Chris Sutton is right; Maeda’s EPL move could end in disaster.

I have written a couple of pieces about Daizen Maeda and his proposed transfer to Ipswich. From Celtic’s perspective, I believe the position is straightforward. If the reported £10 million fee is accurate, then it represents good business for a player entering the final year of his contract.

But, as I’ve said, there is another side to this which deserves much closer examination.

What exactly is Maeda doing?

He has made no secret of his desire to play in the English Premier League. That is his ambition, and there is nothing wrong with it. Players are entitled to have dreams, to test themselves elsewhere and to pursue opportunities they believe will fulfil them.

But as Paulina has said, and I have repeated, surely the identity of the club matters? Is he really aware of what it is he’s about to sign up for? I wrote last night about the issues which might befall Ipswich, but let’s take a deeper dive here.

Surely the manager matters. The style of football must matter. The likelihood of playing regularly matters, and so does the direction in which the club appears to be travelling. You would think all of those things would matter as much as the name of the league printed on the fixtures.

Sutton is right; Ipswich could be back in the Championship within a year. That is not an insult. It is the reality facing almost every newly promoted side entering the richest and most unforgiving league in world football.

Maeda could sign his contract, fulfil his supposed dream and discover within months that every match is a struggle, his team is trapped near the foot of the table and the entire campaign is defined by avoiding relegation.

Is that really the dream? Is that what he’s worked for?

Or is the Premier League itself now such a powerful brand that some players no longer care what kind of footballing existence awaits them once they get there?

Think about it from that perspective. Branding. Has he fallen for glitzy advertising and hype? The first time he takes the field at Portman Road on a wet Wednesday night against another newly promoted team will it still hold the same glamour?

That is what I find so difficult to understand. If he’s in the English Championship in twelve months grinding it out in a major battle for promotion and relevance, what will he think of the decision he’s about to make?

Let me put it another way; Maeda could sign a Celtic contract extension, remain here for another campaign and continue playing at the top end of the table. He could compete for trophies, play in Europe and enter next summer with his reputation enhanced further.

A year from now, the clubs watching him might be considerably bigger than Ipswich. He could have more choices, not fewer.

He might attract clubs competing higher up the Premier League, teams playing European football or managers whose systems are perfectly suited to his movement, speed and extraordinary pressing ability.

Instead of treating the first offer from England as the fulfilment of the dream, he could wait for an opportunity which actually matches his talent. That is the difference between reaching the Premier League and succeeding in it.

There is an obvious counterargument and let’s be honest about it.

Maeda is 28 years old. Football careers are short, and he may feel he cannot afford to wait another year for an offer which might never come. He may believe this is the moment and that refusing it would mean risking the dream altogether.

I understand that. There are no guarantees that another spectacular season at Celtic would lead to a bigger transfer.

Injury, loss of form or a change of circumstances could close the door. From his perspective, the opportunity is real now, and next summer is only a possibility.

That may be the calculation he is making.

But if that is the case, let us call it what it is. It is not necessarily the perfect footballing move. It is the secure move. It is the move that guarantees Premier League wages and Premier League status today, even if neither is still there twelve months from now.

Perhaps money is the decisive factor.

Again, there is nothing inherently wrong with that. Maeda has every right to maximise his earnings. Footballers have limited careers, and the financial rewards in England dwarf what even a club of Celtic’s size can usually offer. But how much money does a man need before footballing happiness starts to matter more?

Maeda has already enjoyed a career many players would envy. He has played for championship-winning teams in Japan and Scotland. He has won trophies, performed in the Champions League and established himself as a regular international footballer.

He is not moving to secure recognition from his national team or for a global fanbase. He already has that. He is not escaping a club where he cannot get into the side. He is one of the first names on Celtic’s team sheet. He is not leaving an environment where he is undervalued by the support. He is adored here.

So, what exactly is he chasing?

Perhaps it genuinely is nothing more complicated than the Premier League itself. Perhaps playing in that competition has been built up in his mind for so long that the identity of the club has become secondary. He wants to say that he played there, tested himself there and fulfilled that ambition.

But football history is littered with players who dreamed of the Premier League and never found the version of it they imagined, if they got there at all.

