Scott Brown says Celtic needs to come together. He says supporters should not be interrupting Board members in their free time, and when it comes to whether the Board is actually doing a good job or not, well, apparently that is above his pay grade.
It is clearly above his IQ level as well.
Look, I am not going to beat around the bush here. I know this is another darling of a large section of the fanbase, but based on his latest contribution Scott Brown has got absolutely nothing constructive to offer this debate.
What he has offered is simply another version of the same argument we keep hearing from elsewhere: everybody needs to calm down, everybody needs to come together, supporters need to get behind the club and somehow all of this will sort itself out.
What that really means is very simple.
Sit down. Pay your money. Shut up.
Well, you know what? Screw that, and screw anyone whose message to supporters is that their job is to support the team come what may.
I am through being gentle with people on this subject because there are a lot of folks around Celtic right now who are playing a double game, and some of these pleas for unity are not pleas for unity at all. They are paving the ground for something else.
Brown, in particular, has every reason to want to remain on good terms with the people currently running Celtic.
We know (because it’s on the record) that senior figures at the club have regarded him as somebody who can return to Celtic whenever the right opportunity comes along. Peter Lawwell said as much. He spoke openly about Brown having a future at Celtic.
And so, Brown’s intervention would carry considerably more weight if he were some completely detached former player looking at this situation from the outside. He isn’t. He has longstanding relationships with these people. He has history with them. They like him. They regard him fondly and I hear they’ve tried to bring him to the club several times.
Celtic has already made clear in the past that there will be “opportunities” for him.
Notice what is missing from that proposition.
There is no suggestion that Brown has to go away and become an outstanding coach first. There is no suggestion that he has to build an exceptional managerial career, distinguish himself from his peers and come back when his professional record demands serious consideration.
There will be opportunities. Not when he has earned them.
When he wants them.
That is exactly the problem.
I have written about this before. You can often tell when a regime is running out of road by the calibre of the people fluttering around the throne room. At the beginning, when an organisation is healthy and ambitious, it tends to attract serious people. It hires people who know what they are doing. Talent wants to be around success, confidence and ambition.
But the closer an ageing regime gets to the end, the more the genuinely credible people start keeping their distance. What remains are the flatterers, the loyalists, the self-deceivers and those who think proximity to power proves that they have arrived, even if that power is ebbing away each and every day.
That is when “he knows the club” starts replacing “he is the best person for the job.”
And Celtic is already stacked to the gills with former players and familiar faces contributing either very little or, in some cases, nothing that could not be done better by somebody selected through a proper meritocratic process.
I have nothing against former players coming back to Celtic. Nothing whatsoever.
But they have to earn it just like everybody else.
If Scott Brown goes away and becomes an outstanding coach, if he develops players, builds great teams, proves himself tactically and professionally and reaches the point where Celtic would be foolish not to consider him, then fine. Welcome home.
But what has he accomplished in his coaching and managerial career so far which remotely justifies handing him an important position at Celtic?
If his name was not Scott Brown, and he had never captained this club, would anybody seriously be suggesting him for one?
Of course not, and that is the culture I object to.
Celtic is already weighted down with mediocrity.
There are too many people inside the building who seem to survive because they are known, liked or trusted rather than because there is overwhelming evidence that they are excellent at what they do.
That matters even more when the club is losing money, because one of the reasons organisations lose money is that they do not get sufficient value from the money they spend. Should Michael Nicholson be on anything approaching the remuneration he receives? Are you kidding me? Where is the value for money there?
The same question should be asked whenever another familiar face is elevated into an important football position without first demonstrating that he is amongst the best available candidates.
Stephen McManus has now been elevated into a first-team coaching role. What has he done which makes that an obvious merit-based appointment?
This is therefore not really a rant about Scott Brown, although Scott Brown is grinding my gears right now.
It is a rant about what Celtic has become.
A club filled with people whose greatest qualification sometimes appears to be that they already have friends in the building, that they are liked, that they are trusted, that somebody remembers them fondly.
The requisite skill set seems almost secondary, and that brings me back to Brown’s comments about supporters.
Brown is cosying up to the wrong people here, and I have always had the impression that Brown comes from that school of footballer which believes supporters have one principal role: support the team. Beyond that, we’re not worth listening to.
There is a school of thought amongst some people within football that supporters do not really understand the game, do not understand the pressures involved, do not understand how clubs operate and should therefore leave the serious decisions to the professionals.
Perhaps I am wrong about Brown.
But he sometimes comes across that way, and his sycophantic toadying to Desmond and the club hierarchy this weekend was, and is, nauseating. He says that right now it’s just constant negativity that affects the team; with all due respect to him he’s talking out of his backside. The team continues to get the support of fans. It’s everyone else at the club we have serious, and deep-seated, concerns about.
So, when Brown tells us that Celtic needs to “come together”, I hear echoes of the same argument being made everywhere else. Everybody needs to sit around the table. Everybody needs to talk. Everybody needs to calm down. Everybody needs to compromise.
