There are moments when I look at Celtic Park, look at the people running the football club, and genuinely wonder whether somebody has quietly replaced the Celtic Board with a troupe of professional comedians.
Because Celtic’s statement following the protest aimed at Dermot Desmond was quite something. Not because it was particularly clever, not because it calmed the situation and certainly not because it brought people together.
Quite the opposite.
It was, in my opinion, a masterclass in how to take an already furious support, throw an industrial-sized bucket of petrol onto the fire and then stand around the boardroom looking absolutely astonished when the flames get higher.
Brilliant stuff. Absolutely magnificent.
If the objective was to strengthen the resolve of the fan groups behind Not Another Penny, then congratulations to everyone involved. Mission accomplished. Gold star. Perhaps somebody should send Michael Nicholson a wee certificate saying: “Congratulations! You have successfully made the supporters’ campaign stronger.”
And this is the part I find almost comical.
At a time when Celtic supporters are already angry about the direction of the club, the leadership structure, the lack of accountability and the increasingly obvious disconnect between the people sitting comfortably in the boardroom and the people filling Celtic Park, the club decided that this was the perfect moment for that board to point the finger and fans and talk about damage being done to Celtic’s reputation.
Honestly, you couldn’t make it up.
Except there is a rather enormous hole in that argument. The protest was not aimed at Celtic. It was aimed at one man.
Dermot Desmond the prick.
So, I am struggling to understand how the Celtic Board managed to transform a protest against an individual into an attack on the reputation of Celtic Football Club itself. Perhaps I need another English lesson. Perhaps the Board needs one.
Maybe we should begin with the difference between “Celtic” and “Dermot Desmond”.
They are not, last time I checked, synonyms.
I have checked several times. Still not synonyms.
Yet somehow we have reached the extraordinary situation where criticism of one individual appears to be interpreted as an assault upon the entire institution, and that, for me, is precisely where the Board’s thinking has gone spectacularly wrong.
Celtic supporters are not stupid.
They can see what is happening. They can distinguish between Celtic Football Club and the people currently occupying positions of power within it.
If the Board thinks dressing up criticism of Desmond as an attack on Celtic is going to make supporters suddenly abandon their concerns, then I have some rather exciting news for them. It isn’t working.
In fact, it appears to be doing precisely the opposite.
Not Another Penny is not going away.
If anything, the weekend’s statement appears to have strengthened the resolve behind it, and I find that absolutely fascinating.
When a football club is facing a supporters’ campaign designed to tighten financial pressure on its leadership, the intelligent response would presumably be to ask why so many supporters have reached the point where they are prepared to withhold money from a club they love.
That might be worth investigating. It might be worth listening to. It might even require a little humility.
I appreciate that humility may be an extremely rare substance in modern football boardrooms, possibly requiring a special licence to possess, but surely somebody could have found a tiny bottle of it somewhere.
I can picture the boardroom now. Michael Nicholson walks in. The statement is placed dramatically on the table. Everyone looks at it. There is a long silence.
Someone finally says, “This should calm things down.”
Another person nods.
“Definitely.”
Somebody else says, “Supporters will understand.”
And somewhere in the corner, the last remaining voice of reason slowly puts on its coat, picks up its briefcase and walks out of Celtic Park without saying goodbye.
Because how else do you explain it?
The Board seems to have forgotten one rather fundamental principle of football administration: supporters are not simply customers purchasing a product. They are the people who make that product valuable in the first place.
Celtic without its supporters is not Celtic in the way the Board seems to imagine it.
There is a reason Jock Stein’s famous words still resonate: “Football without fans is nothing.”
Yet there sometimes seems to be an astonishing reluctance at Celtic Park to behave as though those words actually mean something.
I do not expect the Board to agree with every protest. I do not expect them to applaud every banner, and I certainly do not expect them to enjoy being criticised.
But leadership is not about enjoying criticism. Leadership is about understanding why the criticism exists.
If your answer to an already furious support is a statement telling them about damage to the club’s reputation rather than addressing the reasons for their anger, then I am afraid you have spectacularly missed the point.
This is why I think the weekend’s statement could eventually be remembered as one of those wonderfully counterproductive moments which demonstrates exactly how not to manage a supporter crisis.
The Board did not extinguish the fire. It handed the protesters more wood and then, just to make absolutely certain, appears to have given them the matches as well.
Not Another Penny now has even greater relevance because supporters can look at the club’s response and say: you really do not understand us, do you?
That is a dangerous place for any football club to be, especially Celtic.
The strength of Celtic has always been its supporters. Not a spreadsheet, not a corporate statement, not a boardroom presentation and certainly not a collection of men sitting around a table congratulating themselves for discovering the word “reputational”.
The strength of Celtic is the enormous emotional investment of the people who turn up, sing, buy shirts, renew season tickets, travel across Scotland and Europe, argue about the team, defend the club and spend their hard-earned money because they believe Celtic belongs to something bigger than whoever happens to occupy the boardroom today.
That is why Not Another Penny matters.
It is not simply about money. It is about leverage.
It is supporters saying that loyalty should not be mistaken for unlimited patience, and now the Board has helped reinforce that message.
I almost want to applaud. If the objective was to make the supporters’ campaign more determined, somebody deserves a bonus. Maybe even a wee chocolate biscuit at the next Board meeting.
“Well done, everyone. We’ve managed to unite the protesters even further.”
If the objective was to create meaningful dialogue with supporters, however, I might suggest a small rethink.
Perhaps next time, instead of asking which statement sounds best inside the boardroom, ask a much simpler question:
What will Celtic supporters actually hear when they read this?
Because that is the part which seems to have been forgotten.
They hear a Board defending itself. They hear a Board protecting the people at the top. They hear a Board which still does not appreciate the scale of the anger, and most importantly, they hear a Board which apparently believes another carefully worded statement can somehow make the problem disappear.
Good luck with that.
The supporters are not disappearing. The campaign is not disappearing. The anger is not disappearing either.
And neither is the question hanging over Celtic Park: who exactly does this football club belong to?
It belongs to Celtic, and Celtic belongs to its supporters far more than it belongs to any individual sitting comfortably in a boardroom.
So, if the Celtic Board genuinely believed that weekend statement would bring the temperature down, I have a wee piece of advice.
Put the kettle on. Make a cup of tea. Have a biscuit. Sit down for five minutes and listen to the people who actually keep this football club alive.
Because Not Another Penny is only getting started, and judging by the Celtic Board’s latest contribution to the situation, I have a horrible feeling they might accidentally become the campaign’s best recruitment team.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.