A few years ago, Riley McGree chose Middlesbrough over Celtic. At the time, one of the apparent attractions was the belief that they were an ambitious side and would soon be beating the pathway to the Premier League. He is still waiting.

Celtic instead signed Matt O’Riley, who won trophies, played Champions League football, became one of the outstanding players in Scotland and eventually earned a major move to Brighton. Who made the better initial decision?

McGree chose proximity to the Premier League. O’Riley chose a club where he could play, develop, win and perform on a European stage. It was O’Riley who ultimately reached England’s top flight.

That should be a lesson to every player who believes signing for an English club automatically places him on the escalator towards the Premier League. Maeda at least will get there; how long he can stay is a tougher question to answer.

And even O’Riley’s story carries a warning.

He made it to the Premier League, with the perfect player profile, but the promised land did not immediately resemble paradise. Injury disrupted his start at Brighton, his first season was difficult and his career did not continue along the smooth upward path many imagined when he left Celtic. That does not mean his transfer was a mistake. It means the Premier League guarantees nothing.

It guarantees money and attention. It does not guarantee happiness, success, regular football or development.

The idea that arriving there represents the end of the journey is one of the most successful pieces of branding in modern sport. For many players, it is only the beginning of a much harder struggle. Maeda should know that.

He should also understand the difference between playing for a side expected to win almost every week and representing one that may spend most Saturdays without the ball, defending deeply and chasing lost causes.

Some people will say that sounds ideal for his energy and pressing. Perhaps it does. But there is a difference between using those qualities as an attacking weapon and asking a player to spend an entire season running backwards in a relegation fight.

Does that develop him? Does it showcase the full range of his ability? Does it make the larger clubs more likely to want him, or does he risk becoming another good player swallowed by a struggling team?

At Celtic, Maeda has been able to demonstrate what he can do in decisive matches. He has scored goals that won trophies and carried responsibility when the season was on the line. He has played European football against elite opposition and become one of the most important members of a successful side.

At Ipswich, he may find himself judged by how effectively he helps them survive. There is honour in that challenge. It might even suit his personality. But it is not obviously a step forward simply because the league is richer.

That is the mistake too many people make. They compare competitions instead of comparing footballing situations.

Of course, the Premier League is stronger than the Scottish Premiership. Nobody disputes that. But Celtic is a bigger footballing institution than Ipswich and nobody should dispute that either. Celtic offers European competition, the expectation of trophies, enormous crowds and the pressure of having to win.

Ipswich offers the Premier League, greater money and a very real possibility of relegation. That is not an uncomplicated upgrade.

Perhaps Maeda will go there, tear the league apart and earn the bigger move he might have secured by waiting. Perhaps Ipswich will surprise everyone and establish itself comfortably. Perhaps Gary O’Neil will build a system that extracts every ounce of value from him.

All of that is possible. But Maeda is still making a bet.

He is betting that being in the Premier League matters more than the club through which he enters it. He is betting that Ipswich will provide a better platform than another year at Celtic. He is betting that the first available move is better than waiting for the right one.

Maybe he will win that bet.

But he should look carefully at the players who made similar calculations and discovered that England’s top flight was not the promised land they had imagined. A lot of Celtic players have left this club to play in “Big Five” leagues and not found happiness. Edouard went to the EPL and did not exactly set it in on fire. Kuhn is moving on after one year in Italy. And then there is Kyogo who has bounced from club to club since leaving Celtic and now winds up in the MLS where careers go to wrap up.

Riley McGree thought the English route would take him there more quickly and is still waiting. Matt O’Riley did everything the supposedly slower way, reached the Premier League at light speed and then discovered how quickly the dream could become complicated.

There are no guarantees on either path. I understand why Maeda wants to leave. I understand why Celtic is willing to sell, and I understand why £10 million may satisfy everybody at the negotiating table.

What I do not understand is why a player of his quality appears so unconcerned about where he goes, provided that the destination is somewhere inside the Premier League.

He has earned the right to aim higher than that.

Maeda should not merely want to play in the Premier League. He should want to thrive there. He should want a club whose football suits him, a manager who understands him and a project capable of giving his talent the stage it deserves.

He has that right now, of course.

But some people don’t know what they have until it’s gone.

Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.