5th February 2023; McDiarmid Park, Perth, Scotland: Scottish Premiership Football, St Johnstone versus Celtic; Hyeongyu Oh of Celtic
I do not buy for one second the revisionist bullshit being pushed on one particular Celtic site today about the so-called “Class of 2023”.
It is rubbish.
It is the same crap that website has been promoting since the day and hour Brendan Rodgers came back to the club: that he wasted players, that he rejected talent, that he somehow vandalised a great group of recruits who would otherwise have flourished.
It is absolutely untrue.
And the example being hoisted in our faces today is Oh Hyeon-gyu, who we could face tonight for Be?ikta? if he plays.
Oh has gone on to have a decent career since leaving Celtic. He moved to Genk in 2024, and then to Be?ikta? earlier this year. He has improved, developed and made progress. None of that is in dispute.
But none of that proves the argument being made.
I have little doubt that he will play tonight. I don’t even doubt that he’ll score.
But this isn’t proof that we let go of an absolute gem of a player.
It is proof that we may have signed a player, once again, without any coherent plan for how to use him.
But that’s not the same thing.
You can see the same pattern repeated right now with Kasper Høgh. Eleven million pounds of waste if it turns out that we cannot get a tune out of this guy.
Because this is what we do.
We sign players who don’t fit the style of play. We sign players who are not obvious matches for the team shape, the formation or the way we actually intend to play.
And then we end up making these mistakes over and over again.
If Oh comes to Celtic Park and scores against us tonight, he will hardly be the first player we have signed, wasted, underused or misunderstood, then allowed to leave, only for him to come back and haunt us later.
Jo Inge Berget comes immediately to mind. Harald Brattbakk comes to mind too.
And there are others.
Over and over and over again.
The common denominator is that we seem to sign players on a regular basis who are not obvious fits for the team, and then they go to clubs which do know how to utilise them.
And sooner or later, it comes back to bite us in the arse.
But this is what happens when the guy in the dugout, the recruitment team and whoever was sitting on that little four-man committee are not working together.
When they are working at cross purposes, when one hand does not know what the other hand is doing, this is what happens.
You get inconsistency.
You get incoherence.
You get a system designed for one manager trying to accommodate players who were not signed to play in that system.
And then you blame the manager for failing to develop the footballer.
How can the guy develop a footballer who has been brought in to play in a system he is not suited to?
When you say “develop”, what you really mean is train out of him all the things which made him a good player in the first place and try to reconstruct him in another form.
How many failures at that particular challenge do you need to watch before you recognise that this is where the lunacy actually lies?
Not in leaving good players to rot.
The lunacy is in trying to fit square pegs into round holes by turning them into round pegs.
But every time you shave something away, you lose something of the player you signed in the first place.
It is insanity.
So yeah, I have little doubt that Oh could come back tonight and do us damage.
Little doubt about it.
He is at a club which plays to his strengths but, more importantly, knows what those strengths actually are.
A radical departure from what we do, I will grant you.
And even then, he does not actually play that much for Be?ikta?. In fact, some of his best performances this year have come in the Europa League.
Surprise, surprise.
But we really are a very odd club in the way we go about our business.
I’m not saying we’re the only club in Europe which does this. There are plenty of examples of it, and the managerial graveyards are full of guys who had to work under this kind of lunatic system.
But by God, we are a shocking example.
We are a standout example.
At a time when Scottish football is pleading poverty like never before, we’re spending £11 million on a player we cannot even use properly.
And if Kasper Høgh’s time here ends in disaster, who gets the blame for that?
I know CQN will do its best to blame Brendan Rodgers.
There’s only one problem with that, and it’s the same problem I have with nearly every argument they make about that guy.
It’s obviously bullshit.
So if Oh comes out tonight and plays against us, and if he scores, this will not be anything we haven’t seen before.
It will not be proof that somehow a generational talent slipped through our fingers.
It might be proof that, once again, our board of directors signed a player for whom we had no obvious use.
And he wasn’t even signed under Rodgers.
He was signed under Ange, who couldn’t find a proper use for him either.
That matters.
Because it completely undermines this idea that Oh somehow became another victim of Brendan Rodgers’ supposed refusal to develop players.
The problem existed before Rodgers came back.
It was the same problem then that it is now.
The wrong player, signed without an obvious plan, then dropped into a system which did not suit him and expected to adapt.
It’s the same old song being played over and over again over there.
Anything not to confront the real problems we have.
Anything not to point the finger where it belongs.
Choose The CelticBlog as a Preferred Source on Google News…

” He moved to Genk in 2024, and then to Be?ikta? earlier this year. He has improved, developed and made progress.”
There is the problem right there. Christie was loaned out to Aberdeen and improved enough to win a shot at the EPL. Scales improved so much there he was crossing into the box from 50 yards out and in one occasion scoring as one cross/shot sailed into the net against Sevco from the half-way line.
Now he is terrified to try anything.
Oh is a very good footballer who is probably too good for us.
.
Jan to May 2024 — Idah scores ugly goals and quite a few of them / Oh makes it into every SPL GK’s highlights reel as he is denied time and again by worldies.
.
Oh moves on in the summer which is a great loss to us as Idah reverts to the mean and loses whatever get up and go he had as a consequence.
.
So another episode of our post Postecoglu decline based on disengaged managers and a scouting set up that is amateurish in the extreme.
.
Hopefully Oh and his GK’er worldie streak continues at Parkhead tonight.
If we were a well run club he would be starting for us tonight in the CL.
Feeling lucky after the Donny John collapse and Musk packing up for Mars.