I have heard two estimates from journalists regarding the number of players Celtic intends to sign before the transfer window closes. One says the club will attempt to bring in four more. Another says it will try to sign six.
Six would get us closer, but that figure apparently excludes further departures.
Should Celtic attempt to get through the rest of this window with only four more additions, we will not even maintain the squad strength we possess right now once the expected exits are taken into account.
Six is the minimum number of signings this squad requires because we are no longer talking merely about improving the starting team.
We are talking about rebuilding the squad. Fifteen players who were at Celtic last season have now left. That is an enormous number. To respond by bringing in only two new additions is ridiculous.
Not all 15 were first-team regulars. Some, such as Luis Palma and Maik Nawrocki, had already been out on loan. But we are still discussing perhaps eight to ten players who were in the senior squad, on its fringes or contributing as loan signings.
Those places still have to be filled.
Let us go through the positions.
Celtic needs a goalkeeper, a left-back and a right-back. We need a left-sided attacker, a right-sided attacker and at least one central midfielder merely to bring the midfield numbers back to where they stood before the departure of Bernardo.
That is six players before anyone else leaves, which means it is before the anticipated departures of Arne Engels and Reo Hatate. It is also before Alistair Johnston leaves. Should all three go, the number of required signings does not rise to six, seven or eight.
It rises to nine. Nine more players coming in. That is what would be required merely to bring the squad close to where it needs to be.
Including the two players Celtic has already signed, that would take the total number of summer arrivals to 12 and I already know people will say that is too many. They will say completing that amount of business is impossible.
But there are holes throughout this squad, and those holes have to be filled.
Do not tell me what is possible and what is not when clubs with significantly fewer resources have already completed more deals than Celtic. By my count, Aberdeen has already signed more players than we need. Dundee United has brought in ten, Falkirk and Hearts have each added 12, Kilmarnock and the Ibrox club have signed eight, while St Johnstone has also completed a substantial number of deals.
The precise totals may continue changing as the window moves, but the wider point is undeniable. Every Premiership club has already signed more players than Celtic, and most will probably end the window having completed somewhere between six and a dozen additions. So, I do not want to hear that nine signings would be impossible for a club of Celtic’s resources.
Our supposedly great scouting system should already have identified the players required. Should Celtic sell Engels and Johnston and bring in approximately £40 million, the club could theoretically spend an average of £4 million on each of those nine additions without even exhausting the incoming fees.
It would not have to touch the money already sitting in the bank. Celtic could complete the necessary rebuild and still finish the window with cash remaining and another transfer-trading surplus. That is the simple truth.
As I have said repeatedly, Celtic is where it is because of choices.
This is not an unavoidable situation forced upon the club. We are here because this is where the people running Celtic chose to be. The club could go out and sign seven or eight players and move substantially closer to where the squad needs to be should it be willing to spend the money and operate with urgency.
The resources will exist. They will come from the deals yet to be completed and from any additional opportunities which emerge before the deadline.
The problem is that Celtic does not move quickly enough to carry out this volume of business. The club does not organise itself well enough to negotiate on several fronts and complete deals within the necessary timeframe.
But it is time people stopped understating the scale of the problem. Four signings will not come remotely close to plugging the gaps in this squad. Six may get Celtic three-quarters of the way there, provided nobody else leaves.
Realistically, should Engels, Hatate and Johnston depart, Celtic may require nine more additions. Anything significantly below that means leaving major gaps untouched.
They do not all have to be permanent transfers. At least five or six probably should be, while some of the remaining needs could be covered through carefully chosen loans until January. But the job is enormous. It was always going to be enormous because short-term and lazy thinking created this situation.
Had Celtic filled these holes when they first appeared, the club would not now be facing such an intimidating list.
We have had approximately 12 months to replace Nicolas Kühn. We had 18 months to replace Kyogo Furuhashi properly and around a year to replace Adam Idah. Those problems did not emerge last week.
Had Celtic completed that work last season, signed Marcello Saracchi permanently and moved for a first-choice goalkeeper the moment it knew Kasper Schmeichel would not be staying for another year, at least some of the rebuilding would already have been done.
But the club did none of that. Now Celtic appears prepared to allow more important players to depart without any obvious Plan B for replacing them. As each player leaves, the number of required signings simply rises again.
