21 thoughts on “Celtic is a broken club. No more living in denial about it.”

  1. Sliding doors — it always it but few recognise the moments.
    .
    We had chances and squandered them by the half dozen all while playing pretty poorly.
    They had few chances but took them and played some good football to a pattern that the whole team worked towards. We looked lost / lightweight / leaderless — “weak” would be my single word description.
    .
    CCV — still with his mind on his injury.
    Tierney — football now looks like a chore to him / weak in everything he does / terrible footballer. Horrible to see his decline to the point that this could be his last season at the top level. His physique is that of a 16 year old who plays computer games.
    McGregor — Filling in time practising his manager vibe on the park as it if was training. He is rationing his effort which is not a good look as the opposition run past you at walking pace.
    AOC — looks lost / still got something but he is at best half ersed.
    Scales — unbelievably bad footballer who can put in a shift at times.
    Who is a squad player at best not a fixture and stinks the place out in a poor defence.
    .
    O’Neill has to go — if he needs the money then give him a testimonial.
    Anything to get him out of the club — we have a duty of care and this won’t end well.

    1. Totally agree with all of that mitch. The main issue is the management, coaching and ultimately the board. Folk on here were calling it a miracle last season. Winning a one horse race is not a miracle. MON is finished. Pay his wages until the end of the season if he’s desperate for the cash but he must go now. Anyone could have got us over the line last season, the opposition is that poor.
      Arteta turned Tierney into a proper footballer and gave him back to us for nothing. Last season playing under Rodgers, Nancy and MON he looked finished apart from a few cameos. Even Steve Clarke had Tierney looking good, scored a peach to take us to the world cup. Denmark would put 10 past Falkirk ffs.

      If we want change the collective need to get their arse in gear. Ask the fans if they are willing to go all in. Tennis balls doesn’t work. Half hearted boycotts dont work. The GB have been hung out to dry by the support 48,000 v Ferencvaros with no GB boycott. 48,000 v celta vigo after GB boycott called despite GB telling fans how to get their money back. There will be less for the Besiktas game but not because of any solidarity. There will be less because the glory hunters won’t go..there will be less because the football is shite. There will be less the same reason Hibs fans didnt turn up against us.

      Give Besiktas the entire stadium.

      Celtic fans are to blame for what is happening. Not just the “happy clappers who celebrated like we had won the world cup on last day of season” but the ditherers.
      The ST holders are complicit in our downfall, Shitting themselves another Celtic fan will steal their ticket, and they wont get it back when the one horse race returns!

      The collective is an ineffectual irrelevance!

  2. James, i posed the question at the end of last season. Will mon lose his status if he stays on and fails miserably. Today, I think the answer to that question is becoming more clearer the more he lingers on.
    He’s bit a daft man. He surely must realise that he can’t get a tune out if these players, fir whatever reason he may think. Is it them, or is it him and his coaches? Wherever the answer lies, it’s now time to draw a close and let the fairytale end today. If I could speak to him f2f, I’d plead with him to go. Not that I hold up much hope of this, but if the board acts quickly, gets in a half decent manager, then we can save this season. Will they do that?, i very much doubt it.
    They’ve shafted him with signings…messed him around re his coaching staff, but he’s never done a Rogers and openly criticised them…..probably due to friends within.
    Who’d take over is anyone’s guess. Who the support want and who they get it, is 1 thing, but surely any manager who may be offered the job, would do his research and think twice.
    The clubs a shambles from top to acadamy. The fans have to now gorce the changes, or the shitshow will continue

  3. I think the majority of us that have constantly blamed this board for the massive regression in every aspect of our club, will take no pleasure in the depths we are currently
    plummeting to!!!

    We know MON shouldn’t be there, nor SM et al, but they are and the slow train has now finally arrived at destination dysfunction!!!

    God now knows how we rescue this with the current incumbents littered throughout our club, and without someone who is willing to stand up, take accountability and try to start us on the long road back to some sort of real identity again ???

    We can only make changes to management if someone with real gravitas, ability and style can be appointed, and allowed to do things his own way and the correct way !!!

    None of us expect this to happen under this board and that’s an ongoing & frightening problem !!!

    I thought my positivity had been stretched to its limits last season but this is actually getting worse on a weekly basis.

    The enthusiasm and enjoyment for our club is being drained out of us on a weekly basis!

    I still retain positivity but that comes from my strong faith, and I am now wondering whether we have to experience a period of real hardship to get to where we all want this club to be at !
    That is, a club that can function as professionally as it should be in EVERY department, and use every positive asset that we have to maximise rewards and reputation both at home in Europe !!!

    We are getting close to, courtesy of our present incumbents, a real nadir!!!

    This season has been dire thus far, with the genuine chances of it, completely disintegrating!!!

    Tough times need tough characters …are there any out there capable of helping us out ?

    Please head to Celtic Park asap with the removals van and get to work ! HH

  4. Me and many other fans have been moaning about the board for years for repeatedly making the same mistakes year after year but I always look forward to the window closing because then it’s down to the football people. MON might not have got all he wanted from the window but the job is to make a functioning team out of what you have and it should be enough for Scotland at least.
    Today is on MON, the first half wasn’t good enough but we missed a lot of chances and chucked at least the first goal. The 2nd half for me was unacceptable, the subs made no sense, taking Duran off was criminal and the subs offered nothing. If ever there was a time to play Hogh and Duran up front together it was today. I’m not convinced MON is going to get the best from this team.

  5. A lot of us knew what was going to happen even before we won last year’s title. The big slide was well under way. Action had to be taken in the summer but the ST’s sold out. No point blaming the same MON that won a double now.

