I watched a lot of Celtic podcasts this morning, as I usually do, and I think I am just about caught up with the main reactions across Celtic cyberspace to everything that happened over the weekend.
There is broad agreement on one thing. The club statement was outrageous. Most people seem to recognise that it was inflammatory, counterproductive and utterly incapable of bringing the current dispute any closer to a resolution.
Yet I keep hearing the same proposed solution.
Talks.
Everyone needs to get around the table. Both sides need to start speaking again. Dialogue is the only way this situation will ultimately be resolved.
Well, yes. Of course it is.
But every time I hear somebody say that as though they have discovered the missing ingredient in this dispute, I wonder whether they have actually been paying attention for the last year.
I tend to look at things through the lens of politics because life is politics, and this situation has been political from the start. Forgive me too if I look at any organised campaign of this nature as effectively a resistance campaign, because I have spent most of my life studying how resistance campaigns work.
Talks are an essential part of them.
You always keep the door open to dialogue. You always recognise that ultimately there will have to be some sort of negotiated settlement. But keeping that door open does not mean standing outside it indefinitely while the other side refuses to answer.
Sometimes you have to force them to come to the table.
You make the pain calculus too great for them simply to ignore you. You make the risk calculus too serious for them to overlook you. Slowly but surely, you bring a party which otherwise has no reason to negotiate to the point where it realises that negotiation has become preferable to continuing the conflict.
There is nothing particularly original about what is happening at Celtic.
Resistance movements are almost always targeted for delegitimization by the people they are challenging. If you can persuade people that your opponents are unrepresentative, unreasonable or illegitimate, you reduce the pressure to deal with them.
That playbook is ancient.
What I struggle to understand is why anybody still believes this Board will negotiate meaningfully until it is compelled to.
People keep saying that the only way this gets fixed is by everyone sitting around a table.
If that had not already been tried, there would have been no need for direct action in the first place.
That option was pursued. Supporters organised. Meetings took place. Protests were suspended while discussions were ongoing. Arguments were put forward. The club listened.
Then it went straight back to doing what it had already decided to do.
That is not meaningful negotiation. And that is why there is no prospect of success by that road at this time.
Notice those words carefully: at this time.
I am not saying dialogue will never matter again. Quite the reverse. There will come a point where dialogue becomes essential.
But before that happens, Celtic supporters have to demonstrate something they currently do not possess at the negotiating table.
Leverage.
In any negotiated settlement, both sides arrive carrying their relative strengths.
Right now, supporters have very few cards to play.
The season-ticket money has already been paid. The team continues to receive its backing. The Board holds the authority, the institutional machinery and almost all of the formal power.
It does not need to negotiate.
And it has made it plain that it will not engage with the Celtic Fans Collective in any meaningful way.
That means supporters sitting down with the Board simply to explain themselves again achieves nothing. The Board already knows what supporters think.
The problem is not that our case has been insufficiently explained. The problem is that ignoring it currently carries too little cost.
That has to change.
The threat of action is no longer enough either. Supporters have to demonstrate that they possess both the capacity to act and the willingness to use it.
Last season provided two major examples.
The Not Another Penny campaign mattered enormously because it identified financial leverage. But the Dundee Scottish Cup boycott was perhaps even more significant because of what it demonstrated about scale.
People misunderstood that action at the time. Some spoke as though its success depended on Celtic Park being literally empty.
That was never the point. It is about calculus.
How many supporters have to stay away before hosting a match, operating the stadium, paying players, paying bonuses and absorbing all the associated costs starts to become economically unattractive?
Is it 10,000? Is it 20,000? Whatever the precise number is, that Dundee game showed that many tens of thousands of Celtic supporters were prepared to act together.
The same thing happened during pre-season. After a Double-winning campaign, those friendly matches ordinarily would have attracted significant crowds. Instead, grounds were conspicuously empty.
Supporters have already demonstrated resolve.
Now they have to demonstrate more of it.
Only then does sitting around a table begin to acquire a different meaning.
Because once the Board understands that supporters can organise action, can sustain it and are prepared to escalate it when necessary, the entire negotiating calculus changes. At that point the supporters sitting across the table are no longer simply people asking to be listened to. They are people with cards to play.
That is the difference between dialogue and negotiation.
The Board closing the door on the Celtic Fans Collective actually simplifies the situation considerably. It narrows the options.
If the Collective is told that there will be no meaningful engagement, then it no longer has to agonise over whether planned action might disrupt ongoing negotiations. The club has removed that dilemma itself.
And even while action continues, the Collective can maintain one simple position throughout: “We are willing to talk. You are not.”
That is powerful.
Anyone who imagines the Collective does not understand that this eventually ends in negotiation, and ultimately in concessions of some kind, has not been paying attention either.
The Collective sought dialogue from the beginning.
Direct action came because dialogue failed.
Its own statements have made clear that protests were called off while talks were taking place. Space was created for engagement to work.
It did not work. The next time protests are called, they go ahead.
There is another criticism of the present course which I keep hearing as well: that demanding resignations is somehow incompatible with negotiation.
Again, I do not understand this argument.
