Earlier in the week, I read Daizen Maeda’s comments on the Premier League and I think too many footballers have started believing in the myth of the league instead of the reality of the clubs who play in it.
There is a difference, and it is a massive one.
The reports suggest that Daizen Maeda would be willing to join any club in England’s so-called top flight. West Ham are currently one of those clubs linked with him; they aren’t even a top flight club. If that really reflects his thinking, then I have to admit it unsettles me far more than the transfer speculation itself.
Not because I cannot understand ambition, and not because I think players should stay at Celtic forever. Football careers are short. Players have families, ambitions, dreams and financial futures to think about. I know all of that, and I would never pretend otherwise.
But that kind of thinking is dangerous. It is simplistic. And, if I am being completely honest, it feels a little foolish.
I have never understood this obsession with saying, “I want to play in the Premier League.” No. Which Premier League club? That is the question that matters.
There is a world of difference between pulling on the shirt of a club fighting for titles and European football, and one desperately trying to survive another season before changing managers for the third time in eighteen months. Those are not the same dream. They are not even close to the same football life.
Football has become obsessed with branding.
The Premier League has become this glittering label that seems to hypnotise players into believing that simply being there represents success.
I do not buy it. I never will.
Maybe that is because I watch football with my heart before I watch it with my eyes, and my Ginger Witch instincts tell me something many agents conveniently forget to mention. The badge matters. The culture matters. The manager matters. The dressing room matters. The expectations matter. The style of football matters.
Everything matters.
Simply existing in England’s top division means absolutely nothing if you spend every Saturday chasing shadows, losing matches, changing coaches every few months and wondering why your career has suddenly stalled.
I look at Celtic, and every season begins with one expectation: win.
Not try. Not finish comfortably in mid-table. Not survive. Win. Win the league. Win the cups. Challenge in Europe. Represent something bigger than yourself.
That pressure creates footballers. It forges character.
Every single match carries meaning. Every point matters. Every dropped result becomes a national discussion. Some people mock Scottish football because they cannot see beyond television contracts and wage bills, but they fail to understand that expectation creates an entirely different psychological environment.
At Celtic, you are expected to deliver. Always. Why would someone willingly exchange that simply to say they play in England?
Then there is Europe, and this is perhaps the strangest part of all. Players spend years dreaming of Champions League nights. Even Europa League nights against top teams. Those electric evenings beneath the Paradise lights. The anthem. The noise. The atmosphere. The entire continent watching.
Why would anyone voluntarily walk away from that to spend their midweeks watching someone else play in Europe?
I genuinely struggle to understand it.
West Ham are being linked today. Tomorrow it may be another club. The names almost do not matter. The principle does, because this idea that “any Premier League club will do” ignores perhaps the most important aspect of modern football.
Systems. So few players pay attention to that.
Managers are all different. Some demand relentless pressing. Others want patient possession. Some require wide forwards who stay high. Others ask them to tuck inside. Some full-backs overlap. Others invert. Some teams attack space. Others attack the ball.
Every tactical decision changes everything.
That means not every brilliant footballer fits every team. Likewise, not every average team knows how to use an exceptional player. This is where I become worried about Maeda, because Daizen Maeda is not merely fast. People who reduce him to pace have never truly watched him.
His greatest gift is chaos. Controlled chaos.
He terrifies defenders because he never stops. His pressing breaks teams psychologically before it breaks them tactically. He hunts, chases, suffocates and forces mistakes other players never even create the possibility of forcing.
That requires a manager who values those qualities. It requires teammates who understand how to react once he wins possession. It requires an entire tactical structure built around collective intensity.
Put him into a slow possession-based side that expects him to stand patiently on the touchline waiting for service, and suddenly people begin asking what happened to Daizen Maeda.
Nothing happened. The system happened.
Football history is littered with players who looked extraordinary in one environment and completely ordinary in another. Not because they suddenly forgot how to play, but because football is not mathematics.
It is chemistry. One ingredient changes and suddenly the whole spell stops working. That is why I always laugh when people say, “If he’s good enough, he’ll succeed anywhere.”
Really? History disagrees.
Some of the world’s greatest players have struggled after transfers that looked perfect on paper. Different dressing room. Different coach. Different tempo. Different expectations. Different role. Everything changes.
I honestly believe football supporters understand this better than many footballers themselves. Supporters watch dozens of matches every season. We see patterns. We recognise systems. We know when a player belongs somewhere.
I watch Maeda and I see someone who belongs in a team that presses like its life depends upon it. A side that attacks relentlessly. A club that expects courage rather than caution. A place where work-rate is celebrated rather than merely tolerated.
If he leaves Celtic, then surely that should be the first question. Not salary. Not postcode. Not league. Can they actually use him properly?
Because otherwise, what is the point?
I also think players underestimate just how enormous Celtic truly is. Perhaps living inside the club every day makes it difficult to appreciate, but from where I stand, looking across Europe, Celtic remain one of football’s genuine institutions.