It sounds wonderfully reasonable.
The problem is that it bears almost no relationship to how disputes work in the real world. Sometimes the people sitting across the table from you are people you fundamentally disagree with. Sometimes they want something you are absolutely unwilling to give. Sometimes you want something from them which they have no intention of conceding.
And as I wrote yesterday, if you are going to negotiate with people in those circumstances, you need leverage. Without leverage, you get nothing.
The idea that Celtic supporters and this board can simply “come together” ignores the entire substance of the dispute. Supporters want change. The board does not want change. There is your problem, and if he is suggesting that change is not necessary at this club then he’s either woefully ignorant of what’s going on here or he has another motivation which I think we need to be questioning him about, it’s as simple as that.
What Brown and others are really asking supporters to do is surrender their side of the argument. Stop demanding resignations. Stop protesting. Stop embarrassing directors. Stop applying financial pressure. Stop making life uncomfortable.
In short, to care enough to hand over the money but not enough to actually care what we are getting from it. Well, I’m afraid I’m not willing to do that, and tens of thousands of other Celtic have indicated that they feel the same way.
Because if the people running Celtic change absolutely nothing while supporters are expected to stop opposing them, that is not unity.
That is capitulation. And I will not do it. A great many other Celtic supporters will not do it either. This club has to change. It has to. It must. It is imperative that Celtic changes because otherwise we are a fading power.
Our best days will not be in front of us. They will be behind us.
The success we enjoy today is not guaranteed tomorrow, and one of the great dangers of success is that it allows mediocre people to convince themselves that they caused it. That is where Celtic is now. We have an institution which possesses extraordinary advantages and yet increasingly looks incapable of exploiting them properly.
A football club with enormous resources, enormous support and enormous potential which is nevertheless repeatedly dragged backwards by bad structures, poor appointments, weak strategic thinking and a culture which values familiarity far too highly.
And we are supposed to come together around that? No. I am sorry if, from inside his bubble, Scott Brown cannot see the reality of where Celtic stands. But that reality does not cease to exist because he cannot see it.
This club is in a state of profound crisis.
Supporters have been insulted, dismissed and treated with contempt, and the idea that the people responsible for that and the people on the receiving end of it can now simply sit happily under the same roof because Scott Brown thinks everybody should pull together is childlike, simplistic nonsense, the kind of analysis that is only offered by morons or those who want something out of those in charge.
The problem is not that Celtic supporters refuse to unite behind Celtic.
They already are united behind Celtic. That is why they are angry. That is why they are fighting. That is why they care.
The problem is that the people running Celtic refuse to change.
Until they do, “come together” is just another polite way of telling supporters to sit down, pay their money and shut up, and if Scott Brown, or anybody else, thinks that is what Celtic supporters should do, then my answer is exactly the same as it was at the start. Screw that, and screw anyone who makes that contemptible argument.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

Thought exactly the same when I heard him spouting that drivel. Come on Broony, give it a rest. \?/
Broony will always be remembered for being a great captain and player, but manager/coach I am afraid not.
Just ask Ayr United fans and they all say he lacked commitment and was more interested in media duties.
Scott Brown came to Ayr United and initially improved the team. He talked positively about playing on the front foot, having a high press and playing positively. Although the signs were good in the early days, it soon fell apart, the high press disappeared and the team were awful to watch. One mistake from the goalkeeper and he was dropped. next one came in and made a mistake; he was dropped. Scott went through 6 goalkeepers in one season. His pre and post match interviews showed him to be intransigent. They were repetitive, boring and uninspiring. What seemed like a good appointment turned into a disaster. I don’t think Ayr fans objected to his media duties but they certainly objected to his management of the team. With the failure of his spell at Ayr United behind him, he soon increased his media duties as a respected pundit but, like many others it would have been preferable if he had applied his great insights to improve Ayr United , to show Celtic what he was capable of. As things stand, I can see nothing in Scott Brown that could benefit Celtic. However, its not what you know, it’s who you know. An extremely successful footballer: A very poor football Manager.
Brooney is right, we do need to come together. The fact is that a united Celtic is far more powerful than a fractured Celtic. We got to be the most powerful club in the land by being united, by believing we were no longer backothebussers……. yet, our own club “leaders” are trying to stuff us to the back o the bus. As the song goes……an Ebglish boss a bastard, an Irish one even worse. We’ll unite when the causes of division are out the door #notanotherpenny
The fans already “came together” with the club for the run in to the title last season. Their “reward” for that was the shambles that was the last few days of the transfer window. The board have also now officially stated there will be no “coming together” after a few tennis balls were thrown at their largest shareholder.
What interests me is how MON will deal with the media questions in this weekend’s presser. I’m not sure he can genuinely adopt the “come together” approach now after the board’s statement.
If he sides with the board and condemns then the protests will move beyond just the board. That could get ugly.