Skip to content
The Celtic Blog

The Celtic Blog

Primary Menu
  • News
  • Hot Topics
  • Fixtures & Results
  • Podcast
  • Articles & Features

Celtic can still learn from the Nancy mistake. If we recognise it was one.

If we learn from the Nancy experience, it might be a consequential turning point for us. What are the odds?

James Forrest October 9, 2026
Add us as a preferred Google source
Pensive Columbus Crew Touchline Portrait

One of the things about Wilfried Nancy’s brief stay in Glasgow was that you always wondered whether he ever really got a fair shake of it.

In terms of the players, in terms of the coaching staff, you always wondered whether everybody at the club who should have been behind him actually was behind him.

And yesterday, Nancy talked about that.

He dropped a very big hint that the answer may have been no.

Look, let’s be honest. He was unconvincing.

There was no guarantee that anything he did would have worked. His ideas were radical. They were dramatic departures from anything we had seen at Celtic in a long time.

They were honed in a league where there was a very good standard of player at some clubs, and a lot of middling football at others.

Hot Topic 18 comments this week
European football is about to experience a system shock. Will Celtic be ready?
Latest comment from micmac
“Good point, but until there is a bit of financial equality the EL and ECL are our level, but this board have even got…”
Join the discussion →

We will never know, unless he goes off and proves himself somewhere else, and the offers have not exactly been pouring through his letterbox.

We will never know whether those ideas would have translated successfully to a different country and a different league from MLS.

What we do know is that in MLS, everyone bought into what he was trying to do.

There was no vested interest. There was no old guard. There were none of the doubts that were so prevalent when he arrived in Scotland.

And maybe that was important.

Because whatever the guy was, and whatever he promised to be, it is always easier at a club if you have buy-in from the people around you.

And it is just not clear that this was the case at Celtic.

You can say that was right. You can say it was wrong. But if it is true, then everything we think we know was only half understood.

And as you can probably tell from the tone of the pieces today, I am in a very philosophical mood.

I am asking myself more and more whether there are things we have misunderstood, things we have not seen clearly enough.

This one might be significant.

Because the chances are very high that we are going to be looking for a new manager at the end of the season, or perhaps even before.

And there are lessons to learn from Wilfried Nancy and what happened to that guy at Celtic Park.

Nancy was thrown in at the deep end and asked to make radical changes with very little time for people at the club to adjust to what he was trying to do.

It was madness to throw a guy with dramatic, revolutionary ideas into a team that had just settled down and found its form again.

Absolute insanity.

That could have been done a lot better, a lot easier and a lot more smoothly.

But that is this club for you. It never seems to do things in the joined-up, sensible way.

And he paid for that.

We paid for it as a club too.

I am not saying it would all have turned out well.

He looked like a guy who was out of his depth from day one. I do not think he understood the club. I do not think he understood the culture.

But asking him to make those changes in the middle of a campaign, without first knowing whether the players and people around him were truly prepared to buy into them, was madness.

And that is the part Celtic cannot afford to repeat.

The next appointment has to be right.

But it also has to be handled properly.

The managerial search cannot be left until the summer. It has to be underway now.

Before this season is over, the next manager should have the opportunity to walk through the doors of Celtic Park, meet the players, look every one of them in the eye and find out who is prepared to get on board with what comes next.

If some players are unwilling to adapt, unwilling to change, or simply too comfortable, then the new manager needs to know that before the summer window starts.

And it should not matter who those players are.

Because if you appoint a manager to change the way the club plays, then you have to give him the chance to make those changes with people who actually want to follow him.

At some point, this club has to start learning from previous mistakes.

This would be a good place to start.

We cannot leave the managerial hunt until the summer and then act surprised when European qualifiers arrive before the new guy has properly assessed his squad, worked out what he needs and begun imposing his ideas.

A new manager means a new style.

If certain players cannot adapt to it, they need to be moved and replacements brought in quickly enough that Celtic can actually hit the ground running.

Otherwise, we are just repeating the same cycle again.

Drama. Confusion. Panic. Crisis.

This Board has made some cataclysmic errors of judgement before.

But this particular bear trap is so big they should be able to see it from miles away.

People will say this season has barely begun and I am already talking about next season.

Well, yes.

Because the people inside Celtic should be doing exactly that.

Their short-termism is not going to cut it any longer.

If they are not thinking about this right now, then none of them should be in those jobs.

Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

Add us as a preferred Google source

What do you feel about this?

  • Articles
  • Articles & Features
  • Blogs
  • Celtic
  • Celtic F.C.
  • Cult Of Celtic
  • Media
  • News
  • Opinions & Rants
  • Players & Staff
  • The Manager

Post navigation

Previous: No, Martin. The fans are Celtic. It’s this regime which is not.
Next: Celtic’s war with the supporters escalated again yesterday. When does it end?

Related Stories

2025 Scottish Premiership Football Hearts v Celtic Oct 26th
6 minutes read
  • Articles

Hearts latest ticket allocation is a joke. Celtic are right to call it out.

Paulina Jaczek November 12, 2026 1
2026 Scottish League Cup Football Rangers v Celtic Sep 13th
8 minutes read
  • Articles

Anthony Joseph damns Celtic over Champions League exit plan.

Paulina Jaczek November 12, 2026 1
2025 Scottish Premiership Football Rangers v Celtic May 4th
7 minutes read
  • Articles

Bizarre legal defence aside, the latest Ibrox court case shows up the SFA.

James Forrest November 12, 2026 4
2026 Scottish Premiership Football Falkirk v Celtic Nov 1st
6 minutes read
  • Articles

Celtic has prioritised one position in January. It doesn’t mean we’ll get it.

James Forrest November 12, 2026 7
2025 Scottish Premiership Football Dundee Utd v Celtic Dec 17th
7 minutes read
  • Articles

The Kilmarnock team sheet was further evidence of Celtic’s transfer failure.

James Forrest November 12, 2026 9
SPIRIT_OF_86_02479 (1)
10 minutes read
  • Articles

The anger around Celtic is deep but it can’t be allowed to drown us.

Paulina Jaczek November 12, 2026 0

Trending Now

Bizarre legal defence aside, the latest Ibrox court case shows up the SFA. 2025 Scottish Premiership Football Rangers v Celtic May 4th 1

Bizarre legal defence aside, the latest Ibrox court case shows up the SFA.

November 12, 2026 4
Hearts latest ticket allocation is a joke. Celtic are right to call it out. 2025 Scottish Premiership Football Hearts v Celtic Oct 26th 2

Hearts latest ticket allocation is a joke. Celtic are right to call it out.

November 12, 2026 1
Anthony Joseph damns Celtic over Champions League exit plan. 2026 Scottish League Cup Football Rangers v Celtic Sep 13th 3

Anthony Joseph damns Celtic over Champions League exit plan.

November 12, 2026 1
Celtic has prioritised one position in January. It doesn’t mean we’ll get it. 2026 Scottish Premiership Football Falkirk v Celtic Nov 1st 4

Celtic has prioritised one position in January. It doesn’t mean we’ll get it.

November 12, 2026 7
Celtic FC News
Next MatchScottish Premier League
Sat 21 Nov · 15:00
CelticCeltic
v
St MirrenSt Mirren
Previous MatchScottish Premier League
Sun 8 Nov
CelticCeltic
1-0
KilmarnockKilmarnock
Trinity Tims channel logoTrinity TimsCeltic discussion and podcasts

Latest uploads

Beating Beaton
Beating Beaton
Trinity Tims Watch on YouTube
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy
  • Contact Us
  • Editorial Policy
  • About
Copyright © 2026 All rights reserved.