let DD sort out this mess of his doing
I said at the time that Martin should’ve gone out in all his glory and at the top as they’d think fuck all of throwing him under a bus…
Look at the confidence in the interviews of McInnes and Gillespie at Liebrox yesterday….
They are gonna smash Celtic next year…
If only someone would fuckin smash Lucan !
I said as much a couple of weeks ago that MON was only announced to placate the fans over the World Cup to give the board a break and that soon the chances are there will be an excuse for him not to take up the position.
Hence the reluctance to sign his backroom staff.
It will be the last week of the transfer window we will be scabbling around for a manager and players. this means the money that stays in the bank over this period will accrue a tidy sum.
So sorry to hear about your dog Paulina…
We have a cat but lost Mikey on the road on 14th September 2015 and it still hurts all those years later, we got his ‘son’ Seamus the day he was laid to rest and he gets outey walky in the garden on a lead as we couldn’t go through that again…
Animals are better than a helluva lot of people for sure !
There is a game at play here. DD didnt get what he wanted as the board went with MON ,now he is playing the block with finance his 37.4 being enough to interfer with wages ect for MON team. This shit show sees martin walk and DD gets his man, one MR keane
Very sorry to read about your wee dog, Paulina.
But reflect on this – you rescued him. You gave him food, shelter, medical attention, lots of love, and the best life he could have. You can’t do more than that.
And maybe the legend of the Rainbow Bridge might be true? Wouldn’t that be nice?
HH
INIQUITOUS IV?
Could the one man board be delaying the contracts of SM and MF as an excuse not to start the recruitment process? Reading reports from the clubs whose players Celtic are supposed to interested in, and they’re saying they’ve had contact from the other mentioned clubs but not a peep from Celtic.
Sorry to hear about Ajsik Paulina.
I got a wee Staffy puppy for my 10th Christmas and he was my best friend for the next 14 years, before I lost him to cancer.
I named him Chang (though can’t remember why). He’s been gone now for almost 40 years, but he still pops into my thoughts regularly. We never truely lose that which we have loved.
With regard to MON, I only became aware of the rumours yesterday.
The man is the epitome of professional. However, I hope his evident intelligence will overcome his love for the ‘tic to prevent him taking on what, seemingly, appears to increasingly be a poison chalice.
Sorry to here about your dog Paulina…he looks adorable!