Martin O’Neill spoke to the media today and said that when it comes to signings, Celtic will prioritise quality over quantity.
Many supporters believe we need both. Many of us look at this squad and see something threadbare, a group requiring reinforcements in several key areas and a number of departed players, or players who will, who still have to be replaced.
There is simply no escaping the scale of the work. But if Celtic genuinely has to choose between quality and quantity, then quality is the choice I would make.
We have endured too many transfer windows over the past decade which were characterised by a phrase I use frequently on this site: the appearance of work rather than the kind which actually accomplishes anything.
Too often, the Celtic board has been able to hide behind eight or nine arrivals and present the number itself as proof of progress, even when most of those players were not good enough to improve the team.
Real progress is not measured by how many photographs are taken with scarves above heads. It is measured by whether the football team is better when the window closes than it was when the window opened.
That means signing players who go straight into the side, and not merely because somebody better has already been sold.
Celtic could have entered this season with Callum Osmand and Johnny Kenny carrying much of the responsibility up front. Instead, the club chose to invest heavily in the forward line. We can’t deny that, it’s a fact right in front of us.
I am certain we could have signed several players in the £1 million or £2 million bracket, filled out the squad and declared the job done. But what good would that have done us?
Before long, we would have been back in the same position, asking whether any of them were actually good enough and wondering once again how seriously the people running Celtic take the first team.
We cannot avoid the fact that the squad is still short in several important positions. Martin will know exactly where those weaknesses are and what he needs to strengthen.
But if his intention is to sign proven footballers who do not merely arrive to compete for places, but come in and make those places their own, then perhaps some patience will be worthwhile. I am not saying that I am completely comfortable with the pace of the work. I am not saying everything is fine. I still believe Celtic possesses the resources to deliver quality and quantity.
But if the choice really is between the two, players capable of walking directly into the starting eleven are the way I’d hope we go.
Later tonight, I intend to write about game-changers because that is how I judge a transfer window. When Celtic signed Arne Engels and Auston Trusty, those were players clearly recruited to improve the starting side. Both were established footballers who looked capable of walking into the team.
They took some time to settle, which should not have surprised anyone. But they were signed to become starters, not to sit indefinitely on the bench while everyone waited to discover whether they might eventually become useful.
When you bring in players who look capable of immediately raising the level of the starting eleven, the entire club receives a lift.
That was what characterised Ange Postecoglou’s first summer. Almost every significant arrival went directly into the side and improved what was already there. The team which emerged from that window was substantially stronger than the one which entered it.
Although I have criticised the speed at which Celtic is completing deals this summer, I also remember that three of the most important signings of that Ange window arrived on deadline day.
Jota, Giorgos Giakoumakis and Cameron Carter-Vickers were the signings which helped win the league. Those were three key positions where Celtic obviously needed reinforcements, and all three players were sufficiently good that supporters could immediately understand how they might improve the side.
That was the moment when I knew Celtic had assembled a title-challenging team. The January additions then helped turn that title challenge into a title victory.
I am not arguing that Celtic should wait until the final day again. I sincerely hope we do not. The club needs at least two more players before the Champions League registration deadline if Martin is to have the strongest possible chance of navigating that competition.
I also do not believe Celtic can afford to sell another key player before that work has been completed. But Martin has now put his cards on the table. He has told us what he wants, and he has told us what he expects.
If he gets those players, then there is every chance this summer can still produce the kind of transfer window many of us hoped for.
This morning, I expressed concern that Celtic may be pursuing two parallel recruitment paths, with the priorities of the manager and the priorities of the club not necessarily matching. That concern has not disappeared.
But Martin himself appears to know exactly what he wants, and he increasingly sounds confident that he will get it. I hope that confidence is justified.
Quality over quantity is not a perfect answer to Celtic’s current situation. But we should not allow perfect to become the enemy of good.
There may still be pieces missing when the transfer window closes. Celtic has left itself an enormous job to complete in a very short period, and the people at the top of the club are responsible for allowing so many needs to accumulate.
But imagine that Celtic finishes this window with five or six new players, and every one of them is capable of walking into the starting eleven and improving the overall quality of the side. I will argue later that the two new forwards have already done precisely that.
If the remaining arrivals are of a comparable standard, then there is no reason to regard Martin’s comments today as anything other than a net positive. It may even suggest that Celtic has finally become smarter about recruitment.
The days of filling the squad with projects, punts and players who may become useful several years from now appear to be over, at least as far as the manager is concerned.
A transfer window should not be judged by the volume of activity. It should be judged by the quality of the footballers who arrive and the difference they make. Six genuine first-team players will always be worth more than a dozen hopeful additions who disappear into the squad and contribute nothing.
Celtic still needs numbers. Nobody should pretend otherwise.
But those numbers must also possess quality. Martin O’Neill appears determined that every remaining signing should matter. If Celtic backs him properly and delivers the players he wants, that is a strategy I can support.
Not because quantity is unimportant. Because quantity without quality is only another version of the appearance of work.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

I’m looking forward to Monday night and getting the season underway. The two signings we’ve made look pretty high calibre, the month of August should be the launch pad for the season. There will be incoming and outgoing, there will be competitve games, and by Sept 3rd we’ll know a lot more about the shape we’re in.
Great article but because of years of neglect we need quality And quantity. At least 4 new players have to come in and that’s without losing anyone else.
We have had too many poor transfer windows recently and we are paying the price now, we have 27 players in the 1st team squad with a further 2 out on loan. We can’t keep adding players. We are carrying far too much dead wood. Ralston, Scales, McCowan, Kenny, Bernardo, Balikwisha all need sold. Until the squad is trimmed it appears its one in one out.
I cannot see the PLC board being too happy with the present situation. There they were, coasting along as usual, achieving the square-root of SFA, and earning undeserved fortunes. Enter stage left, Martin. This fella must terrify the eejits on the board, as Big Ange did before him. I’m confident of more big signings being made. When MoN metaphorically slaps these guys, they’ll take it…and they’ll like it!
Hail Hail.
The two signings definitely look quality but we’ve also sold our best player. Signing quality over quantity leaves us exposed to injuries but maybe that’s the chance some of these youngsters need? We’ve been unlucky with the serious injuries we’ve had but there’s a couple of positions whiteout proper back up. We’ve been unlucky need a GK and a LB and replace quickly anyone that leaves. It’s not too bad right now, I’d expected Engels, AJ, Hatate and possibly Nygren to all be away which would’ve been a huge task to replace all them, it still might happen but I’m at least excited to see our new boys competitively.
That’s a mess, hopefully it’s clear what I was trying to type. Predictive text.