Has the door been closed indefinitely to fan media? It sure seems that way.
If you follow the online controversies around Celtic, you will know that a number of sites and individuals in Celtic cyberspace have been frantically trying to distance themselves from a comment made on a podcast the other day suggesting that perhaps Dermot Desmond was deserving of a bullet.
I find myself wondering what kind of age we are living in when people feel compelled to apologise for something somebody else said.
What kind of age is this where simply being part of a community apparently means accepting responsibility for the actions and words of everybody else within it?
And what kind of world have we created when people are so concerned at their own standing that they feel they have to protect themselves against even the possibility that somebody completely unrelated to them might somehow have blackened their name?
Because I do not accept that premise at all.
This is one of the great tricks of the political right, and it is no coincidence that we are seeing a version of it deployed here against the Celtic fan media movement by allies of the board and its grovelling, snivelling apologists.
Somebody somewhere says something stupid, offensive or outrageous. Immediately everybody remotely associated with the same cause feels compelled to denounce it. If you do not, apparently you endorse it. If you refuse to participate, apparently you are implicated in it.
It is nonsense. It is intellectually weak, fundamentally dishonest and, in my view, corrupt in the broadest sense of the word.
The people pushing this think they are being terribly clever. They are not.
Nobody should be accepting the premise of this bullshit. Everyone should be challenging it, because this trick only works if you accept the frame they have handed you. And we should not.
Let us examine the comment itself for a moment.
Does anybody seriously believe that the person who made it was announcing an actual intention to shoot Dermot Desmond? Of course not. It was a joke. It was completely off the cuff, the sort of thing you say in frustration and then regret.
You may think it was a terrible joke. You may think it was tasteless. You may think it crossed every line of acceptable discourse and that the person who said it should be criticised for doing so. Fine. I think you need to get out more, but I won’t give you a hard time over it.
But that is completely different from pretending it was a genuine threat, and it is a million miles away from suggesting that everybody else in Celtic fan media somehow has to answer for it.
Listen, I wrote last month about the Celtic site which said that the support was being reduced to putting its faith in the actuarial tables as a solution to the Desmond problem. I thought it was a beautiful line because it said an enormous amount without spelling everything out.
Everyone knew what it meant. But I elaborated on it anyway because there is not a single one of us who has not contemplated the obvious reality here.
This man has such a grip on the club that some supporters have reached the point where they believe the only realistic way the situation changes will be when he falls of the perch. That is a bleak place to be.
In America, opponents of Donald Trump have occasionally joked about the “hamburger from heaven”, another piece of deliberately dark humour about an apparently immovable figure eventually being removed by nature rather than politics. Nobody hearing that phrase requires a seminar to understand the joke.
Once you are having conversations about actuarial tables and hamburgers from heaven, you are already expressing the belief that circumstances will only fundamentally change when the individual at the centre of them is no longer alive.
That is not even dark humour, that is stating the grim reality of our situation, and deliberately collapsing the distinction between rhetorical excess and an actual threat is intellectually dishonest.
I am not a free-speech absolutist. In fact, I think free-speech absolutism is one of the most cowardly shields sections of the right hide behind, and many of its loudest advocates do not remotely practise what they preach.
What they often seem to want is the licence to say whatever they like while treating speech they dislike as some monstrous offence against public decency.
Donald Trump has talked approvingly about protesters being roughed up. He spread the grotesque and false claim that Haitian immigrants were eating people’s pets. Yet when journalists use ugly language about people around him, suddenly parts of the same political culture become enormously concerned about tone and civility.
Give us a fucking break.
And the Celtic version of this hypocrisy is every bit as transparent.
Some of the people wringing their hands over this and squealing like pigs are the very same people who have spent month after month denouncing fellow Celtic supporters in some of the most vitriolic language imaginable.
I have already said on the podcast that, as far as I am concerned, I have reached breaking point with some of them. I no longer consider them part of my community. I want nothing to do with them, no matter how this ends and no matter which way it goes. I have nothing in common with them at all.
And you do not get to behave the way they have for months and then suddenly appoint yourself guardian of acceptable language because somebody else says something you find offensive. That is not principle. It is opportunism.
So, do I wish to apologise on behalf of this outlet? Do I wish to distance myself from somebody else’s remark?
No. I absolutely do not. I did not say it. Nobody who writes for this site said it. We are not responsible for it.
And I reject completely the notion that every Celtic site, podcast or fan group must now line up and issue ritual denunciations lest somebody accuse us of secretly approving of assassination. It is absurd.
I hope the guy who actually made the comment does not feel compelled to perform some grovelling ritual of contrition either. As far as I’m concerned he made an off-colour remark that people are reacting to entirely dishonestly.
If he wishes to explain what he meant, that is his business. If he thinks it was a bad joke and wants to apologise, that is his business too. But those choices belong to him because the words were his. They were not mine. They were not yours. They were not the collective property of Celtic fan media.
And they certainly do not make the rest of us guilty by association.
Anyway, guilty of what? Of offending the tender sensibilities of a handful of board apologists? Well that won’t keep me up at night.
I am done pretending we are all merely engaged in some pleasant disagreement about the best way forward. Some of these people have spent the best part of a year treating fellow Celtic supporters with a level of contempt and hostility that would bring disgrace on some of the fan forums across the city.
And they can all eat shit.
They can complain their little faces off about this remark and anything else they like. The only way selective outrage like this works is if the rest of us agree to forget everything they themselves have said.
I am not prepared to do that.
If this dispute had been conducted in a civilised manner, if those on the other side had been honest about their positions, willing to practise what they preach and prepared to treat other supporters with basic respect, then perhaps we would be having a different conversation.
