Paulina has already written this morning about Haissem Hassan and Callum Osmand, and rightly so. Both of them gave Celtic something different in the second half last night, something quicker, more direct and more dangerous than what we had seen before the interval.
I do not want to simply repeat that argument here.
I want to widen the lens a little, because what happened in Lisbon told us something about more than two individual players. It told us something about the shape of this team, the problems Martin O’Neill still has to solve and, perhaps, one version of Celtic which might actually be worth pursuing.
That was a strange night.
The first half was every bit as bad as we feared and every bit as difficult as we expected, given the options available to the manager at the back and the continued absence of a proper ball-winning player in the middle of the pitch.
At half-time, Celtic had pretty much got what we deserved.
The second half was different. Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain came into midfield, Hassan appeared on one side and Osmand on the other, and suddenly Celtic looked more mobile, more dangerous and far more capable of causing Benfica problems.
There is an experiment in there which I think O’Neill should try again.
I feel slightly sorry for Høgh because I think he was scapegoated for the first-half performance. Sebastian Tounekti was too, and I am not quite ready to throw either of them to the wolves.
For a start, I think Høgh is being unfairly maligned. I actually thought he played reasonably well in the first half, certainly compared with the dysfunction happening behind him.
He worked hard, tried to make things happen and was operating in a team where some of it was functioning badly. Strikers are often judged in isolation when the real problem is that the service into them is poor, the wide areas are not working and the midfield is not giving them enough support.
Last night was worse than that; I thought our attacking players were punished for lapses at the back that had damn all to do with them.
So, I am not prepared to pin that first-half performance on them. Still, there is another reality which Celtic now has to confront: I do not see a version of this team which accommodates Hassan, Høgh and Durán together.
At some point, one of them has to be sacrificed. Right now, because Durán is scoring goals and Hassan is creating them, Høgh is probably the one who drops out.
I feel bad for him, but that is football.
Osmand also gave Celtic more than Tounekti did when he came on. That does not necessarily mean Tounekti had a bad game. I thought his getting subbed last night was more about the guy being asked to do things which are not naturally part of his game.
When he was caught completely wrong-footed in the penalty area for the first-half goal, that was not because he is a bad footballer. It is because Tounekti is not a defender, and that is not what where he was supposed to be in the first place.
If you want to examine how Celtic ended up with an attacking player performing defensive duties in his own penalty area, then look at the tactical structure around him.
Kieran Tierney was excellent overall, but the way Celtic pushes both full-backs so high up the pitch means attacking players are regularly required to cover the space behind them. Those players do not have a defender’s instincts, so why are we surprised when they can’t quite get the job done?
The same problem exists on the other side, perhaps even more. Colby Donovan plays far too high up the pitch for the amount of protection Celtic has behind him.
There was one moment in the first half where he was crossing the ball from Benfica’s corner flag. A simple pass out of defence then left their player running into an enormous space down our right-hand side with nobody anywhere near him.
That is not primarily an individual error. It is coaching, tactics and structure.
And that is exactly why I am reluctant to savage individual players for problems which the system itself is helping to create.
At the weekend, I would probably go with much the same back four which started against Benfica. There are not many alternatives.
Dane Murray made a horrendous mistake in giving away the penalty, but that is what can happen when you throw an inexperienced young defender into a game against opposition of this quality. You cannot demand that young players learn at the highest level and simultaneously expect them never to make painful mistakes while doing it.
The midfield is where the decision is more complex, but I think it was made easier last night.
I would play Callum McGregor, Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain and Mika Baur all day, every day. I thought the McGregor-Oxlade-Chamberlain combination looked significantly more promising than most of the midfield combinations we have seen this season, and Baur is the obvious player to complete that three.
Then I would put Osmand wide left and Hassan on the right. Up front, take your pick as far as I am concerned, but Durán is scoring goals and right now that means he gets the nod.
The negatives from last night could fill another article, and there is one issue in particular which I want to come back to properly, so I am not going to disappear down that road here.
We knew Celtic needed central defenders. We knew we needed better options across the back line. We knew we needed a defensive midfielder. We have all said it often enough.
The club chose not to address those problems properly, and we are seeing the consequences. So very little about the negative side of the Benfica performance surprised me. What surprised me were the positives.