  6. I have come to the opinion that MON was not the man who took us to the final in 2003. I am more inclined now to think that Robbo was the main tactician. Age should not be a barrier to or an excuse for what we are watching now, unless dementia has set in.
    Nothing MON is doing just now remotely resembles what his last side were doing on the park. It cannot be just down to the players although watching Scales and McGregor would make a good case for it, same old same old, get it out wide cross to nowhere and while doing it be so slow that opposition reforms as you said.
    Bain had a decent game although most of the shots were straight at him, but then he positioned himself as keepers should, had Sinisalo or the other guy been faced with same, I reckon they would have picked a couple out, He is in my opinion better than what we have.
    Should sevco win the league and gain entry to CL we can look at a long time in the doldrums as they will spend every penny to get to and stay at the top.
    Something is rotten within Celtic Park just now and it aint just the players.

    1. High, that Sevco reference is absolutely spot on and frightens the fucking life out of me. I honestly believe the Huns would go on towards a run like their 9 IAR. That is the utterly depressing prospect and that’s before you factor in what Hearts could become. We could and should have been light years ahead of this league and it’s become more and more level until we are going to struggle to even stay there.

    2. I’m thing same as you Hugh and questioning the 2003 game. I think it’s time to part company with MON . It’s not working and the football has been desire to watch . We all knew last season was about getting the points but this season we are as bad if not worse

  7. I know I could get stick for this and I’ll willingly accept that. I am no happy clapper, but I am a ST holder and a fan for over 50 years. I did renew because my first is to support my team, though through many seasons it’s been Hell and through many it’s been a joy. I was here before anyone on this board and I hope to be here after the sleekit feks are gone. I just can’t see that happening whatever protests are asked for and I really do believe in what a lot of the fans are calling for. I haven’t attended a single Europa game, but I would not quit supporting my team.
    At the spilt we were in third and given ‘zero chance’ of winning. Now, as much as it was a penalty against Motherwell, I’m the first to admit I’m glad we fucking got it because last season was the loudest wake up call we were ever going to get, but the board, coaching staff and recruitment seem to have slept through it. We have enough individual quality, but as ‘lesser’ sides keep showing us, you can have less individual quality and be a much higher quality team. Today is the best example of that yet. If we can get this coaching team out (it kills me to say it of MON) and get anyone with the slightest nouse enough to pull this team together and into fitness, we will do it. We are a third of the way into the season and even a Huns win keeps us top. No happy clapping, but supporting the team matters. We have to do that and yet I’d still be happy to endure some short term pain that might kick Desmond up the arse in the long term, if he and his cling-ons are as immovable as they seem to be. HH everyone.

    1. Good post Marty,
      Pains me to say it too, but we need a change !

      If it’s done soon, and this incompetent board, were capable of actually making a prudent, responsible and effective hire, this season would definitely be saved !

      “IF” is always such a huge word in these situations!

      Used in conjunction with this board, it is almost impossible! HH

  8. The worst thing that happened to Celtic was MON winning the league title last season. If Hearts had won it MON would’ve been replaced and a rebuild would’ve taken place. The SPL would also have became an attractive TV package.

    The small mindedness of the fans is reflected by the board.

    1. I would go further and argue that the worst thing to happen to Celtic was the dissolution of Rangers in 2012.

  9. We are still well on our way to a top six finish which isn’t bad for a ‘club’ with no strategy, no ambition, no accountability and a ‘team’ full of imposters. Hopefully we can stay in front of St Johnstone for a few more weeks at least!

  10. The Board should have backed Nancy …he was bringing a lasting change but the players didn’t want it and the board backed them over the Manager. Remember Nancy had to cope with a lot of dubious refereeing decisions and was constantly pilloried by the press with no protection from the Board.

    The players and Board threw him under the bus.

    He’ll mend them they get what they deserve , the fans don’t we back them 100% ..it’s all we can do .

  11. After winning the League last season nearly every Celtic supporter thought that after that near miss there would a complete overhaul of Celtic. MON should have walked away with thanks, and cheers ringing in his ears
    But no Desmond and his lackeys saw a chance of carrying on running the club their way, rather than bring in a manager with knowledge of the modern game, and ambition, along with an experienced DOF, they carried on in their disfunctional way, with the results we now see.
    MON seems delusional these days, if only he was realistic and honest enough to walk away, he would then keep his dignity, if he doesn’t, then this could end in a very undignified and messy way.
    I hope it doesn’t end that way.

  12. The board and the management needs to change ASAP.
    MON needs to go and take SM with him.
    Total disgrace.
    Clueless with no structure or idea.
    MON may be a Legend but enough is enough.
    Time for change before thw season varnishes before our eyes.

  13. As many of you will be aware, I have repeatedly said on here that “Rome is burning”
    Until the stench of Desmond is removed our club will continue in steep decline.
    There are mentions of Nancy not given time and a chance to implement his style.What utter nonsense, poor Wilfrid should never have even been considered for the celtic job.
    No experience, no track record, no clue.
    And James do me a favour, you mention a new signing in January who can save the day.Have you completely missed the recent windows.
    We don’t sign good players, we sign overpriced leftovers who nobody else wants.
    And replacing Martin? Pep Gaurdiola would not touch the job while Desmond is stinking the house out and neither would John McGlynn for that matter.
    We have got to get shot of Desmond ASAP.
    As I’ve stated for a year now.
    ROME IS BURNING.

  14. As you say it was no surprise, in fact it was expected. The only retaining factor, and why the legend that is MON has no real need to worry, is that in “The Owner’s” Celtic if you’re a mate of his or one of his selected lackeys ( which tbf virtually all of the senior managers at Celtic are) then you don’t need to worry about job security!

Comments are closed.