I have said it before, and I will keep saying it until somebody inside the marble halls of Celtic Park finally decides to remove their fingers from their ears and listen to the people who make this football club what it is.
Celtic belongs to its supporters. It always has, and it always should.
Yet here we are again, watching another chapter in the increasingly poisonous relationship between Celtic’s Board and the supporters who dare to question it.
Honestly, I sometimes wonder whether the people running our club have mistaken Paradise for their own private kingdom, with Dermot Desmond sitting on his throne issuing commands while the rest of us are expected to bow, pay our money and keep our mouths shut. Well, I have news for the Celtic boardroom pricks.
That is not how Celtic works.
Celtic Ultras and the Green Brigade have now announced plans to boycott the remaining Europa League home fixtures and all Scottish Cup matches, home and away, including a potential appearance at Hampden.
They will also withdraw from the Home Cup Ticket Scheme.
Scottish Premiership matches are not included, and the groups have said they will review their position at the end of the season, or earlier if sufficient progress is made.
Before anybody in the Boardroom starts celebrating the disappearance of another inconvenient section of the support, perhaps they should ask themselves a rather embarrassing question.
How on earth did we get here?
The Green Brigade statement could hardly have been clearer. It described the disconnect between those who control Celtic and those who support it as having never felt greater, and warned that under Desmond’s influence a dark cloud hangs over the club, creating an increasingly poisonous environment.
I could not agree more with that central point.
The group also accused the Board’s latest statement of being another attack on supporters, particularly over the St Andrews protest, while expressing fears that the club’s response represents another warning that bans could follow.
Now, I am not suggesting that every action taken by every supporter group must be beyond criticism. Nobody gets automatic immunity simply because they wear green and white.
There can be perfectly legitimate disagreements about methods of protest, and the disruption at the Alfred Dunhill Links Championship has undoubtedly intensified an already bitter dispute.
But disagreeing with a particular protest does not mean we should turn a blind eye to the deeper problems at Celtic.
The Board’s response was to condemn the St Andrews disruption, withdraw recognition of the Celtic Fans Collective as a representative organisation and threaten indefinite bans against individuals found to have planned, facilitated or participated in the incident. Pasted markdown. The club is entitled to defend its position.
But perhaps somebody could explain how shutting the door on a representative body is supposed to rebuild trust with supporters who have spent years asking for greater accountability? How can the club level unproven accusations in that way in an attempt to split the fan-base and actually believe that is the road to success?
Maybe the Board has discovered a revolutionary new management philosophy.
If you stop recognising the people asking uncomfortable questions, perhaps the questions magically disappear. Genius. Somebody give these people a management award. Preferably one made of cardboard.
Let me be absolutely clear about my own position.
I believe Dermot Desmond’s influence lies at the heart of this increasingly damaging relationship between Celtic and its support. I do not believe Celtic can truly thrive while its leadership treats organised supporter representation as an inconvenience rather than an essential part of the club’s identity.
And I certainly do not believe that stern statements, threats of bans and refusing to recognise representative organisations amount to leadership. Desmond has been a central figure at Celtic for decades. His influence is enormous.
But with influence comes responsibility. I am sure I read that somewhere.
If he wants to exercise that level of power over the club, then he should expect supporters to scrutinise his decisions and demand answers. That is not rebellion. That is accountability.
Apparently, however, accountability is becoming one of those things certain people at Celtic Park would rather avoid.
Supporters are expected to renew season tickets, buy merchandise, travel across Scotland and Europe, sing themselves hoarse and defend Celtic through thick and thin. But when those same supporters ask for transparency, ambition or a meaningful voice, suddenly they become a problem to be managed.
How convenient.
The dark cloud hanging over Paradise is not going to disappear because the Board publishes another statement explaining how disappointed it is with supporters. Nor will it disappear because the Celtic Fans Collective is no longer recognised by the club.
Pretending that the people raising concerns have somehow lost their legitimacy does not make the concerns disappear.
It merely makes the leadership look increasingly unwilling to confront them.
And this is why we have to look beyond the Green Brigade alone.
The Celtic Fans Collective brings together a range of supporter organisations around demands for transparency, accountability and ambition. Its existence reflects something much wider than one ultras group or one particular protest.
It reflects a growing desire among Celtic supporters to have a meaningful voice rather than being treated simply as customers whose responsibility begins and ends at the ticket office.