We are extremely fortunate that the entire squad does not need to be rebuilt at once, although some days it feels as though the people running the club are determined to reach that point. Eventually, Celtic has to stop taking the piss and bite the bullet.
The club has created a serious mess and must begin digging its way out properly. The more gaps we fill now, the fewer will remain for the next window. The longer we delay, the larger and more expensive the eventual rebuild becomes.
It is like maintaining a house. You can repair the damage properly when it first appears, or you can keep patching over each problem and telling yourself that the structure will survive for another year. The trouble with constant patchwork is that it creates new problems while the original ones continue deteriorating beneath the surface.
You never get ahead of the repairs. Then, when substantial work finally becomes unavoidable, the scale of it feels overwhelming and you discover that you are in no position to carry it out. That is where Celtic is now.
The people running this club think only in the short term. They appear incapable of meaningful long-range planning, so every transfer window begins with unfinished work from the previous one. The missing winger becomes next summer’s problem. The absent goalkeeper becomes January’s emergency. The lack of full-back cover is tolerated until somebody gets injured. Nothing is fixed when it should be.
Everything is postponed until it becomes a crisis.
Nine signings may sound like an outrageous number. It is not.
It is simply the accumulated bill for years of neglect, delay and decisions made without any coherent view of what the Celtic squad should look like six or twelve months later. That bill was always going to arrive.
The only question is whether this board finally pays it or leaves the next manager staring at an even bigger one.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

“Just when I thought I was out they drag me back in!” I would like to posit this and that is I don’t think we need that many panic buys as there is a team there, if the formation and the tactics are right. The reason I say this is “pound for pound” we must have a better squad than Dundee United and look how they performed against Sevco. Fast paced, well organised and enthusiastic. If we went half way round the world to sign Nancy then could we just look closer to home.
I think the problem at Celtic is that there are a group of players who believe they are bigger than the club. We need someone to come in and play players in their best positions and reward hard work and talent purely on merit.
One other thing the opposition always looks fitter than Celtic for example, I love the OX but if the backroom boys can’t get him fit enough after a year then one of them has to go. I used to blame John Kennedy but maybe it is the culture at Parkhead.
I’ve read this 3 times and still have no clue what 123 is trying to say.
Chris. Simply put. We have better players than any of the SPL teams and should be winning easily every week but we don’t have the right tactics or formation. We should be playing two up and try and different, more attacking midfield. Hatton and McArdle are better than who we are playing.
For my money Hogh will come good.
Read it a fourth time!
Duran on the wing, Come on!
Listening about Sevco signing a shit load, just like they did last season, not all of them cheaply, makes me not the slightest bit worried about the numbers we bring in. If it’s 4 or 5 of high quality, we’ll piss the league. Look what we achieved last season with zero backing and the Nancy debacle. Høgh will 100% come good, he’s already shown he gets into the right places. Duran looks the bollocks, but never on the wing again, please. Hassan, if we get him, looks like he could finally give us what Kühn gave us. I’d definitely rather we got quality over quantity. I like Bernardo and McCowan, for example, but when you look at how often we used them and they made a big difference, a proven quality midfielder for a higher price will definitely be better than a couple more of those type of players. I’m absolutely in no way a board happy clapper, but let’s face it, as a Celtic fan you learn to be fekin grateful for what you get with this lot. Quality over quantity every time.
Well said. We only need a couple of midfield players of proven European experience to blood in the likes of Hatton and McArdle. Hogh will score a barrel load as he is always in the right place. You got to be in it to win it.
Sevco would have been vastly improved if they had only bought Shankland and kept Tavernier for the crosses but they have gone out and bought 8/9 bang average players. Desperation.
Question for you James – when would you give youth a chance? And I don’t mean 5 minutes when we are 3 up at home. When do we blood players like Hatton or Bonnar, or trust Donovan to be the cover we need? Signing another right back before selling Johnston would send a terrible message to Donovan (and to a lesser degree Ralston).
Yes we need additions to the squad but you need to reset your expectations (and your arithmetic, 9+2 isn’t 12). And you need to trust MON – although you come across at times of resenting the success he brought with the squad that Rodgers was failing with.