There are some transfer stories that make me smile. There are others that make me sigh. Then there are the ones which leave me wondering whether somebody inside Celtic Park has forgotten where we actually stand in football’s food chain.
The latest whispers from Italy tell us that Celtic have been linked with Lazio winger Matteo Cancellieri. Reports suggest he could cost even more than Kasper Høgh did, and that is precisely where my Ginger Witch instincts begin to kick in.
I know a bargain when I see one, and I recognise clever recruitment when it unfolds in front of me. Kasper Høgh was exactly that. Celtic identified a player with enormous potential, moved decisively, completed the deal and brought in someone who looks capable of making a genuine difference.
That is the kind of business I want to see repeated. It is the model and the path Celtic should follow, rather than this endless parade of glamorous names which appear to exist more comfortably in newspaper headlines than anywhere near Celtic Park.
I simply cannot understand why we continue to hear that Celtic have been linked with players who sit miles beyond what the club has historically been prepared to pay.
“Celtic have been linked with…” “Celtic are monitoring…” “Celtic are interested…” “Celtic are watching…”
Wonderful. But are Celtic actually buying anyone? That is the only sentence I truly care about.
When I read that Lazio reportedly values Matteo Cancellieri at a figure higher than the fee Celtic paid for Kasper Høgh, I immediately ask the obvious question: are Celtic genuinely prepared to spend that kind of money?
Because if the answer is no, why are we even standing in the queue?
There comes a point when common sense has to prevail. Celtic cannot stroll into a conversation with a club from one of Europe’s biggest leagues, wave around £3 million or £4 million and expect them to thank us politely before handing over one of their players.
Football simply does not work like that anymore.
Italian clubs know the value of their assets. Agents know the value of their clients. The market knows exactly what talented young footballers are worth.
If Lazio believes Cancellieri commands a fee deep into the high seven figures, or perhaps even eight figures, Celtic has two choices.
Either decide that he is genuinely worth that amount and pay it, or walk away before wasting everybody’s time.
That is not negativity. It is realism.
I would applaud Celtic if the club suddenly decided it was prepared to spend £8 million or even £10 million on exactly the right player. If the recruitment team truly believes someone is worth it, go and get him. Do not hesitate, negotiate for six weeks or leak endless stories about progress. Complete the deal and move on.
But history tells me that this is not normally how Celtic operates. History tells me that we bargain, negotiate and hope circumstances change.
Sometimes that approach works brilliantly. Sometimes it produces another Kasper Høgh, and sometimes patience delivers outstanding value. But it only works when the selling club is willing to negotiate.
If Lazio has no intention of significantly reducing its asking price to a point where we are realistic buyers, then the pursuit feels faintly ridiculous from the beginning.
Why spend days or weeks chasing something which is almost certainly out of reach when there are talented footballers across Scandinavia, Belgium, Austria, Switzerland, Eastern Europe and countless other markets who could strengthen Celtic immediately?
Those are the markets where Celtic has traditionally found success. They are the places where our recruitment department should be working day and night, because that is where intelligent scouting can beat wealth.
That is where our competitive advantage lies. It does not lie in trying to outmuscle clubs from Serie A.
I keep returning to Kasper Høgh because his signing should teach Celtic something. It should remind everyone inside the club exactly why that transfer succeeded. Preparation, conviction, decisiveness and realistic ambition. We knew what he would cost us but we into the deal prepared to pay the money for once.
This feels like one of those pursuits which could drag on and on only for us to realise, too late in the day to go shopping for an alternative, that the deal won’t work.
I am not saying Celtic should never aim high; if I thought we were ready and willing to fork out another eight figure fee I would be over the moon. Every supporter enjoys seeing exciting names linked with their club.
I certainly do, for a few minutes. Then reality taps me on the shoulder.
Dreams do not win league titles, qualify for the Champions League or strengthen the squad before crucial European qualifiers. Players do.
Real players. Signed players. Players wearing green and white Hoops instead of appearing endlessly in transfer gossip columns.
Sometimes I honestly think Celtic falls in love with the romance of the chase: the speculation, mysterious negotiations and excitement surrounding a potential deal.
But I would rather fall in love with completed transfers.
They are infinitely more satisfying.
Every hour spent pursuing a player who is probably beyond Celtic’s financial reach is an hour which could be spent securing somebody else. Somebody realistic, attainable and desperate to wear the Celtic jersey. Somebody whose club would meet us in a realistic place in terms of the fee. That is where successful recruitment begins.
Not in fantasy, wishful thinking or newspaper headlines. It begins with understanding exactly what your budget can achieve and acting accordingly.
If Celtic genuinely intends to transform itself into a club capable of paying eight-figure transfer fees regularly, then wonderful. I will celebrate that ambition and welcome it with open arms. But if that is not the plan, and almost everything we have seen in recent years suggests it probably is not, then I would rather Celtic get real.
My Ginger Witch heart longs for ambition. It always will. But my footballing head longs for intelligence, and the two can exist together. Kasper Høgh proved exactly that. He arrived because Celtic moved smartly rather than recklessly.
The deal made sense, the player was attainable and everybody involved understood what success looked like before the negotiations began. That is the blueprint.
Not endless links or impossible pursuits.
Celtic must stop chasing shadows.
It is time to start catching players.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.