But they established the terms of this argument themselves. They accused us of being divisive. They accused us of acting out of self-interest and self-promotion. They accused people campaigning for change of somehow betraying the club.
They have questioned motives, smeared individuals and treated legitimate anger amongst the support as though it were something shameful.
So no, they do not now get to use one man’s off-colour joke as an indictment of an entire movement.
People are perfectly entitled to condemn what he said. I think they need to learn to take a joke, but they are not entitled to make everybody else responsible for it.
Because once this becomes an argument about collective guilt, it stops being about the remark at all. It becomes another attempt to delegitimise everybody who has challenged this board and everybody who refuses to accept the way Celtic is being run.
You know, eventually all of this will end. There will come a point beyond which we do not have to keep doing this anymore.
I have said from the beginning that change is inevitable. It is coming whether these people like it or not, whether they accept it or not and whether they approve of the form it eventually takes or not.
It is coming because Celtic cannot continue indefinitely as it is being run now.
But when this period is over, people will remember how others behaved during it. They will remember those who tried to smear an entire community of fellow fans because those fans care enough about their club to fight for it. They will remember those who used every controversy to pursue their own agendas.
And they will remember which people were prepared to argue their case honestly and which people preferred scummy tactics like guilt by association.
Because that is what this is really about. It is not morality. It is not tone. It is not suddenly discovering a deep concern for civility.
This is a smear job, and I understand why some people find that tactic attractive, because it is easier than arguing the actual case. Not one of them appears particularly enthusiastic about defending the way Celtic is being run on its merits.
So instead, we get distractions, outrage, lectures about tone, demands for denunciations and attempts to make an entire community answer for one man’s joke. I refuse to be cowed by any of it.
Because as tactics go, this is gutter level. It is pathetic.
And the correct response is not to apologise and play into their hands. It is to refuse the premise altogether. To Hell with them.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

I’ve a confession to make , I made a silly comment in response to a blog , I said & I quote, ( i would shoot them but I can’t afford the bullets ) I then said sorry don’t have the money , I then said it was only a joke , I made no direct threats to anyone person , maybe not the correct words but it was just a silly comment, so if your referring to me then I’m owning up and apologising , now I’ve been made aware of this I’ll be very careful about the choice of words I use in future , once again I can only apologise for my comments , I would say that my words were taken out of context , but that’s just a cop out , no more stupid remarks from me in the future . PS if this was about my comment, never at anytime did I mention anybody by name .
“So, do I wish to apologise on behalf of this outlet? Do I wish to distance myself from somebody else’s remark?
No. I absolutely do not. I did not say it. Nobody who writes for this site said it. We are not responsible for it.”
Is that not what you’ve just done James? Surely if you’re entitled to pass comments on other bloggers views, then they’re entitled to do likewise?
As the old saying goes “Many a true word spoken in jest”
I hope I’m not responsible for people falling out with each other, if my comment is not taken as a joke ( stupid as it was ) then maybe that’s what all Happy Clappers want , we all want what’s best for Celtic so let’s all get together and try to keep up the pressure the best way we can , whether we agree or disagree let’s keep the replies sensible & I’ll keep my mouth shut, HH
A stupid comment made by some eejit, but in the modern day climate of the internet, anybody sensible wouldn’t make such a comment.
As an auld guy still breathing after a long time in this World, I sometimes laugh to myself when thinking of my father and grandfather back in the day, and the terms they used for certain ethnic groups and throw away threats they would utter now and again in discussions. These were two men without any racist intentions or threatening behaviour in real life, and In fact like most Trade Unionists of their day, they would have criticised any racist, mysogynistic or sectarian behaviour, especially in the workplace.
The internet has changed the World and it has shown at times what a horrible species the Human Race can be. As far as the Football World is concerned, their is nothing I liked better than having discussions with fellow supporters, although sometimes it could get very heated, especially when drink had been taken. But when all’s said and done, Football is for recreation or entertainment, and we should always try to keep it that way.
Most Celtic supporters are level headed individuals, and know when someone’s serious or not, whoever this person is, sounds like a stupid individual and his podcasts should be given a body swerve.
I didn’t realise it was just a comment, I thought it was an actual Podcaster, I honestly don’t know what the hulaballoo is all about, one comment amongst thousands. In the 1980’s my auld auntie used to say Thatcher should be shot, but I don’t think she meant literally. On second thoughts maybe she did.
First off all Micmac , I’m not an eejit , if so maybe you’re auntie was , I still don’t know if I’m the one being referenced , if so I can only apologise for my remark similar to your auntie’s remark about thatcher , my frustration got the better of me, what more can I say , sorry again for a off the cuff remark being used as a stick to beat me with , people should grow up and take a response to a article written on a blog as just a way of expressing anger at something you hold dear and that’s CELTIC ,
Don’t take it personally, who knows if it’s you the article is pointing the finger at. We’ve all been eejits at times.
It’s not you man, it was on a live podcast with 4 talking heads, the comment then attributed to another Celtic podcast who had to clarify it was nothing to do with them and as James has pointed out, now various fan media outlets are feeling the need to say it’s nothing to do with them. Unless you were on that live podcast it isn’t your comment he’s talking about.
Micmac, coming from Greenock where Thatcher shut our shipyards and stopped our children’s free school milk in the same breath, I 100% wanted her dead, and not with a throwaway line. I celebrated the day that witch died as much as any other joyful event in my lifetime!
I have criticized some AI pics on here but I must say there are also some belters and this is one, with the typical Glesga red sandstone tenement street and the most iconic football top in the world, aye that also makes me pine to be living in one again.
And while I’m at it some of the very atmospheric AI pics of CP etc are excellent to.