9th May 2026; Fir Park, Motherwell, Scotland; Scottish Premiership Football, Motherwell versus Heart of Midlothian; Heart of Midlothian manager Derek McInnes
Earlier this week, Paulina wrote a piece about our former winger Aiden McGeady. In fact, she wrote two pieces about him.
In one, she highlighted how he was talking about Tounekti and what Tounekti needs to do to improve his game. And when someone with McGeady’s record is advising another winger on how to improve his game, that is something worth listening to.
Because McGeady is one of those guys who knows.
And more than that, McGeady is one of those guys who is very happy to share advice and what he knows.
Aiden has always been outspoken.
It got him into trouble whilst he was at Celtic. He had numerous arguments with Gordon Strachan in particular. And I like that a player is willing to speak up for himself.
McGeady never went running to the press or anything like that. He did his talking behind closed doors, but he made sure that everyone knew what his views were.
A few years ago, when I watched the first series of Sunderland ’Til I Die, I was not surprised to see Aiden talking openly to the cameras about his then coach, Chris Coleman, and expressing his dislike of the jokey attitude around training following a recent defeat.
McGeady, who was then and has always been a model professional who insists on high standards, was appalled that the players could be taking such a lax attitude to fixing their problems whilst those problems continued to mount to the extent that they were burying the whole club.
That is the McGeady we know: a vocal pain in managers’ backsides all through his time at Celtic, and probably elsewhere too.
A guy with opinions like that belongs in punditry.
And whilst it’s impossible to agree with everything a pundit says, one of the pieces Paulina put up the other day was a criticism of his body-language comments about Camilo Duran, where she rightly pointed out that McGeady is the latest in a long line of people in punditry to imagine themselves as experts in a very complicated subject which none of them are really qualified to speak on with any expertise.
Still, for all that, McGeady is a guy worth listening to.
He brings his experience in the game. He brings his knowledge of the game. And he brings his fearlessness to a microphone in a way that suggests he’s not going to be particularly worried about who he offends, or whose nose he puts out of joint, in the course of doing his job without fear or favour.
Those are the magic words.
And that is why I think this guy is going to be very respected within the profession.
Aiden McGeady has always said the thing no one else wants to say.
And one of the most profoundly important things that he said in relation to Celtic was last season, when everyone was talking about player pathways and how Celtic had not provided the right opportunities to its academy footballers.
McGeady said something which has stayed with me ever since and which, to me, settles the argument once and for all.
It echoes what a lot of us had been saying at the time, but to hear it come from not just a professional player, but someone who had come through Celtic’s academy system, made it enormously significant and recast the whole debate on Celtic’s alleged unwillingness to give its academy players a chance.
When asked about it, McGeady said that the pathway that exists now is the pathway that was always there.
Every young player who ever broke into the Celtic first team had players in front of him. Our club was signing players for what, in Scottish terms, were high transfer values when he personally broke into the side.
He wasn’t kept out of the team to facilitate the presence of expensive foreign imports, and nor did he break into the team because the club was sick of signing those players.
The way McGeady puts it is that he was so good that he could no longer be ignored by those coaching the first-team squad.
And that is exactly right.
That is the standard that any young player who wants to break into this team must now aspire to: to be so good that they cannot leave you out.
I have said before that there are allegedly dozens of examples of players who we allowed to leave, or who were snapped up by English clubs, or whatever it might be, and who allegedly we did not give opportunities to.
But as I’ve always said, anyone who believes that our club would prefer to spend millions on foreign imports than raise players through our own academy structure has not been paying attention in class.
That is what our club would love the chance to do most.
The simple fact is that our coaching system at Lennoxtown is wrong. Our academy system has failed in its principal responsibility, which is to go and find those players and polish them to that standard.
The Aiden McGeadys are rare anywhere, but they are shockingly rare at Celtic.
But it’s not because the pathway doesn’t exist.
McGeady said you make your own pathway. When you’re good enough that they can’t ignore you, the world opens up.
And he was correct.
The best thing about it is that this came at a time when everyone was talking about pathways and opportunities and the club needing to do more.
And McGeady said, well, the club will give them a chance when they’re good enough.
And that ended the argument.
