Martin O’Neill did exactly what many of us feared he was going to do today. He took Dermot Desmond’s side.
He said that the fans who protested against Desmond were not Celtic. Well, I’m afraid to tell him this, but they were Celtic. They were Celtic supporters, and whether Martin likes the manner of that protest or not, they spoke for a great many of us when they made their feelings known.
And in some ways, his answer perfectly captures the strange place this club has reached. Because Martin O’Neill apparently thinks throwing a couple of tennis balls onto a golf course somehow places those supporters outside the Celtic family.
Well, this club operates with a 74-year-old manager whose relationship with some of the players may already be on shaky ground. It can sign an 18-year-old Chelsea reserve defender on loan who was not fit when he arrived, who is still not fit, and who might finally be available next week.
It can stagger from one short-term fix to another, one temporary solution to another, one improvised decision to another. Apparently, all of that can be Celtic. But a few tennis balls on a golf course? That, according to Martin, is somehow beyond the pale.
And perhaps that contradiction tells you everything about where we are. Because the problem is not that those supporters were somehow outside Celtic. The problem is that this increasingly dysfunctional version of the club is Celtic.
This shouldn’t be Celtic. But it is.
I’m going to be honest. I hoped that O’Neill would see the light and change course, but it was more hope than expectation. Because what he said today was pretty much what I expected him to say.
Whatever the reason, he is not going to shift from taking Desmond’s side. Whether that is because Desmond has leveraged him to the hilt and he feels he cannot speak his mind, or whether he genuinely has some misguided belief that fans brought almost to the end of their rope should not be allowed to protest and demonstrate their discontent, the conclusion is the same.
He is not going to take our side in this. He is not going to agree, or even accept, that we have rights in this situation at all.
Is this stuff fixable? Maybe it is. Maybe it isn’t. Only on a long enough timeline will we get the answers to those questions. Would it be easier if we had the manager in our corner? Yes, absolutely it would. But not this manager.
I never expected it from O’Neill, and I don’t expect it at any point in the future.
He talks about unity. But unity has been made impossible by the people who run this club. They play their little games. They fail to communicate a strategy, a vision or any kind of long-term plan. They have allowed the relationship between the institution and the people who sustain it to deteriorate to this point.
And all the while, this is presented as somehow normal. A club lurching from one improvised decision to the next. A manager brought back at 74 years old because the structures around him are so weak. Players arriving who may or may not fit the team. Short-term fixes layered on top of other short-term fixes. A recruitment operation so unclear that nobody outside the building seems able to tell you who actually runs it.
That is apparently Celtic now. And then supporters are told they are the problem for objecting to it.
O’Neill can call for unity all he wants, but unity is not something one side gets to demand after helping create the conditions which destroyed it. Unity is an outcome. It comes from trust. It comes from respect. It comes from people believing that they are being listened to and treated seriously.
You cannot manufacture it by telling supporters to shut up and get behind the team.
And that, ultimately, is what so many of these calls for unity amount to. It is exactly what his call for unity amounted to today. There was no acknowledgement whatsoever from him that perhaps there are reasons behind the protests and the anger.
So what he means is that Celtic is stronger when the Board can do what it wants, Desmond can run the club how he likes, and the rest of us sit back and shut up.
That is not unity. That is obedience. And that is not going to happen. That is over. That is done.
I don’t care that Martin O’Neill doesn’t like it.
But I will tell you this: if this all goes wrong, he is not going to get away with blaming us for it. He has his own role in this.
His effort today to roll back what he said three weeks ago was pathetic, and nobody should have bought it. There is no going back to the way things were until the club changes.
Until it improves its relationship with supporters, there is no restoration of normal relations here. That is finished.
O’Neill can be as disappointed as he likes, and all the former players who want to crawl out of the woodwork can be disappointed too. Fans are not going to be lectured anymore by people who take out of this club what we put into it. That’s done.
We are not going to be lectured anymore by ex-players and the Friends of the Man either. That’s done too.
If they don’t want to recognise where we are coming from, if they don’t want to accept that supporters might have legitimate reasons to be concerned and angry, then I honestly don’t care any longer what their opinions are. Because those opinions are based either on complete ignorance or a fundamental misunderstanding of what this is all about.
This is one of the most backward football clubs in Europe. And I don’t believe that is an exaggeration. There are corner shops better run than this club.
That is the madness of the whole thing.
The fans are treated as though they are unreasonable for objecting to dysfunction which would embarrass any properly run organisation. We are supposed to accept the chaos. We are supposed to accept the short-termism. We are supposed to accept the lack of strategy.
We are supposed to accept managers being undermined, recruitment being improvised, decisions being made without explanation and supporters being treated like an inconvenience. And then, the moment somebody objects, suddenly we are told Celtic is stronger when everybody is together.
Well, you know what? Tell that to the people who broke this thing.
Tell it to them, not to us, because we are sick of hearing it.
These people decided last summer that they were not going to support the Celtic manager who was in place at the time. They made that decision. No one else did.
They decided that the Celtic manager was somebody they were not prepared to support in the way a Board of Directors should support its manager. And when they made that decision, any moral right they had to lecture the rest of us about loyalty, unity and getting behind people evaporated immediately.
Since then, they have made things progressively worse.
And the extraordinary thing is that the guy sitting there today defending the major shareholder and criticising supporters for protesting has been screwed over by these people as much as almost anybody.
If he is willing to tolerate that, that is up to him. Somewhere along the line, he accepted that his role was to absorb the criticism on behalf of those running Celtic.
We don’t have to accept that role, and we’re not going to.
He would be better focusing on doing his job than telling fans what we should and should not be doing, because supporters are finally getting active again. I suggest he and the players do the same.
