The other day, I wrote a lengthy piece about why this club is run by maintainers rather than builders, a distinction that will be very familiar to anyone who plays deep strategy simulations.
Maintainers try to protect what they initially have for as long as possible before attempting to expand. Builders are different. They are out to create something bigger and better from the beginning. They are aggressive expansionists because they understand that the way to grow is not simply to sit there nurturing your own little garden.
It is to take the one next door, then the one next door to that, and keep going.
That piece was very little read. I am not suggesting that you go and read it. You do not need to understand it to follow what I am saying here, although it might provide some context.
Because when you are tending and maintaining instead of growing and expanding, you are essentially allowing the game to run you.
The map around you is always changing. It is never static. Whilst you are standing still, everybody else is moving. Some will be ploughed under and disappear before they ever become serious players. Others will aggressively accumulate power, resources and influence.
Football is exactly the same.
The clubs which are standing still are asking to be swallowed eventually.
The clubs which aggressively pursue their objectives, within realistic limits, are the ones which tend to get things done. Football, in the end, is like almost every other business. The organisations which rise are usually those which are ruthless, determined and relentlessly focused on what they want to become.
You can be perfectly content running your little corner shop. There is nothing inherently wrong with that. But empire builders are the people who take the profits from that first corner shop, buy another one, then another one, and keep expanding.
You can see football organisations doing exactly that.
The City Group is probably not the greatest example to use at this particular moment, but it is nevertheless one model. Tony Bloom’s organisation is another. Multi-club ownership and football networks are increasingly part of the landscape.
Now, this current Celtic Board is barely adequate for running one major football operation, far less a stable of them. But that does not mean the idea itself should be dismissed.
There are markets Celtic cannot properly crack because we do not have the footprint or the profile. A multi-club structure could potentially give Celtic access to some of them.
If you are permanently locked into a country with a tiny television deal, waiting for fairer winds to blow through the business may not be the optimal strategy. At some point, you have to ask how you create a foothold in bigger markets instead of simply complaining that those markets exist.
That is one of the areas where Celtic have been astonishingly slow to move.
Why should there not be a Celtic-linked club in England?
I am not necessarily suggesting that we buy an English club, paint it green and white, call it Celtic Something-or-Other and sit waiting for it to climb through the divisions. That would be an absurdly simplistic version of the idea.
But imagine Celtic had a club in England where players could be sent on loan, where talent could be developed and where the organisation could establish a genuine foothold in a stronger commercial market.
As that club grew, Celtic PLC would have exposure to a market in which it currently has no meaningful revenue share.
The potential benefits are obvious.
Forget England for a moment. Look at Belgium or Holland, countries renowned for developing players and producing excellent young talent. Their clubs have academies, coaching traditions and football cultures which are different from our own.
Imagine Celtic owned or controlled a club in Holland.
Instead of simply treating it as some feeder organisation, imagine sending some of our best academy players there to learn different methods, different tactical systems and different ways of understanding the game.
That alone could transform elements of our academy structure.
It would also give Celtic far greater visibility over emerging Dutch talent. Rather than joining the queue after somebody has already broken through, we could be part of the structure developing them.
Again, this is an area where Celtic do not even appear interested in moving, despite the fact that the cash reserves sitting in the bank might give us the capacity to explore it.
We can maintain. Of course we can.
Celtic’s underlying strength is such that if this organisation were run even five per cent better, there should be very little chance of another Scottish club challenging us consistently far into the foreseeable future.
The fact that we are now struggling even to maintain properly is dreadful enough.
But it becomes even worse when you consider how much more Celtic could actually be.
And a multi-club football group is only one small part of that.
There are all sorts of commercial possibilities which we barely seem to entertain. The fact that Oasis playing Celtic Park could reportedly generate millions should not merely be greeted as a tremendous coup. It should also raise a question.
Why were we not pursuing this sort of thing more aggressively before?
