So, Cameron Carter-Vickers is getting another kicking from an ex-Celtic player for daring to say something out loud that every single one of us watching Celtic can see with our own bloody eyes.
Apparently, this is now the great crime.
Not playing badly. Not losing three games in a row. Not being tactically all over the place. Not looking like a team that sometimes doesn’t appear to know what it is supposed to be doing. No.
The real problem is that one of the players had the audacity to actually talk about it.
Honestly, you couldn’t make it up.
After Celtic’s 1-0 defeat to the Ibrox mob at Celtic Park, Cameron Carter-Vickers was asked about the performance and gave a remarkably frank answer. He said Celtic had played “a bit too random” and that the team needed to get better at having “a script and sticking to it.”
He also made it clear that the responsibility was not simply sitting at Martin O’Neill’s door.
He talked about the players. He talked about the coaching staff. He talked about the fact that there are a lot of new players and that Celtic need everyone working from the same script. He even backed O’Neill and said he was confident in the group.
So, what exactly are we supposed to be outraged about?
The word “random”?
Oh, the horror. Somebody call the authorities.
A Celtic player describes Celtic looking disorganised after a defeat and suddenly we have apparently reached the end of civilisation. Does it matter that most of us who watched it actually recognise that he was 100% right?
Apparently not. He committed the cardinal sin, if you believe the anger.
Former Celtic players have queued up to tell Carter-Vickers that he should have kept it in-house. Paul Lambert called the comments “cringeworthy” and “bang out of order”, arguing that the players needed to solve the problem themselves.
Chris Sutton weighed in and slammed the remarks.
Alan Stubbs has now taken a similar line, describing the comments as a “cheap shot” and a “cop-out” and arguing that Carter-Vickers should have looked at his own performance first. Scott Brown has also said he was not keen on players being too open publicly, insisting that there is a time and place for everything.
And I understand that argument.
I really do.
I have said myself, and James has as well, that Celtic players should not be publicly criticising their manager, coaching staff or tactical instructions every five minutes.
There has to be a dressing room inquest. There has to be accountability behind closed doors. There has to be a degree of unity.
But there is a rather enormous difference between throwing your manager under the bus and saying: we weren’t good enough, we were too random, we need more structure and we all need to improve.
That is not exactly Carter-Vickers standing outside Celtic Park with a megaphone demanding O’Neill’s resignation, is it?
In fact, quite the opposite.
He backed the manager. He backed the coaching staff. He backed his fellow players, and he acknowledged that Celtic had not been good enough.
That sounds rather more like leadership to me than some of the carefully polished football soundbites we have been fed for years.
And this is where I find myself disagreeing with the “keep it in-house” brigade.
Yes, ideally these conversations happen inside the dressing room.
But what happens when supporters have been watching the same problems unfold in front of them week after week and hearing absolutely nothing meaningful from anyone?
Do we really want another player to walk in front of a microphone, smile politely and tell us that “we’ll learn from it”, “we’ll go again”, “the boys are together” and “we’ll take it one game at a time”?
Because I have heard enough of that.
It is the football equivalent of putting a scented candle beside a burning building.
Everything is fine. The boys are together. We just need to work hard.
Lovely. Meanwhile, the house is still on fire.
Carter-Vickers actually told us something useful.
He said Celtic need a script. That is an insightful analysis of the problem.
I have been saying for weeks that this Celtic team has looked disconnected, disorganised and, at times, completely leaderless. The defeats to the Ibrox mob have exposed that brutally. So did the Europa League defeat to Ferencvaros.
And when Carter-Vickers says the team needs what amounts to a Plan B to fall back on, I know exactly what he means.
Footballers need structure. They need patterns. They need to know where their teammates are going to be. They need to know what happens when possession is lost, how the midfield protects the defence and how the team progresses the ball.
They need to know what the plan is when Plan A isn’t working.
That isn’t rocket science. It is football.
And if a Celtic player is saying publicly that the team hasn’t had enough time to develop that structure, I don’t immediately want to shoot the messenger. I want to ask why the hell he is saying it in the first place. Because perhaps, just perhaps, he is saying it because it is true.
And that is the uncomfortable bit.
We have spent far too long expecting Celtic players to sit quietly, smile for the cameras and pretend everything is wonderful while supporters are left to work out for themselves why the team looks like eleven people who were introduced to each other approximately seventeen minutes before kick-off.
So yes, I support Carter-Vickers speaking. Would I have preferred him to choose his words slightly differently? Probably. Was it politically wise? Probably not.
But was he wrong? I don’t think he was.
And there is another important point here.
In spite of criticisms to the contrary, Carter-Vickers did not absolve himself. He explicitly said: “As players, we can do better for sure.” He said the players and coaching staff needed to nail down what Celtic wanted to be as a team and work towards it.
That is not passing the buck. That is distributing responsibility.
And frankly, I would much rather hear that than another meaningless football cliché.
There is something particularly amusing about former Celtic players telling current Celtic players that they must not speak publicly when some of them have spent an eternity complaining that nobody at the club communicates enough.
We cannot have it both ways.
We cannot complain that too many people at Celtic hide behind bland media training when they can be bothered to speak to the fans at all, and then attack the first player who actually gives us an honest answer. Pick a lane.
Personally, I would rather have the honesty.
I would rather hear Carter-Vickers say Celtic were too random than be told Celtic were “unlucky” after being beaten by the Ibrox mob.
I would rather hear that the team needs a script than another solemn declaration about “taking the positives”.
And I certainly don’t think Carter-Vickers deserves to be painted as some sort of dressing-room rebel who has undermined his manager.
He hasn’t. He has actually done something much more valuable.
He has confirmed what supporters have been seeing, and suggested that there is some frustration inside the club itself. He has pointed to a lack of clarity, consistency and structure. We have all said much the same.
And he is suggesting that there is work to do both on the pitch and behind the scenes.
That doesn’t mean Martin O’Neill is finished. It doesn’t mean Carter-Vickers is right about everything. It doesn’t mean the players carry no responsibility.
They absolutely do.
But football is a collective enterprise, and pretending that every problem is simply the players’ fault because “once you cross the white line, it’s down to you” is far too simplistic.
Managers coach teams. Coaches create structures. Players execute them.
And when something isn’t working, responsibility belongs to everybody.
That is precisely what Carter-Vickers said. So, I am going to give him credit for it. For telling us that what’s in front of our eyes is real. For not trying to pretend otherwise.
Maybe he should have kept quiet. Maybe those with an old-school football mentality would have preferred that. Maybe it’s easier for some people to blame Carter Vickers than it is for them to blame Martin O’Neill, which seems to be the thing here.
But personally, I think Celtic supporters have been kept at arms length for too long. It was good that someone finally gave us a glimpse behind the scenes. We have watched. We have paid. We have travelled. We have supported. We have renewed.
And we have listened to enough bloody nonsense.
If one of our senior players finally decides to tell us that Celtic need a script and need to start playing like an organised football team, I am not going to have a go at him for it.
I am going to say: Good. Now let’s bloody well find the script.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.