Political campaigns and resistance movements routinely identify specific individuals as part of the problem. Sometimes their position is precisely that meaningful progress cannot happen under the existing leadership.
That is not unusual.
When Celtic directors acted against what I believe were the best interests of this football club last summer in pursuit of a personal vendetta, they crossed a line for me.
I said then that everything had changed.
They do not simply get to remain indefinitely because demanding accountability might make future conversations uncomfortable.
Michael Nicholson is the most obvious example.
I have said repeatedly that I believe he is grossly unfit to be the chief executive of Celtic Football Club. Grossly unfit.
There is no negotiating our way out of that judgement.
Stopping calls for Michael Nicholson to leave would not suddenly make Michael Nicholson a better chief executive. Asking supporters to moderate that demand for the sake of dialogue would not make Celtic more effectively run.
You can negotiate policy.
You can negotiate supporter representation.
You can negotiate governance reform, security arrangements, communication structures and the mechanisms through which future engagement takes place.
You cannot negotiate yourself into believing somebody is competent when the evidence has convinced you otherwise.
So, this campaign is now in a different phase.
Constructive dialogue does not lie at the heart of this particular phase because Celtic itself has closed that door.
The door to future negotiation should remain open. It must remain open. Ultimately, this dispute almost certainly ends around a table.
But people need to stop confusing the destination with the road required to reach it.
If Celtic’s Board will not come to that table prepared to negotiate in good faith because supporters have asked politely, then supporters have to change the calculation.
They have to demonstrate strength. They have to demonstrate resolve. They have to demonstrate that ignoring them has consequences.
Once the Board understands that supporters possess genuine leverage, and once it understands that they are prepared to use it, talks may become meaningful again.
Until then, another meeting is just another meeting.
Everyone keeps telling Celtic supporters that this ends around a table.
Of course it does. But you do not arrive at that table with influence simply because you asked nicely enough.
You arrive carrying whatever leverage you have built.
Right now, the purpose of direct action is to build it.
The club has chosen the next phase. Action.
And so, action it is.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

I despise Lazio more than any club on the planet with the exception of sevco but you have to admire their actions when it comes to disputes with their club. It will be painful to watch but I think a competitive game and an empty stadium is what it,s gonna take
The board will not give in. The collective inflamed things 1000% with the St Andrews affair which was personal to the majority shareholder. We now have to take DD’s wrath. No board member will be replaced and no change of policy will happen now. No quality will be added to the squad. They will hoard the cash even more as the rainy day they spoke about has finally arrived.
It can happen but it requires solidarity. The fans are split on too many issues. ie the tennis balls, the GB, boycott, season tickets. etc. etc.
It probably requires a total collapse of the football team to get meaningful change…that might happen!
When are you gonna stop being a total dick Dan
I agree with your main point James but your facts are wrong. A organised boycott was called for the Dundee game but it only had around 40% support. 24,000 turned up compared to 40,000 to a comparable fixture the year before. That is not solidarity in fact it is a collapse in support for an organised strike. A company would love a union to capitulate like that.
All STs sold out….and they will all sell out next season.
So what’s the plan? Are we going to boycott the Celta europa league game? How much support is there for that? The last game the place was nearly full despite Bhoycie saying there was going to be 1000s of empty seats.
Does anyone know what’s going on?.
The collective looks rudderless.
I totally agree. The Collective does look rudderless and everything we hear from them is pointing the finger at independent supporters buses. What is the plan.
The only thing that will bring change at Celtic Park is a lack of success on the park. It’s the reason myself and one or two others on here wanted to see moderation and conciliation. This came from the support for the last 7 games of last season, and we saw the results of that common sense behaviour, with the double being dramatically won. The Board didn’t seem to learn the lesson, they carried on with their dictatorial policy of silence, and the continued barring of the Celtic supporting media.
I hate to say it, but in the near future, negative results on the park may find this Board out, and the backlash will be enormous. Crowds will diminish in size naturally through the season, and unless there is then big changes, ST’s sales next season will crash.
The us and them policy of this Board is mind bogglingly stupid, but on their heads be it, they have damaged our club in the short term, we tried to go down the conciliation route in the closing stages of last season, we bought ST’s till the sold out sign went up, and still they direspected us.
All I can say to damn them even more, is that Sevco would never behave like this towards their “loyal” fans. Enough said !
Micmac, I respect your views but I would expect season tickets to sell out again next season and there are plenty fans waiting on the list to replace the few who may not renew. I really admire those who don’t renew as it is a very tough decision
Micmac once again totally agree with your response , maybe just maybe if we all turned up for a home game and didn’t go in …..I know in my heart it would be hard and the “happy clappers” would still go in but hey ho! DAN YOUR STILL A DICK!
Absolutely correct, there is no negotiating at this moment of time, that bird has flown, and our intransigent board have made it quite clear that is the case. We need action, serious and sustained action, and we need the upper hand that will eventually force DD’s flunkeys into a climb down and eventual submission. It’s not going to be easy, it will be painful with a lot of bloodletting, but the Celtic support have to be relentless here, there should be no wavering and no compromising on their terms at any stage, there can only be one winner, the faction that truly owns this once great Club, and all true Tims have to show solidarity and be fully united against the enemy within.