There are moments in football when a Celtic supporter does not need a dramatic injury announcement to start imagining the worst.
Sometimes all it takes is a player returning to the pitch, only to disappear again a few minutes later. Unfortunately, that is precisely what happened with Alistair Johnston during Celtic’s victory over Hibernian.
When AJ came onto the pitch at Easter Road, I genuinely hoped we were finally seeing the beginning of his return to full fitness. The Canadian international has already endured far too many injury problems, and Celtic could certainly do with having one of their most dependable defenders available again.
That optimism lasted precisely 21 minutes. Johnston was forced off again after feeling something high in his hamstring, and suddenly we were all wondering whether another dreadful piece of injury news was about to arrive. After everything Celtic have already been through with injuries this season, my imagination was certainly working overtime.
Was this another lengthy absence? Had he aggravated the same problem? Were we going to watch another important Celtic player disappear for months?
Thankfully, the reports which have emerged since then appear considerably more reassuring. Johnston is reportedly facing something closer to a month on the sidelines rather than another catastrophic lay-off.
Obviously, I would much rather see him wearing the green and white hoops than sitting in the treatment room, but compared with what many of us feared when he walked off at Easter Road, a month feels almost like good news.
Almost. Because I would not be a Celtic supporter if I simply breathed a sigh of relief and stopped thinking about what comes next. Johnston’s absence still leaves Celtic with a problem at right-back.
Fortunately, one of the more positive developments this season has been Colby Donovan, and the timing of his new contract could hardly be more appropriate.
Donovan has signed a deal which keeps him at Celtic until 2031, and I welcomed that news this morning, because I firmly believe young players should be able to see a genuine pathway from the academy into the first team.
In Donovan’s case, we are already beyond talking about potential alone. He has played regularly this season, he has been trusted, and he has performed well enough to earn praise from Martin O’Neill and a first call-up to the Scotland squad.
So, Johnston’s latest absence does not simply throw some untested youngster into a crisis. It gives a young player who has already shown that he belongs at this level an opportunity to take another step forward.
I do not expect Donovan to become Alistair Johnston overnight, nor should anybody else.
Johnston is an experienced international footballer with established qualities. He gives Celtic energy, aggression and a very strong attacking presence down that side.
Donovan is still learning. He will make mistakes. There will be games where his inexperience shows, and Celtic supporters have to allow for that.
We cannot spend years complaining that academy players never receive proper opportunities and then demand perfection from one the moment he finally gets a run of games. That would be rather convenient, wouldn’t it?
Development requires patience, proper coaching and, above all, trust.
The good thing here is that O’Neill clearly trusts Donovan. He has already described him as exceptional and admitted that the youngster has done better than almost anyone could have anticipated.
That is significant praise, and now Donovan has the opportunity to demonstrate that Celtic do not have to panic every time Johnston becomes unavailable.
But there is a wider issue here which should not disappear simply because the news about AJ appears better than we originally feared. Celtic still need sufficient depth.
A club competing domestically and in Europe cannot find itself holding its breath every time one first-team player feels a hamstring.
Injuries are unavoidable. Nobody can prevent every muscle problem, knock or setback.
But good squad planning should prevent one injury from destabilising an entire position. That is what depth is supposed to be for.
And the right-back position is particularly demanding in the modern game. It is not simply a matter of standing in the correct defensive area and stopping somebody running past you.
A full-back has to defend intelligently, support attacks, provide width, understand when to overlap and when to stay, and fit into whatever tactical structure the manager is using.
Johnston gives Celtic all of that when he is fit. The question over the coming weeks is whether Donovan can continue showing that he is capable of taking on more of those responsibilities.
I hope he does. Nothing would please me more than seeing another academy graduate establish himself properly in the Celtic first team.
But the club also has a responsibility here.
Donovan should be given the support to develop rather than being expected to carry a position because the squad has not been planned properly.
There is a difference between giving a young player an opportunity and making him the emergency answer to every problem.
That is why his new contract until 2031 is encouraging, but the contract itself is only the beginning. The real proof comes in what Celtic do with him now.
Give him meaningful minutes. Coach him properly. Allow him to make mistakes. Let him develop alongside experienced players rather than expecting him to behave like one immediately.
That is what a genuine academy pathway looks like.
As for Johnston, there should be absolutely no temptation to rush him. We have already watched him return once and last only 21 minutes.
Nobody needs a repeat performance. If the new injury means a month, then give him the month. If it takes slightly longer, so be it.
I would much rather Celtic get AJ back properly than shave a week off his recovery and find ourselves discussing another setback immediately afterwards.
His importance to the team is precisely why caution matters. Celtic need him fit, not merely available.
So yes, the latest indications are a relief. When Johnston walked off against Hibernian, many of us feared something far worse than this.
If the prognosis really is around a month, we can probably put away the most catastrophic scenarios.
But Celtic cannot become complacent either.
Johnston’s absence places greater responsibility on Donovan, and that will tell us something useful about where the youngster really is in his development. It will also tell us something about Celtic’s squad planning.
Can the team absorb the loss of an important first-choice player without the whole position becoming a weekly problem?
That is what good squads do.
For now, I am going to take the positive news. I hope Johnston’s recovery is straightforward, I hope Celtic give him every minute he needs, and I hope Donovan embraces the opportunity now sitting in front of him. His new contract says Celtic believe in him. The next few weeks give him a chance to show exactly why.
And perhaps, for once, Celtic supporters can spend a month talking about the football rather than trying to become amateur hamstring specialists every time somebody reaches for the back of his leg.
That would make a pleasant change.
Choose The CelticBlog as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.