There are people who are going to say that his comments last night about Derek McInnes were nothing but an ex-Celtic player swinging the boot at an Ibrox manager.
There are those who are going to say that McGeady is simply being a contrarian and taking McInnes to task for his comments about an injustice being done to Hearts, which the club should have pursued, and about how he has carried that grievance with him to Ibrox.
A lot of people are going to say that McGeady is just looking at things through a Celtic-supporting lens.
And some of that may even be true to an extent.
But here’s the other thing: McGeady is saying it because he believes it.
McGeady is saying it because he’s got a very sharp bullshit detector, and McGeady is paid to speak his mind. He’s not afraid to speak his mind.
He knows that’s the kind of criticism that will be levelled at him after last night. He knows that will be the prevailing judgement of some around him in punditry who don’t want to have to say that McInnes is simply a man looking for excuses for his own failures.
But McGeady is not scared to say that out loud, even if some of them are.
And in this, he joins a number of other pundits who are going to do very well because they will tell the truth as they see it.
I’m not going to like everything Aiden McGeady says. I’m not going to agree with every word that comes out of his mouth.
But I know that I’m not watching some shill. I know I’m not watching some guy who’s trying to cover his arse and doesn’t want to be at the centre of controversy.
But I also know that I’m not watching a guy who’s being controversial for its own sake.
When you listen to McGeady talk, you hear a guy talking common sense. A guy saying: this is the obvious situation. This is the obvious point.
Just as he’s always done in his career.
From criticising Chris Coleman’s lax attitude to training at Sunderland, to whatever his arguments were with Gordon Strachan about team strategy or tactics at Celtic Park, to his telling Tounekti that there are certain things a winger has to be willing to do that he is not doing, and therefore he is not fitting into the team in a proper way.
McGeady has always just told it as he sees it.
And underneath all of that, there is real intelligence.
I’ve always thought that McGeady was a guy who had balls.
He had offers from everywhere when he left Celtic Park, and he took the one in Russia. You could not get much further away from the comfort zone that people believed McGeady would retreat to.
He went to Moscow to learn a different language, to live in a different climate and to experience football in a completely different way.
It was not the easy decision, but for him and for his family it was the right decision, and he did not hesitate. He did not let cultural, social, language, political or any other barriers get in his way.
Just as when he took the decision to choose the Republic of Ireland as his national team over Scotland, he knew there would be critics.
He knew he would get slammed.
People like Gordon McQueen accused him of being a traitor to his country.
McGeady didn’t let any of that stop him. McGeady never has. This is a guy of personal conviction and courage.
And so, when he talks about McInnes looking for excuses, when he talks about McInnes deploying smoke to cover his own failure, that’s worth listening to.
And it’s worth listening to whether you agree with it or not.
It just so happens that I do.
It just so happens that it gels perfectly with a lot of what some of us in Celtic fan media have been saying about McInnes: that he never accepts personal responsibility.
But McGeady is not saying it as a Celtic fan having a go.
He’s saying it because he believes it. And that is why I like to listen to the guy. That is why I’m going to enjoy listening to the guy.
Not because he says the things I want to hear, but because the words that come out of his mouth are completely unfiltered, and because at the centre of them is a real grounded intelligence.
He won’t get everything right.
But I’ll bet he gets more right than he gets wrong.
And that’s why I’m glad he’s a pundit.
I’m glad he’s in the media environment right now, and I hope he’s there for a very long time to come.

I agree that McGeady is a great listen as speaks with uncompromising honesty and intelligence, no matter his audience. The only part I slightly disagree with is that he is not qualified to speak about a player’s body language as an indicator of where he’s at form and confidence wise. He maybe hasn’t studied body language (although I wouldn’t bet against it) but a body language expert won’t have played for Celtic with the expectation of 60,000 fans analysing his every move. So I would argue that McGeady just pips the body language expert in qualification to describe this particular scenario.
A Sevco supporter was on SSB last night, saying that his club is too big for McInnes, citing the exact same case as McGeady, but without mentioning him by name. He was disgusted at McInnes’ attempts to gain plaudits for “his” Hearts side, and claim that injustices were done, before and after his new club were playing against them, with the weird “handshake” with the Hearts manager at the end, were embarrassing and showed him up as not fit to manage his club.