That is exactly the kind of thinking Celtic Supporters Limited raised when they published their document examining the club’s strategic failures earlier this year.
Their argument went beyond the obvious money lost through Champions League exits and poor preparation.
That is something I have written about before as well.
If your strategic plan in June is to sign certain players because you believe they can improve the team and grow into valuable assets, then abandoning that plan because you go out of Europe in August does not merely cost you the Champions League money sitting directly in front of you.
It can cost future revenues too.
Potential transfer profits disappear. Squad development stalls. Future European qualification becomes harder. Commercial momentum is lost.
Those losses compound.
Almost everything Celtic do feels short-sighted.
The overriding question always seems to be: how do we keep what we have now?
But sometimes the only way to preserve what you have is to become stronger.
The world does not stop moving because you have decided you are comfortable. Your space contracts as others around you grow into it.
Look at Hearts.
If Tony Bloom gets five years and their supporters are patient enough to see what grows from what he is planting there, where could that club be?
Look across the city.
If the Ibrox club’s ownership eventually does what people there have talked about for years and expands the stadium footprint, closing that 10,000-season-ticket gap, what does that mean for Celtic?
Especially when we have discussed stadium redevelopment ourselves and then done virtually nothing with it.
Imagine Celtic Park significantly larger than it is now. Imagine the additional matchday income, season-ticket capacity, hospitality and commercial opportunities generated over decades.
That would be building from a position of strength.
Instead, everything Celtic do is cautious, steady and risk-averse.
There may be circumstances where that is perfectly logical.
But if everybody else is progressing, we are eventually going to get caught.
If everybody else is modernising, improving and expanding, then standing still becomes dangerous.
Hearts are already tied into a wider football structure. That does not simply mean Bloom brings experience and expertise from elsewhere. It gives them access to networks of scouting, analytics, coaching knowledge and recruitment which they did not previously possess.
The whole organisation can learn.
The Ibrox club is now connected to a wider ownership group too.
Both may be relatively small pieces within larger structures, whereas what I would envision for Celtic would involve this club occupying a much more substantial position. But the basic principle remains the same.
Information travels.
Talent travels.
Ideas travel.
Successful recruitment methods can be shared. Coaching knowledge can be shared. Analytics can be shared. Mistakes made in one place can prevent the same mistake being repeated elsewhere.
That constant exchange creates opportunity.
And if Celtic remain outside that world indefinitely, we should not be surprised if we eventually find ourselves behind it.
This is not prophesying doom for the sake of it.
It is a cold-blooded analysis of where maintaining ultimately takes you.
The cheapest time to build Celtic’s future is while Celtic is still operating from a position of strength.
Right now there is money in the bank. Right now we still have enormous commercial advantages domestically. Right now there is something resembling a strong foundation from which to build.
Five years from now, things may look very different.
If Celtic are second or third in Scotland, if other clubs have moved ahead of us structurally and become smarter, leaner and better organised, then fixing the problem will cost vastly more than preventing it would have done.
Cash reserves which could once have financed growth will instead be used plugging holes created by failed seasons.
Managerial recruitment becomes harder when the expectation is enormous but the infrastructure underneath it is weak.
Players become harder to attract.
European revenues shrink.
Winning stops being assumed and has to be rebuilt as a mentality.
That is the cost of maintaining whilst everybody else is growing.
That is the cost of desperately holding on to what you have whilst everybody around you is building something better.
So many opportunities are being missed. So many possibilities are not even being explored.
And perhaps this is the real answer to the question we so often hear from south of the border and elsewhere.
Your club is successful. What more do Celtic supporters actually want?
The answer is simple.
The best version of Celtic.
A club which is not merely capable of dominating the Scottish game today, but is building the structures which allow it to do so tomorrow, five years from now and ten years from now.
A club which looks at its current advantages and asks what they can become rather than how long they can be preserved.
A club which understands that sometimes the safest thing you can do is grow.
That is not the Celtic we are watching right now.
But it could be.
And it should be.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.
