15th August 2026; Tannadice Park, Dundee, Scotland; Scottish Cup Football, Dundee United versus Celtic; Benjamin Nygren of Celtic celebrates after he shoots and scores in the 62nd minute to make it 4-0
A couple of weeks ago, in the aftermath of their two victories over us, one of the Ibrox ex-players in the media, I think it was Alan Hutton, suggested that there was no Celtic player who would get into their team.
That, of course, is a preposterous statement to make. It is one of the most idiotic things anybody has said this season so far. When you consider it on its own merits, you quickly realise that it has none.
They are allowing a handful of performances to blind them to the simple fact of the matter, which is that Celtic have better individual players than them in almost every department of the pitch.
That does not mean Celtic are playing better football right now. It does not mean we are functioning better as a team right now. It does not even mean we would beat them if we played them tomorrow.
But player for player, quality for quality, I have thought about this and looked at it in a hundred different ways, and I can only conclude that all talk of their squad being superior to ours is absolute nonsense.
Absolute nonsense.
Look at the Ibrox central midfield, for example, and ask yourself who, just in terms of merit and being the better footballer, would get into our team.
There is not one of them who would start over Callum McGregor. There is not one of them who would start over Mika Baur. We do not know how good Joël van den Berg is because we have barely seen him yet.
Oliver Sørensen has more experience and is a better footballer than Dan Neil. I think he is a better footballer than Cammy Devlin too. So is Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain.
You’ll notice I have not even mentioned Benjamin Nygren yet.
The simple fact is that they do not have a player in their squad anywhere near the calibre of Benjamin Nygren when he is played in his correct position as part of a system that works.
It’s a joke.
Look out on the left-hand side of the pitch and I do not believe they have a better player than a fully fit Jota, if we get him back. I do not even think there is any real argument for saying that, at the moment, they have better players on the left than Yang.
On the right-hand side, Haissem Hassan looks like he could become a superstar if, if, if things fall right for him.
And as for the forward line, that is not even a contest. That is an embarrassment.
Right-back? I do not believe they have a better right-back than a fully fit Alistair Johnston.
Left-back? Forget about it. Kieran Tierney all day, every day.
At central defence, although their defenders are majorly hyped, I do not think there is a better player in there than Cameron Carter-Vickers when he is on his game.
I think the claim is a bunch of nonsense.
The problem is not that Celtic lacks quality. The problem is that we lack balance, we lack cohesion and we lack a strategy that works.
If we had a single ball-winning midfielder, a big tough bastard, you could reconfigure this entire team around that one player and restore the balance that the side does not presently have.
I genuinely think you would see a different version of Celtic if we had that footballer.
We have too many players who are too similar, especially in midfield. The problem with Celtic is not all down to the personnel. The problem is that this team is all over the place tactically, and it is terribly coached.
Terribly coached.
I do not think I have seen a worse-coached Celtic side than this in a very long time.
They do not look fit. They do not look sharp. They do not look properly motivated. They do not look as though they know what they are supposed to do when they go onto the pitch.
It is incoherent, fragmented and broken.
But that does not mean they are bad players.
The squad imbalance is such that I am not even sure there is anybody in football who could come in and make this function properly as a unit with the personnel exactly as it stands.
And Martin O’Neill’s stated intention to have all the best players on the pitch? Well, that is a lot of players to try to cram into a system when there simply is not room for all of them.
There is literally no configuration of this present team that you can reliably expect to win games in which every one of those supposed best players also features.
It is the reason why I do not believe the return of Jota and AJ will necessarily make that big a difference.
They will improve their positions, absolutely. Of course they will.
But this team will still have the same midfield imbalance, and that is where games are going to be won and lost. Until we figure out how to play a style of football that actually suits our forward line, those players are going to wither on the vine.
The problem is not the personnel.
We have a squad which, in the right configuration and with one or two additions, would dominate this league and do so comfortably.
But those missing pieces are the critical element of the story.
Those missing pieces, the players we had the chance to buy in the summer and did not buy, are the whole story.
With them, this team flies.
Without them, this team does not function.
That is the sad reality going forward into January.