The supporters. The history. The honours. The identity. The European nights. The expectation. There are countless clubs in richer leagues that would exchange places with Celtic in a heartbeat if they could. Money has convinced people that size can be measured only by turnover. I reject that completely.
Greatness cannot always be counted in pounds. Sometimes it is counted in stories. Sometimes it is counted in memories. Sometimes it is counted in generations who inherited a football club from their grandparents and will pass it to their grandchildren.
Celtic have that. Many clubs never will. So, if I were Daizen Maeda, I would ask myself one simple question: am I moving upwards, or am I just convincing myself I am climbing?
If the right club comes along, one with genuine European ambitions, a style built around relentless intensity and a manager who understands exactly what makes Maeda so devastating, then perhaps a transfer makes perfect sense. As I said, careers are short. Opportunities do not wait forever. I understand that.
But “any Premier League club”? No. That sentence alone worries me, because there is no such thing as just the Premier League. There are twenty completely different football clubs living under one broadcasting umbrella.
Some build players. Some break them. Some elevate careers. Some quietly bury them.
I only hope Daizen Maeda remembers which kind of club he already plays for before he starts dreaming about another one.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

Last night was evidence…as if we needed it…that the premier league is what it is, by the addition of foreign players.
England were made up of a team who mostly play they’re football…or have played their football, in the premier league. The Argentina side moved up a gear when they had to, and blew them out the water towards the end of the match.
I only watch games involving Celtic, and that of my grandsons side, Greenock juniors. I gave up watching boring 0-0 draws between mid/lower leagues sides from the premier league a long time ago. I no longer have any desire to watch it. It’s of no interest to me.
The money is the pull of England, it’s as simple as that…the fact DM declared he’d play for anyone who’ll have him, confirms this.
It’s a league that’s hyped up with the help of Sky TV. Pundits who spend as much time cackling and laughing, are low standard.
Last night I couldn’t wait till Wayne Rooney took the marbles out of his mouth so I could make out what he was saying
Big Joe, as per usual, was honest and articulate.
As you said in an earlier article Paulina, the grass is almost certainly not greener on the other side…maeda be wary !!!!
Maeda is not going to get in a team like Arsenal, Man U, Man C, Liverpool. He is nowhere near that standard. Ange didnt even fancy him for Spurs or he would have left already.
I honestly think West Ham would be a better choice. West Ham could win the championship. Make no mistake the celtic footballing side of last season would not have won the English championship.
West Ham have bigger gates than Celtic and will do even in the championship. He will be in a team expected to win every game.
A team like Brighton or Brentford would be tough for him and he could go like many other Celtic players who never made it down there.
He has done all he can at Celtic…good luck to him.
Maeda has done enough for us to earn his move with our best wishes.
If he is half the player he thinks he is then all will be good.
We are not some sort of footballing pinnacle so more and more players will outgrow us.
Plus if we pull in our horns and decide that a T/O of £150mill is not for us then who are we to hold players back who have bigger horizons that our manager and our Irish Raj?
It will be tumbleweed for the next 4 days — the golf is on so Desmond will not want to be disturbed. I fear our failure to fail last season will make it all the harder this season.
I wonder what the betting markets are saying?
We don’t have a midfield and without a supply the forward line doesn’t matter. Ask Kuhn, OH, Idah and the rest of the forwards who jumped ship.
Maeda is going no matter what, he’s off, it suits him to go and financially it will suit us.
What worries me right now is that Greg Taylor is dropping hints about returning to Celtic. Absolutely no way do I want that to happen, PAOK made a big mistake signing him on and only realised too late that they had a defender who could not defend. He only played a few games because of that fact, before they found him out, and now that he is surplus to requirements he is trying to sneak back into Celtic Park.
God forbid that happens.
Maeda has played at Celtic Park for five and half years, mostly he’s been very influential for Celtic and I wish him well if he moves on. I do agree that he might earn more money, but I’m not sure that Daizen’s speed and workrate will be enough to get him a move to a top half EPL team. He’ll probably be with a team fighting relegation or in the Championship.
Cgreen if you think that Celtic’s problems lie with our M/F, then if Engels and CalMac move on, and you think this Board will replace them with better, then I’m afraid you’re going to be sorely disappointed. The M/F gave Kuhn a lot of good service and got him a move to Italy, where he was found out without that service. Idah was a reasonable success at Celtic and shouldn’t have been sold when he was. OH was a Postecoglou signing that BR didn’t fancy, nothing to do with a lack of service.
The thought of 3 or 4 from Engels, Maeda, Nygren, CalMac and Johnston leaving, fills me with dread. We just don’t seem to have the scouting network, goodwill of agents and realistic spending on transfer fees and wages, to replace that quality.
The chemistry you mention is gone, the team is being broken up, Maeda will earn a shed load more cash and he knows Celtic also only try to get CL football for the cash, they have no ambition in the tournament so I don’t think he will miss being concerned about getting a real drubbing which has happened on a few occasions.