I did not expect Oxlade-Chamberlain to improve the midfield as much as he did. I did not expect Hassan and Osmand to give us that much more energy and threat in the wide areas, and I did not expect to come away from this game thinking there might actually be a version of this team worth pursuing.
That is the part I want to hold onto.
I said after the Motherwell game that it was one of Celtic’s best performances of the season, and there was one reason above all others: movement off the ball.
Football has to be fluid.
Watching a static system where players hold their positions and the ball is eventually lumped towards a solitary striker was horrible, and we saw far too much of that, particularly in the two games against the club from Ibrox.
Those performances should be seared into the memory of everybody who had responsibility for the coaching on those days.
Against Motherwell, the movement returned. Players pulled defenders out of position, created space, created chances and got shots on target.
Crucially, we saw plenty of that again against Benfica. Celtic hit the woodwork three times. We had opportunities, the forwards looked mobile and their movement created space for themselves and for other players.
In the attacking third, I thought Celtic played well. On another night, if we keep the door closed at the other end and avoid conceding the early goal, perhaps we even get something from the game.
Because this is exactly what we thought when those new players arrived. They are good footballers. They change the dynamic of this team and make us quicker, more fluid and less predictable. The problem is that the weaknesses behind them remain.
That is the wider issue for me this morning.
Paulina is right to concentrate on Hassan and Osmand because their performances deserve attention. But I think the bigger question for O’Neill is whether he can build a structure which allows those players, Oxlade-Chamberlain and Durán to express themselves without constantly exposing the defensive weaknesses Celtic failed to address in the summer.
That is the balancing act. Because there is the outline of a good attacking side here.
There are players who can move the ball quickly. There are wide players who can beat opponents. There is a striker currently scoring goals. There is now a midfielder in Oxlade-Chamberlain who looks capable of adding some drive and presence … if and when he plays and that’s going to be the X factor of course.
But none of that matters enough if every time Celtic commits players forward, one simple pass leaves the defence exposed.
Overall, it was a poor result. Benfica are a top-class side capable of punishing exactly the weaknesses Celtic carried into Lisbon, and I never expected this to be some glorious European evening.
What I did not expect was to see things I genuinely liked, especially after the break.
That gives me some comfort, but more importantly it gives Martin O’Neill something to work with at the weekend.
He could do far worse than look closely at the team which finished in Lisbon and ask himself whether starting with Oxlade-Chamberlain, Osmand and Hassan gives Celtic something we have been missing for much of this campaign.
Movement, energy and fluency.
Players creating space for one another rather than standing in rigid positions waiting for something to happen.
The problems have not disappeared. Not in the least.
But for the first time in a while, I came away from a European defeat thinking Celtic might actually have stumbled across part of the solution.
Paulina has dealt with two of those individual answers already this morning. The wider challenge now is whether O’Neill can put those answers inside a system which does not simply create another problem somewhere else.
That is the real work. And now he has to be brave enough to do it.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

Conceding a penalty in the first 5 minutes was the end for us, the defending for the 2nd and 3rd goals was terrible and I am 100% ready to throw Tounekti to the wolves, he’s had plenty of chances and he’s never going to be the guy. He’s 4th choice behind Yang, Jota and Osmand. Even if those 3 were unavailable I’d be tempted to play someone else on the left. Hogh needs to prove himself but it’ll have to be off the bench if we persist with this formation because Duran is better than him as CF and Hassan has to start on the right. That’s our hardest game of the season out of the way at least.
A fair article james but some ifs and buts. Benfica hit the woodwork a few times also. This could easily have been 6-1 similar to their Hearts game. Benfica poor up front and in defense and would get totally found out in the UCL. They seemed to think the game was over at half time (which it was) and they became a bit stale, though they improved a bit with the subs.
Some positives though and Hearts will be a far easier game which is necessary because our coaching staff are bereft of ideas.
I really wanted Murray to develop and be our academy diamond, but unfortunately time and time again he costs us in big games. He’s done for me, just not good enough in the big games and almost always causes a goal with a poor attempted clearance or stupid mistake. Why MO’N dropped Scales instead of Murray is beyond me.
I’m also struggling with your defence of Tounekti. I’ve never known a winger who steadfastly refuses to take his man on and run into the space. Constantly passing back, and his wild shot over the bar from the Duran rebound sums him up perfectly.
