1st November 2026; Falkirk Stadium, Falkirk, Scotland; Scottish Premiership Football, Falkirk versus Celtic; Scott Bain of Falkirk celebrates with Lewis Neilson of Falkirk after making a save
There were two stories doing the rounds the other day which offer an insight into where we are as a club, and into Celtic’s signing and transfer policy.
One said that if we sign a midfielder in the January window, we may be willing to let Luke McCowan go out on loan.
I think the chances of McCowan leaving on a permanent deal are virtually zero, because we gave him an extended contract on better terms than almost every other club in this league could afford, or would be willing, to pay.
The second story concerns Scott Bain, and the allegation that Celtic tried to re-sign him in the summer, only a year after we had let him leave the club.
Under normal circumstances, a story like that would be staggering. But in the context of where we are as a club right now, it is entirely believable.
Between those two stories, you get a pretty clear picture of the complete incoherence in the way Celtic does its business.
McCowan will not play enough games to justify the salary increase he received, and we all know that. We have known it for a while. And that is no longer even the biggest issue with the McCowan deal.
The fact is that this guy now faces sitting on the bench indefinitely.
He will play, if he is very lucky, only a handful of games between now and the end of the season, and if the next manager wants to retain him, I will be astonished. And yet we are talking about needing another player to come in before we allow this guy to leave, even though we clearly have no real use for him.
I may not be Luke McCowan’s number one fan, but it is an absolute disgrace that we do not simply cut this guy loose and allow him to pursue his career somewhere he will actually play every week. But this is what we do.
We waste players. We waste so many, many, many players.
And then there is the Scott Bain story.
Celtic replaced Bain with Ross Doohan in the summer of 2025. Doohan came back to the club on a three-year deal after having previously come through the academy and spending time elsewhere. He was, in effect, installed into the squad structure that Bain had previously occupied. Needless to say, he has barely been seen.
So, if Celtic really did explore bringing Bain back only a year later, what exactly was the plan? What exactly would his position have been?
Because we were linked with a lot of really good first-choice goalkeepers, but we did not appear to make a serious move for any of them.
Was Bain being brought in to be Sinisalo’s understudy? Was he being brought back so that we could move Ross Doohan out again? Or are we stockpiling goalkeepers here?
Would we still have signed Sam Johnstone? Would we have signed anyone in goal had we managed to get Scott Bain or are we expected to believe that Scott Bain might have been Celtic’s starting goalkeeper just 12 months after the club had deemed him surplus to requirements? That would be remarkable.
At almost any other club, it would be remarkable anyway. But at Celtic, there are people who would barely have been surprised.
This whole process has become so confused that even I struggle to keep it straight in my head, and I do this for a living every single day.
A coherent football operation should be easy enough to comprehend. You should be able to look at the squad and understand the logic.
With Celtic right now, you need a whiteboard, three different colours of marker and a detective’s corkboard with string connecting the photographs. And that brings me back to something I said during the debate we had last Thursday.
Martin, the guy who came on, asked explicitly whether our concern was about the process or the implementation.
And I had a problem answering the question. Because, quoting Captain Willard in Apocalypse Now, I do not see any method at all.
I do not see a process. I do not see a strategy. And unless I can evaluate the strategy, I cannot properly evaluate the implementation.
But it increasingly appears that Celtic are doing both badly.
Because we did not even get Scott Bain; apparently it was too difficult dealing with Dundee. So not only does the strategy itself appear completely incoherent, even the implementation of that incoherent strategy failed.
Then there is Luke McCowan. We gave him a new deal at the end of last season, extending his time at the club and giving him more money, which now makes him incredibly difficult to move on. Martin O’Neill explicitly said that he was the kind of player a new manager would be “keen to work with.”
And then we benched him in all but a handful of games.
Not that I’m necessarily complaining about that. I was angrier that we retained him in the first place, I certainly don’t want him in the team.
But this is the polar opposite of what we were assured was the plan. Maybe there is a plan here. But God alone knows what it is.
And the more you learn about how this club behaves, the more you hear about the way we are going about our business, the less sense any of it makes. At the Greenock meeting, we are told Nicholson said there is a four-man committee who decides on signings with the manager getting the final signoff.
To me that sounds like at least two players too many, because beyond the lead scout and the manager what else do you need? But the real question is, how many of those four are actually qualified to spot players?
Every new piece of information seems to confuse the picture rather than clarify it.
This is supposed to be a football club with a functioning recruitment operation, a coherent squad-building strategy and some sense of what the team is supposed to look like six months, twelve months and five years from now.
Instead, we appear to be extending contracts for players we barely intend to use, signing players we do not intend to. We let players go and then try to bring them back. We know we’ve done this with the likes of Jota, we tried to do it with Kyogo, we attempted something similar with Greg Taylor and now this.
And there are still people who believe that things are working as intended.
Well, I will tell you right now, if this is things working as intended, I would hate to see what a real crisis looks like. Because this is already awfully close to the textbook definition of a shitshow.
Choose The CelticBlog as a Preferred Source on Google News…

That just about sums up the state club is in……giving Scales and McCowan extended contracts with a ball more money and now talking about resigning Bain ffs……