There are games when we are going to look good and be capable of playing good football, because we have the players in the team to play that kind of front-foot game.
But if we find ourselves having to fight and scrape and battle, especially in the middle of the pitch, it is not going to function at all.
If we cannot find a way to get the ball to our forwards, nothing is going to work.
I wish I believed this was all in the tactics. I wish I believed there was some system out there which would suddenly turn this into a title-winning side.
I do not believe that for a second.
I do not believe for a second that we currently have a title-winning squad in the form in which it has been constructed.
I think any team which puts us under pressure and any team which turns the game into a slog has a very good chance of taking points from us.
But this idea that there is no player in our squad who would get into the Ibrox team is a joke.
If you removed just two of their defensive midfielders and put them into our squad, that is game over.
You could probably pick any two half-decent defensive midfielders in this league, put them into our squad, and I would feel vastly more confident about this Celtic team.
And that is the disgrace here.
We have still not gone out and bought somebody to play in that position.
It is why we are giving trials to 32-year-old former Chelsea players who have not kicked a ball in anger in over a year.
That is how far we have fallen as a club, but it also shows you how desperate the need is, and everybody knows it.
The ultimate frustration is that with those one or two extra players, we would not be in this mess right now.
Now we have to get to January without them.
But do not let anyone tell you there is not a lot of talent in this Celtic team, because that is very obviously not the case.
There is plenty of talent here.
It is simply not in the right places and not in the right positions.
And this is what happens when non-football people interfere in football decisions, just as I discussed earlier with Ross Desmond.
Anyone who thinks this shambolic, incoherent squad-building strategy can continue is not paying attention in class.
The Ibrox club does not have better footballers than Celtic all over the pitch.
What it has, at the moment, is a team which makes more sense than ours does.
That is a very different thing.
And until Celtic understand the difference, until we stop confusing a collection of talented individuals with a properly constructed football team, we are going to keep looking considerably less than the sum of our parts.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

It’s a stop gap, but when he’s back I’d play AJ in that defensive midfield position. He played inverted under Ange, so is happy enough stepping into midfield and is the most combative player we have. Donovan to continue as RB.
Good article James “Unbalanced” sums our squad up, defensive midfield is a specialist position that the most unlikely players can sometime fit into. John Clark was a pretty ordinary M/F player until the sweeper defensive position became the thing in the 1960’s, playing behind the C/B.
He was a natural, his reading of the game in front of him and his anticipation of where the danger was going to be was terrific, he was small and not physically strong but his anticipation and intercepting when the opposition attacked was so impressive and allowed big Tam Gemmell and Jim Craig to gallop up and down the park, whilst he swept up behind Billy. Fast forward to the modern game and the best example we ever had of a great defensive Midfielder was Lenny, again he didn’t have to be a great tackler, because his reading of the game and anticipation of where the ball was going was so impressive. Both weren’t strong tacklers but you wouldn’t mess with them
Considerindg MON was Lenny’s manager with both Celtic and Leicester, I really thought that MON would have had a decent defensive midfielder in the door at the start of this season.
You do wonder if the suits at Celtic Park and the tracksuits at Lennoxtown ever talk to each other.
Just another point to annoy us There’s Swansea City at the top of the Championship in England, with two of their star men being Welsh and Idah, other managers seem to rate our players and can fit them into systems that work.
A lot of our players would get into the Ibrox side as first choice and this season they would do a lot better there than they are at CP. Some of their players would get in our team also. All our goalkeepers are poor, too slow. We haven’t had a real decent keeper since FF. Schmeichel and Hart were both done by the time we got them.
Raskin would prosper in our midfield. I’m not sure McGregors present day negativity would fit in to their side. The last game at Ibrox he was trying to keep the score down rather than attack the game. Neil looked not too bad either in that game. I think we could give him a run out.
While we can moan about not having perfect players for all positions. We have got some decent players (by scottish standards) and I think their coaches would get a lot more out of them. If you gave the LASK boss a couple of our players like Hogh & Duran it might have been double figures. Their most expensive signing cost less than we got for Johnny Kenny whom most of our fans labelled a reject!