And he should not think that standing beside Dermot Desmond grants him some kind of immunity either. It doesn’t. If this goes wrong, he will be sacked just like every other manager would be.
Those above him will survive. They will throw him to the wolves in two seconds flat if doing so saves them from taking one iota of responsibility for their own mistakes.
That is another reason he should think very carefully about whose interests he is defending.
Because supporters are demanding change. They are demanding competence. They are demanding accountability. And they are demanding the right to say, loudly if necessary, that the people running this club are getting too much wrong.
That is Celtic.
So when Martin O’Neill says that the supporters who staged that protest were not Celtic, I think he has the whole thing backwards.
The players signed without obvious roles. The injured youngsters brought in before they were ready. The lack of long-term planning. The chaotic structures. The Board which will not communicate. The major shareholder who will not listen. The manager comparing tennis balls on a golf course with masked Ibrox supporters intent on causing harm.
None of that should be Celtic. But it is. That is the point. This is what Celtic has become.
And until the people running it are gone, there is no prospect of unity because this version of Celtic is unacceptable to those of us who want something more.
Martin O’Neill does not have to agree with us. He plainly doesn’t. But he cannot redefine Celtic so that the people protesting against this dysfunction are somehow outside it, while the dysfunction itself remains comfortably inside.
Those supporters were Celtic. This Board is Celtic. This manager is Celtic. This chaos is Celtic.
That is precisely the problem.
None of it should be. But right now, it is.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

I,to my sorrow will not be back at Celtic Park until this shitshow of a board are gone.At the age of 76 and supporting this magnificent club since my first game at the age of 4. I have had enough.I have been there through the good times and the bad times,through protests and all,followed everywhere from Lisbon to Leeds ,from Milan to Motherwell, from Seville to Station Park Forfar and here we are in a state I never ever thought this great club would be in. I have never been so sad to have to take this stand but here we are. I know I,by myself will not make a great deal of difference as my money for my ST has been paid but I finish with tears in my eyes writing this.
Hail! Hail!
Reply
I chucked it with my season tickets after Ange was Mark Lawwell’d with almost nothing but shit signings. I will always watch our games but I fear I will never be back.
I lost all respect for mon when as a talksport pundit he savaged our then manager BR more than once then when he was offered the Celtic job he said he was given 40 mins to decide if he was taking it ,what a f*****g lie that was he’s a money grabbing little **** who’s in the process of destroying his so called legacy and doesn’t even know it.
Good article James. Whatever his feelings MON should have refused to answer questions about the tennis balls.
There are stories going about, that he lost a lot of money in tax avoidance schemes, which if true wont sit well with many Celtic tax payers, but I think he has given enough to Celtic, and the club should pay him off. A few defeats and he will be gone anyway, and now he is under the most pressure he has ever had in his life.
The problem is. Who would want the job while there is wholesale unrest? It would only be someone who is desperate. I cant see Howe or Mckenna touching it with a bargepole right now.
MON is getting further away from the fans with every passing day and it looks like he does not care about that fact. I have stood by him previously, but I can no longer do that, it is time he passed the baton over.
All he had to say was
I love our fans, we need our fans, this isn’t something for me to comment on, I’m here to talk about football.
The end
Three weeks from now this club is going to be in the biggest crisis since 1994, Their lack of structure, ambition communication and respect for their fans has been beyond belief . Clubs all over the World would love to have a fan base like Celtic, but our largest shareholder, and the lackeys that do his bidding, don’t seem to appreciate what they’ve got, and just see the fans as mugs who supplyi the money that helps their gravy train to keep on rolling.
MON is out of touch with the mood of the fans, I wish he had walked away, the next 3 weeks is going to be a testing time for him. If he can come through this with 5 or 6 victories, then he may survive this period, I myself would be very surprised if this manager and team are capable of achieving those victories.
MON didn’t like the golf course stunt, fine. It’s his opinion. He did get round to saying something important and correct though, that he can’t control what fans might do, what the media might do, and that’s right. He should be focused on his job and just no comment to all the other stuff going on around the club. His job is to win football matches. His opinion won’t solve any of the deeper problems at the club and it’s not his mess to clean up anyway. He’ll constantly be asked to comment, it’s a game he can’t win so should just refuse to answer those questions.
MON has chosen a side today and it “isn’t Celtic”, it’s those holding Celtic back.
Superb article JF.
I was expecting him to be more conciliatory with both sides but he wasn’t, he backed his boss 100% and chucked Celtic fans under the bus.
Strange he would side with the people who have thrown him under the bus to.
MON needs to keep his mouth shut and learn to say no comment, i’m here to talk about football. We’ve learned recently that he can’t even do that. We learned how he handles defeat. Defeat by a shitty club across the city. He runs away from scrutiny and threatens to leave. We know it “didn’t take him long to decide”, because he realised the easy money he would be losing. All his recent stunts have put him way down in my estimation. The fans ARE Celtic, Martin. Button your mouth and focus on beating a shit Sevco team. And while we’re at it, it’s about time we got rid of Maloney & Co and brought some proper coaches in.
Martin Martin Martin
Thought he would have had more experience in dealing with the media.
Looks like he has gave in and will just go through the motions until he is asked to leave.
Feel so sorry it has come to this for him.
I’m struggling to see what’s changed to take MON from his downtrodden statement from three weeks ago to yesterday’s statement that he’s now raring to go again.
His words matched his demeanour three weeks and but yesterday it looked like the same demeanour, but with words that didn’t match it.
Could the difference be that he’s been told he’ll only be paid if he sees out his contract till the end of the season? That would enable DD to do the sacking and prevent a repeat of his humiliation at BR walking out on him.
Why do the protests from even the most rebellious fan groups, always fall short of touching the boards steadiest source of income? Season Tickets? Has the time now arrived for that to change?