Tonight, the Celtic Fans Collective issued a statement which effectively refutes a number of the Board’s claims and doubles down on the protests.
The Not Another Penny campaign will continue. The Collective has pledged its full support to those who were behind Saturday’s action, and the organisation has pushed back strongly against the club’s suggestion that it had ever been involved in anything resembling constructive dialogue in the first place.
Tomorrow, I am going to write about the Streisand effect and why this whole episode is a classic example of it. But tonight, the point is much simpler.
The club has blundered into an unwinnable fight. If it follows through on its threat to ban supporters, that decision will touch every section of the fan base. Because who exactly are they going to ban?
Are they going to ban the Green Brigade en masse? That would look like a grotesque and vicious overreaction to what was, in reality, a relatively light stunt.
Are they going to start working their way through the executive of the Celtic Fans Collective? That would be foolishness on an entirely different level.
The Collective has deliberately tried to draw its executive from a cross-section of the support. For an organisation which the club insists is not genuinely representative, it went out of its way to hold a democratic election and now has an elected executive in place.
So, what happens if Celtic starts banning people from that group for what they may or may not have known, or for what they may or may not have approved? There is not a section of the Celtic support which would not be touched by that.
That is what happens when you target a body made up from a cross-section of the fan base. The club may try to delegitimise them, but that’s not their decision to make. 400 fan groups supported the establishment of the Collective and many thousands of us participated in the elections for its executive leadership.
You cannot delegitimise what we have made real.
And this is where the board has created a serious problem for itself.
Even some supporters who currently think the protest at St Andrews went too far, and who broadly sympathise with the club’s anger over it, may find themselves unable to justify what happens next if Celtic chooses to start handing out sweeping bans.
The club could turn people against itself who are not against it now. That would be an extraordinary act of self-harm.
But the alternative is hardly much better for them.
If they do not follow through on the threat, they expose the original statement as bluster. They make themselves look exactly as they appeared when that statement first came out: angry, emotional, reactive and weak.
Prepared to let one man’s fury shape the tone and direction of the football club, but perhaps not foolish enough to actually carry through the consequences of that fury once the moment has passed.
That is the bind. Follow through, and escalate the crisis. Back down, and expose the threat as empty. And tonight, the Collective has called that bluff.
Sky Sports News carried the Collective’s statement.
That matters. If the club hoped this would disappear after issuing its threat, if it believed it could make its position clear and then return quietly to normality, that calculation has already been shattered.
The story is still alive. The Collective is still standing. The campaign is still going. The threat did not end anything. If anything, it has made the possible scale of the confrontation bigger.
So, what happens next?
Has anyone inside Celtic actually thought about that?
I would guess not. I would guess there are people inside the club who do not want this escalated any further. I would guess there are people who understand perfectly well what happens if this becomes a prolonged war between the Board and organised sections of the support. But that may not be their choice.
That may be the choice of the man in Ireland.
And this is the real danger in allowing the whole direction of Celtic to be shaped so heavily by one person. If that one person decides to embark on a genuinely destructive course of action, who is going to stop him?
Someone has to. Someone should. And for the good of Celtic, someone must.
Because this is no longer simply about one protest, one statement or one angry man who had his golf game spoiled.
This is about what happens next.
We may find ourselves depending on the answer to that question. The immediate future of this football club may hinge on the answer to that question.
Because if there was ever a moment for somebody inside Celtic to stand up and say that enough is enough, then surely this is it.
This is zero hour now. This is the moment.
If certain people inside this club decide that they are going to escalate this to the next level, then other people inside this club have to stop that.
But who has the guts?
Now, in the hour of gravest need, who will put Celtic first?
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

Let’s wait and see. This might also be when we find out how much balls the collective has (no pun intended). You say many thousands voted for the collective elections. Do you have a number for that James? Even a ball park figure?
If the board go for it and take STs off supporters, who is going to stay away in solidarity? Nobody backed the GB by staying away last season for sure. Even the CC organised boycott of the cup game only got around 40% support. The board have 2 choices 1. de-escalate and hope results improve or they go all in and start taking STs off fans. Your ST could be at risk James, so fair play to you for putting your head above the parapet.
The NAP is a damp squib and has minimal affect and no real sacrifice for the ordinary fan. If the support want change they need to make big sacrifices.
The golf thing was fairly mild I would say, I doubt if the police are seriously investigating it though it was probably illegal in some minor way. That could be an issue.
What if certain protest groups started coming to CP and carried out protests disrupting games etc. Would that be acceptable to you James? After all the protest had nothing to do with the actual golf.
If the folk running Celtic decide to escalate we have to go all in, lose the title if necessary. This is already going to affect the players. Winning the title this season like many in the last 15 years is going to be more about the competence of the opposition.
mr mojo , i always find you a little bit too sweet to be wholesome ,
I can tell you i and many more Irish supporters won’t be traveling over to a dull Celtic park this season if the GB are banned again and that is a simple fact , the side is and has been depleted now for a while and one of my grand children has seen enough , no interest no excitement at the club , i can get a week in the canaries in january for my wife and i for what a weekend costs in glasgow , ask that pr!ck dermy dez knows the writing is on the wall for him and his he should do us all a favour and gwan the fuc while its his choice at the moment to make
“mr mojo , i always find you a little bit too sweet to be wholesome” …eat your heart out Bernie Taupin!
You’re wasted on here Bertie.
The bhoys did.
58,673 for the game 3rd of January 2026 while the GB were banned. Were the Bhoys not there Brattbakk? I cant remember.
We hear people threatening not to turn up, or throw in their ST book but when it comes to the crunch there is no solidarity. The next home game v the Ibrox entity, CP will be packed to the rafters, same as always, whether the GB or anyone else is banned wont make a blind bit of difference.
What happens next is a very good question. I think the board will ban people with some tenuous link to either organising or promoting the protest like they said they would and it’ll be a mistake.
They’re normally so good at ignoring fans too.
Why are we determined to implode though? MON gets talked about as a frail 74 year old yet DD is 76 and his age never gets mentioned. Let’s say we force him to sell, who will he sell to? Someone with Celtic’s best interests at heart? Or the highest bidder? The only good way to get rid is to buy him out, if there’s no one credible in the wings then we could easily go from bad to worse owners. Let’s be very honest here, the club has money and success, it’s not as strong as it ought to be and the board have overstayed their welcome but things could be worse.
Does the current situation merit boycotts? I don’t think enough people believe so but something has to change
I don’t agree with the St Andrews event being called a stunt and minor protest. So far golf has been lucky in not having thugs and crime at events other than heated Ryder Cup moments in the USA. I adore the sport of golf and if I saw a number of grown men in balaclavas approaching a green at the home of golf with spectators there, it would not be far fetched to assume and worry they were a terrorist organisation about to do harm as this just doesn’t happen. So some spectators could have been terrified. In today’s society, masked men is a no no in public places, so I think what these NEDS done was very serious and I can understand DD’s anger. If they had thrown the balls without masks, it would not have been such a big deal. These people if identified should be banned for life from CP.
Forever a prick Dan open your fucking eyes
Neo50. Insults usually mean you have nothing better to say. I want the board out as much as anyone but you can’t go around in balaclavas scaring the crap out of everyone, we were quick to call out the Ibrox mob for wearing masks. Seems to me that you may be the prick