25th October 2026; Easter Road Stadium, Edinburgh, Scotland; Scottish Premiership Football, Hibernian versus Celtic; Callum McGregor of Celtic
We all knew that there were some issues inside Celtic.
Some of us suspected that Callum McGregor was among those players not particularly happy with some of what was going on in training and around the coaching setup. And last night he made some pretty wild statements which hinted not only at his own displeasure, but at a wider dissatisfaction within the club.
There are people who are going to try to pretend that this is not proof of anything. They’re going to claim that there is nothing in it except one player venting frustration after a bad result.
But, of course, those are the same people who keep telling us that this is a well-run club.
The simple fact is that when your captain is publicly contradicting elements of the coaching, the tactics and the setup of the team, there is nothing healthy about that. At the very least, it tells you that something is wrong.
What makes this an especially worrying moment is that a lot of us have known that Callum was the one to watch for a few weeks now.
His reluctance, or perhaps the club’s reluctance, to put him in front of the media has been obvious. His tendency to shy away from post-match interviews has also been pretty apparent.
When Callum is unhappy, it’s not difficult to spot it.
And I don’t know whether he felt that it was better to stay away from the microphones, or whether someone else at Celtic Park did. But because it was Callum, and because we’ve all had an inkling that maybe he hasn’t been terribly impressed by certain things, we all sat up and took notice of this interview immediately.
And the fact that it appears to have confirmed some of our worst suspicions is disappointing, but not terribly surprising.
Not only did he offer a critique of wingers playing as forwards and forwards playing as wingers, but he suggested that our game has become a bit like basketball.
In short, he is objecting to long punts up the pitch which are not really targeted anywhere.
That is an explicit criticism of the playing style and the tactical approach, which means that it is also an explicit criticism of the coaches and the people running things from the touchline.
He has said that we need to find one system and stick to it, which is another suggestion that there are, if not competing interests, then certainly competing ideologies at the club, and some disagreement over how best to approach games.
Every single one of us has commented on the fact that we have players here we do not seem to know how to use.
McGregor has just echoed those concerns through a bullhorn.
Graham Young of the Evening Times is not one of my favourite journalists, but his article on this was spot on.
Celtic have, in the past, been able to hide behind the idea that players have been misquoted, or that their comments have been taken out of context.
There is no such issue here.
McGregor’s comments are straightforward. They are clear. And they are unarguable.
If this guy was simply talking as he sees it about certain things that he reckons have gone wrong, in isolation, that would be one thing.
But the breadth of what he said strongly suggests that this is about more than one player sounding off after a bad result.
This is not simply frustration at a single momentary lapse in concentration or a single break in the team’s shape.
McGregor has real worries about what we are trying to do.
And he has spoken them out loud.
As Young points out, it is not the first time McGregor has been outspoken about the club.
During the summer, when he said he would stay at Celtic as long as the club continued to show ambition, O’Neill gently slapped him down over the comment.
I don’t know why O’Neill should have had any objection to a player wanting the club to show ambition in the first place.
O’Neill later suggested that perhaps the remarks had been taken out of context, or that there had been some kind of misunderstanding around them.
But McGregor said those words on the club’s own official channel.
He said them in front of Celtic’s own in-house interviewer.
Nobody was fishing for controversy.
Nobody was taking somebody’s words and twisting them into something else.
And the same basic problem exists now.
These are McGregor’s words.
They are his assessment of what Celtic are doing on the football pitch.
This is about as clear-cut as you are going to get.
A few weeks ago, when we were talking about O’Neill’s decision to stay at the club after his spell of reflection in the aftermath of the two games against the Ibrox club, there was a suggestion in some quarters that the team must be baffled by all the goings-on.
But, as I pointed out at the time, and as others subsequently said, the real problem is not that the players were left in total ignorance about what was going on.
The real problem is that the players are probably very well informed.
They will know far more than we do about the chaos inside Celtic Park at the moment. They will know where the disagreements are. They will know where plans have been frustrated, where tensions exist and where relationships are strained.
They will know which decisions came from where.
McGregor, as captain, will know more than most.
And if these are the comments being made in public, you can only imagine what the conversations are like in private.
There is a profound disconnect at Celtic.
And that disconnect runs far deeper than the one between the supporters and the board.
It now appears to infect every part of the machine.
What makes this really feel like a significant moment isn’t even that the captain has spoken out.
It isn’t even that he has criticised the approach in a way that leaves it plain that the concerns inside the club run deep.
It’s that he has identified exactly what supporters have been talking about on forums, podcasts and blogs for many, many months now.
Square pegs in round holes. A playing style that seems to vacillate between controlled possession and lumping the ball up the pitch like it’s public-park football. A tactical incoherence which makes it look as though we are trying to meld two different styles. Players being asked to do things they are not used to doing, and may not even be capable of doing.
And more than that, in talking so openly about Kasper Høgh and Camilo Duran, McGregor has made it clear that he shares the concern that we do not know how to get the best out of either player.
That is a damning indictment of the coaching staff at Celtic Park.
It is a damning indictment of the way this team is being managed right now.