I find it astonishing that a club with Celtic’s history has allowed relations with so many of its own supporters to deteriorate this far, and I would ask the Board one simple question. If this many people are unhappy, might the problem possibly lie somewhere other than with the supporters? When do these people question their own role in this?
I know. What an outrageous suggestion.
Perhaps the next club statement can explain that the Celtic support has collectively lost its marbles while everybody in the Boardroom has somehow achieved managerial perfection. That would certainly save them the inconvenience of examining their own decisions.
But sarcasm aside, this is serious.
A football club cannot thrive when its leadership and a substantial section of its support are locked into a permanent cycle of accusation and retaliation. Supporter groups can make mistakes. The Board can have legitimate concerns about particular actions.
Both of those things can be true. What cannot continue indefinitely is a relationship where every disagreement becomes another battle for control.
I keep coming back to the same question.
When does this end? When do we finally get a Celtic Board which understands that supporters are not the enemy?
When do we get leadership which recognises that listening to criticism is not weakness, but one of the basic requirements of running a major football club? I want Celtic to thrive. I want a club which combines success on the pitch with ambition, transparency and respect off it.
Instead, we have a Board which appears increasingly comfortable fighting battles against its own supporters while the football operation itself has enough problems demanding attention. The timing could hardly be worse.
The team needs stability. The manager needs conditions in which he can actually work. The club needs to rebuild confidence.
Instead, we are discussing boycotts, bans, protests and a total collapse of trust. As far as I am concerned, Desmond’s continuing influence remains one of the greatest obstacles to repairing that relationship.
If the present approach continues, Celtic will remain trapped in this miserable cycle, with supporters demanding change and the Board apparently determined to demonstrate that it will not be dictated to.
Nobody is asking the Board to surrender its responsibilities. We are asking it to understand that responsibility includes accountability.
There is a difference between running a football club and behaving as though the club belongs exclusively to those who occupy its Boardroom.
Celtic’s history, identity and worldwide reputation were not built by the principal shareholders. They were built by generations of supporters who gave this club their voices, their money, their loyalty and their hearts.
Those supporters deserve better than carefully worded statements and threats of exclusion.
I do not expect every Celtic supporter to agree with the boycott. Some will support it. Others will oppose it. Many will have mixed feelings. That is perfectly reasonable.
But I refuse to accept that the answer to this crisis is to dismiss every supporter organisation which challenges the Board. And I refuse to accept that loyalty to Celtic means remaining silent when the club is being badly served by its leadership.
My loyalty is to Celtic Football Club.
To its history. To the supporters who make Paradise what it is. And to the idea that Celtic should always be bigger than the ego of any one individual, no matter how wealthy or influential he might be.
I want the dark cloud lifted from Paradise. I want Celtic to thrive, not simply survive. And I want a Board which understands that supporters are part of the solution, not the enemy.
Until that happens, the same question will continue hanging over Celtic Park.
When does it end?
Because honestly, I am sick and tired of watching a club with such extraordinary potential being dragged into another needless war with its own people.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

Detmott Desmond the Gerald Ratner of Celtic Football Club He is Killing our club by a thousand cuts.
Who in their right mind would go to war with people who put in over £40m into a club every year. The guy and his fellow parasites have lost the plot. Just GTF before you do anymore damage
****HAUD YER WHEESHT ***
The message delivered to the participants of the Dunhill at the home of Golf in particular and the world in general used Humour and Witt to alert the entire sporting world of the crisis at “the club like no other”
Mission accomplished by what I like to call The Walfrid Flying Pickets.
The reaction at 22:10GMT was absolutely fantastic.
The official CELTIC FC PLC website was used to declare all out war on the supporters and anyone agreeing with the supporters was the way I interpreted the mother of all rants.
Let it be know that anyone doing business with DD & Son may be legitimately targeted by Witt, Humour, Ridicule peaceful protest or Boycott.
A famous group once statated “you have to be lucky all the time we only need to be lucky once”
Rumor has it that the Spalding Company are working OT to catch with the surge of Tennis Baws!
The Wimbledon Tennis Club recruitment staff were highly impressed with the bowling technique of our displayed on the 15th Green and would like to hire our Bhoys…..
In honour of the publicity given to the Dunhill The home of Golf will rename the 15th Green Desmond’s Folly.
The Bells of hell go ting-a-ling for DD,&Son.