If MO’N reverts to type on Sunday, Scales will come back in, the Ox won’t be in the squad and Nygren will come back in. Lets face it, with some of his selections, I wouldn’t be surprised if he gave Johnston another shot in goals!
James, in the words of George Galloway, I salute your indefatigability.
However, I have to ask, is it worth it?
The people in charge clearly care little for the club, and even less for the supporters.
While they are there, nothing will change, and there appears to be nothing anyone can do about it.
First of all, I don’t entirely find fault with Dean Murray at the penalty, the player blind sided him and dived in front of him just as he tried to clear it, that could have happened to anyone and it was unavoidable.
Claiming Tounetki is an attacker who is not used to tackling and therefore not culpable is just fkn nonsense, everyone has got to be adept at every aspect of the modern game, not particularly experts but certainly passable at various skills. Same goes with Donovan having to be coached to defend properly, again nonsense, he has a brain in his head and he should be using it, he has been caught out often enough to realise what he is doing wrong and I’m sure he has been taken to task on many an occasion by the coaching staff, so don blame them for him not listening.
AOC will drop out, Nygren will start. Osmond will also not start. It’s all so predictable.
I agree 100% Johnny.
We seem to have this thing about categorising players as only having the skillset to play one position. This also applies to midfielders,
I asked a pal, who played at a good level, if he thought Celtic were missing a strong defensive midfielder. He replied by asking me if Graeme Souness was a number 6, 8 or 10. I realised what he was getting at and and replied “all three”. He confirmed that was correct and said he couldn’t believe Celtic were considering paying big money for a midfielder who could only play No. 6 and no other position.
DannyGal – completely with you and Johnny here. Tracking back and impacting the situation is an integral part of a wide player’s responsibilities. Too often when Tounekti tracks back he doesn’t affect the attacking player at all. And players need to be adept at a number of roles – PSG don’t have a “ball-winning” midfielder, they have better midfielders all of whom can tackle, control the ball, pass and move the ball forward. When Hakimi goes forward, a midfielder fills the gap – when Donovan goes forward, too often nobody covers the gap, which is unforgivable.
I think we are pretty strong in the forward areas (especially with Yang and Jota coming back). Osmand is a real talent and I expect him to force his way onto the pitch.
Let’s see whether AOC gets game time and I am keen to see what van den Berg offers.
James you seem to be hard on certain players, and excuse others for laziness and lack of concentration. Our C/B’s are left exposed on so many occasions, Donovan is a really promising player, but tends to go a wandering at times, Tierney hasn’t the pace these days to recover when teams turn over possesion, and it leaves us one on one, or two on two at the back, on so many occasions .Our attacking side of the game is alright, it is the link, or lack of it, between Defence and M/F especially defensively that’s the problem.
Benfica have some better players than us, that’s just a fact, Portuguese teams get the choice of young Brazilians with the laguage in common, and Portugal is an attractive country to play football in.
MON and our coaching team have to find a way of getting an improvement in defensive areas, On Sunday I would definitely play Scales, rather than Murray, who again showed his inexperience, by getting suckered by the cheating player, who tricked the referee into the penalty award. You see penalties awarded every week from that kind of situation , it is cheating, but has just become part of football because of weak refereeing.
Hearts threats come from down the wing, with Miller and McPake proving that there is life in your football career, after being dumped by the Celtic and Sevco Academies.
I also thought it very harsh that a player can just stick his leg in from behind at a ball which is about to be kicked and get a penalty for it.
An outrageous rule imo
A feel sorry big Dane there but rules are rules I suppose.
Benfica went in at HT with the game won and did what any team would in those circumstances and dropped a few gears. They could have kept it going and scudded us but they went easy on us, hence why we looked better in the second half…game state as the analysts call it.
You’d think Paulina was playing for the Tic the amount of mentions she got in this article. Lol.
I don’t know if it’s just me but at the beginning of the season I thought AOC was our best performing midfielder. Showing his class with a full pre-season under him and then couldn’t play in Europe. After that, never got a look in. Strange decision in my opinion
You’re right I think, the Ox looked a step up on where he was last season and said after the game all he needed was minutes. I know everyone not playing wants to play but I’ve been very surprised at how little he’s featured. Him and McGregor could share the load, it might benefit everyone