McGregor, let us not forget, has worked under two elite-level managers in the past ten years: Brendan Rodgers and Ange Postecoglou.
Two guys with modern outlooks and modern thinking.
He knows what that looks like.
And he knows what the difference is between that and this.
So yes, this one feels significant.
This one feels real.
And O’Neill will have to answer questions about it when he sits in front of the media today.
But the one thing he will not be able to say is that McGregor’s comments have been taken out of context or twisted, because that simply is not what happened here.
McGregor got in front of a camera and a microphone and expressed his concerns, as captain of Celtic, about what we are doing right now.
There is no way to spin that.
And nor should anyone try.
Choose The CelticBlog as a Preferred Source on Google News…

Callum used the basketball analogy. Brendan Rodgers often used the same analogy when discussing the importance of controlling possession. I wonder if Callum’s choice of words is coincidental? Both the club captain and at least one senior player have now publicly expressed concerns. The most worrying aspect is that we know it to be correct but that it will change nothing in how the coaching team approach games. They are so out of their depth they cannot change.
Callum’s comments have uncovered a few issues that journalists, punters, fans and bloggers have been questioning:
Q. Why do Celtic seem to crumble when a moment in a match turns against them?
A. Because they know they are not set up to respond to a setback which is likely to re-occur quickly.
Q. Why do players’ body language appear to reveal something is not right with them?
A. They’re unhappy with what they’re being asked to do as it’s not getting the best out of them.
Q. Why does there appear to be a disconnect between the manager and coaching staff.
A. Because the players see it close hand in training, tactics, team selection and formation.
I think as captain, and ultimately the management team’s spokesman on the pitch, it’s hard to ignore CalMac when he speaks as he has in this interview.
I remember Tierney saying post Hearts title winning match, that it was CalMac that kept everything together and the squad focused through the tough periods of that season.
He has been regularly criticised this season, very unjustifiably so, in my opinion, and it must pain him to watch standards drop every season he’s there. What a difference it would make to him and team to have that DM, our club have been crying out for!!!
He is just echoing what so many of us have watched and opined on since the season started.
No clear style of play, square pegs in round holes, “basketball” football etc!
He also comments on players “learning on the job” ie playing matches to learn the system, due to late signings etc…which isn’t very reassuring when you think about it !
This ultimately brings you back to our board and the mess our club is in! Poor, inadequate and tardy recruitment, indecision on hiring of management & coaches, leading to substandard squad, communication and style of play.
We can only hope and pray that CalMac’s words resonate with MON and throughout our club, and that the stuttering garbage we are frequently subjected to, can be replaced with some clear style of play, settled formations and players lined up in their strongest positions!!!
Keeping the faith ! HH
Good comment Gerry, There is definitely a disconnect which is worrying.
Great comment Gerry.
You summed up the situation perfectly! Hail Hail
You have to ask, who put calum in front of the camera?. Cal would not have asked , this was again another example of division within those at the top V the football dept.
Cal may have the same views as those 1 or 2 at the top, but he is a mug for allowing himself to be the point man and if its not at the top it can only be within the football dept, i.e MON v the coaches.
I never did buy the delay in signing the coaches as MON going into bat, i always said the delay was in fact the opposite, MON didnt want them but in the end DD, advised by the scrooge board made the decision because MON choice of his backroom was too expensive in comparision.
I have had enough of this gas-lighing arse. He is the problem, dragging the team back into short back and sides possession when ever they start to make any progress. Why do you think the anti- Celtic media give him so much airtime? Fully expect to be banned but you know what probably for the best as I can’t see any progress until Peter Pointer has left the building and will continue to say so.
Who can we get to replace him? Do we know anyone else who can pass a ball 3 yards backwards and then point to where it should go? How about every other player in the SPL and lower leagues?
For the team’s sake I can only hope he will be dropped for speaking out.
Who would you play in his place, anyone watching Celtic these days who thinks CalMac is the problem at the club, is very much mistaken.
MM as I said I see CalMac’s game as passing the ball backwards and sideways three yards and therefore I believe every single player in the SPL could replace him. I understand he believes it is the correct way as if you have the ball the opposition can’t score. I disagree with that philosophy as the match only lasts 90 mins so I believe in all out attack and stopping the other team having a “high press”. I don’t think it is the Celtic way and therefore I blame him however the real culprit his Rodgers who instilled the culture of fear about losing the ball.
Perhaps CalMac feels he doesn’t have the players to win the ball back and I guess that is the fault of the board. I want that possession philosophy gone.
The fact that this controversial video by Cal Mac was allowed to be aired on the Celtic U-Tube channel.
The contents are clearly know to be a vailed attack on Martin, Malone and Fozzy .
Tells me that the cunning bastards on the board and Mute Mike and Weasel Wilson have decided too ‘Empty” the three stooges ASAP.
I predict that Keane & Co will be installed after the Turks pump us big-time on Thursday.
Cal will head for the Heath Row departure lounge and catch his flight to join Brendan and John Kennedy or maybe even Ange.
Then he can retire gracefully unlike the bombastic Martin who has failed on his second attempt at glory.
His legacy is that he wholeheartedly supported DD&Son who denigrated our fans.