Last night, one of the things I feared most about the coming season finally happened. Celtic materially weakened the midfield before bringing in another midfielder.
No matter how people feel about Paulo Bernardo — and I will discuss the player himself in a moment — this deal makes no strategic sense whatsoever.
We are now another man down in an area where Celtic may already be facing the loss of at least two further players. Our squad depth has shrunk again, and it was never particularly impressive to begin with.
It would be different had Celtic sold Bernardo permanently for a significant fee. At least then the club would have received money which could theoretically be reinvested in a replacement.
But a loan with an option to buy is preposterous.
Celtic has lost an important squad player without receiving the kind of immediate income which might fund another signing. Another club gets the benefit of Bernardo now and the right to buy him should he succeed.
We carry the risk. They receive the opportunity.
When I look at the composition of the midfield, the fact that Celtic has handed Luke McCowan a new contract while allowing a Portuguese Under-21 international to walk out of the door is sickening.
That is not an attack on McCowan personally. He did not award himself the contract, and he cannot be blamed for accepting it.
But as a matter of squad planning, what exactly is the logic?
Who decided that retaining McCowan while allowing Bernardo to leave was the correct balance for this midfield? Who looked at the possibility of Arne Engels and Reo Hatate also departing and concluded that Celtic could afford to remove another established option first?
It is further proof that the club’s transfer policy is an incoherent shambles.
Bernardo did not always impress in a stronger Celtic team than the one we currently have. But I still believe he could become an outstanding player because he possesses many of the qualities required to reach that level.
I hope he goes away and becomes a monstrous success.
The problem is that, should he do so, the option to buy means we may never see him in a Celtic shirt again. The club taking him on loan will benefit from his development and can then complete the transfer on terms which have already been agreed.
Celtic will have surrendered the player before discovering how good he might eventually become.
I do not know who is directing the transfer policy at this club. I do not know who believes that retaining McCowan and letting Bernardo leave represents progress.
Most importantly, I do not know why any supporter should feel comfortable watching another proven squad member depart when no replacement is in sight.
And Bernardo will not be replaced immediately. At this stage, I am beginning to wonder whether any of the players leaving Celtic will be properly replaced at all.
I look at what other clubs are doing. Take the club across the city as an example. I am not particularly impressed by the quality of many of its signings, but I am impressed by the fact that it has made a number of them.
At the very least, it appears to recognise that football is a squad game and that squads require strength in depth.
It may be that several of those players are not especially good. But when one gets injured, another can take his place. Because many of them appear broadly similar in level, there may not be a dramatic drop in quality whenever the team is changed.
Should that group be turned into a functioning unit, it will possess something Celtic does not.
Depth.
Celtic may have a strong starting eleven when everybody is fit and available. We do not have a strong substitutes’ bench, and we do not have the depth required for a long domestic and European campaign.
There is now almost no chance that we will possess it before this transfer window closes.
Someone was keeping count of the number of players who were at Celtic last season and have now left. I believe the figure stood at 14 before last night.
Bernardo makes it 15.
This departure hurts because he was a genuine member of the first-team squad. He did not start every week, but he was regularly available from the bench and could step in when injuries, suspensions or fixture congestion required it.
There was a degree of comfort in knowing that Paulo Bernardo was there.
He produced several excellent performances last season. Even when he was not first choice, he was a credible option who understood the team and could contribute at the required level.
That option has now gone.
The loan players have returned to their clubs. Celtic is weaker at left-back. We are weaker at right-back because there is no established cover. We are now weaker in midfield, and we are weaker on the left side of the attack following Daizen Maeda’s departure.
Some people want to congratulate the board for spending serious money on two forwards.
Fine. Those deals were required, and the players deserve their chance.
But almost every other part of the squad now appears weaker than it was. There are fewer credible options available in multiple positions.
Consider what Celtic needs merely to restore the squad to an acceptable level: a goalkeeper, a right-back, a left-back, now unquestionably another central midfielder, a left-sided attacker and a right-sided attacker.
An entire summer has already passed.
Does anyone honestly believe all of that business will be completed?
We are not even close.
And this is before Engels leaves. It is before Alistair Johnston leaves. It is before Reo Hatate potentially leaves.
Should those departures happen, Celtic could lose three midfielders who were central to last season’s title challenge.
Yet how many credible midfield targets have emerged? One?
We had one believable link and reportedly allowed that deal to collapse over approximately £300,000.
There is no plan here.
There cannot possibly be a plan because no coherent plan could look like this.
Even the most incompetent villain from a Scooby-Doo cartoon could construct something more convincing.
There are moments when I think I have almost worked out what Celtic is trying to do. Then something like the Bernardo deal happens, and I am back at square one, trying to find logic in something which appears to have none.
I cannot adequately describe the trouble this squad may be in.
Any manager other than Martin O’Neill might already have walked away over this. The board told supporters that it had listened and learned, yet its behaviour increasingly looks as though it listened, learned exactly what infuriated everyone and decided to do it again.
Almost as an act of spite.
That is how grim this situation now appears.
Celtic did not need to move Bernardo out before securing his replacement. There was no immediate financial benefit which made the decision unavoidable. There was no strategic advantage in reducing the midfield further while major uncertainty already surrounded Engels and Hatate.
The club simply allowed another first-team option to leave.
That is not rebuilding.
It is dismantling.
The squad is becoming smaller, the gaps are becoming wider and the deadline is getting closer. Every outgoing player increases the amount of work which must be completed, while nothing about Celtic’s recent conduct suggests that the people responsible are capable of completing it.
This board claims to be preparing Celtic for the season ahead.
From where I am standing, it looks far more like people are driving the club towards the edge and refusing to touch the brakes.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

Bemusing. I cannot make any sense of what we are doing. Having MON for a season just kicks the can down the road. Do our board actually want our rivals to surpass us? Does DD need a strong “Them” to increase value of Scottish football hence his shares? Thats the only plausible reason. Unless…..
What can i say? There’s only so many ways we can say our board are parasitical shites.
Shites masquerading as football fans.
I just seen someone referring to the Dundee game as “a cracking performance”.
FFS! That’s what we are up against. I bet you he’s a season ticket holder. LOL
It’s the same script: you just know things are going to get worse, and as night follows day they do.
It’s getting crazier by the minute. Maybe the plan is to play with a goalie and two strikers. Hope the goalie doesn’t get injured or Duran will be between the sticks. It’s just not Celtic anymore, as I said a couple of days ago I wish I hadn’t renewed my ST which I’ve had in one form or another since the mid 1980s. Che was right, don’t give them your money.
Did MON not say the CEO was handleing all transfers?
Total boycotts is all we have left to rattle the accountants. The STs are already sold, so it is now the only option. NAP from last season did the square root of f**k all, nothing changed. Fans could protest outside on home game days but not go into the stadium to watch the game, I really cannot see anything else that would have the impact of boycotts
Bernardo was a player I thought would be great at Celtic, he had a pretty good spell during his 1st season on loan, he did get injured in his 2nd season, and after coming back he just hasn’t kicked on. James you say he showed up well at times last season, I’m afraid I never saw that, Good luck to him in Poland, I still think there’s a decent player there.
It is obvious we should have had new players -midfielders included- in weeks ago. Since we bought Bernardo he has done the square root of hee haw though, so I’m glad he’s away as he was providing nothing and now perhaps some wages can be freed up for someone who will provide at least something.