Articles & Features

Why Celtic Has Nothing To “Learn” From Ibrox’s Failed Europa League Campaign.

Image for Why Celtic Has Nothing To “Learn” From Ibrox’s Failed Europa League Campaign.

Martin O’Neill is in the papers today, being ever so slightly misquoted by the headlines in that he suggests we try to “learn” from Ibrox’s European campaign. I say ever so slightly misquoted; he used words not dissimilar to that and so it’s not an outright fabrication. But maybe the right word is to say that his words were “misrepresented.”

In fact, all O’Neill was telling us is to take heart from the fact that a team we’ve beaten to the title got that far, and that it proves that with the right wind at your back that a team from Scotland can once again scale those heights.

I applaud the sentiment, even if I don’t necessarily agree with the fundamental premise on which it is built. For Celtic to go as far as that in Europe two things would need to happen; first, we’d need to be very fortunate in who we drew in European competition and secondly, we’d need to win more than just seven games on the way to getting there.

What else, exactly, should we be aiming to learn from their run? They got there, as I said last night, on the back of a one win in three games record … to get to a European final on a run like that isn’t just riding your luck, it’s shooting the moon.

If you saw their team for the final – and indeed, for some of the games prior to it – they went with a system that was so defensive they had to rely on a hit-and-hope punt up the park for their goal. What can we learn from that? Well, Ange has already said that there’s nothing we can learn from it because we’re never going to play that way.

We will play front-foot football next season in Europe, regardless of the opposition. That’s the truth of it. We may make some big signings to make the midfield more robust, and to make the defence more solid, but the basic strategy will be to attack teams whoever they are, whether that’s at home or away. We will score goals. We will concede them too.

And it will either work, or it won’t. But we will win games along the way, and we will earn a reputation as a team which tries to put teams under pressure rather than one that sits back and tries to soak it up. Ibrox did that reasonably well … but not well enough, as it turns out, because they didn’t win the tournament and no-one cares who finishes second.

Martin O’Neill wants us to be better … he does not want us to change the way we play, or the underlying philosophy that got us here. Not that it matters, because when the question was posed to Ange about whether we had anything to learn from Ibrox he was emphatic in saying no, and even directed the questioner to the big trophy itself.

Ultimately, that’s the only data point he cares about. We will make our own history, not some other club’s almost-but-not-quite version of it.

Share this article


  • Jim says:

    McGregor, Bassey and Lundstrum are thugs in football shirts. Lundstrum almost scalped a German and wasn’t even booked.

    We don’t play anti-football. We will win playing ‘pure, beautiful football’.

    The truth is Eintracht were far better. They matched up to them physically and could play a bit themselves. If their finishing had been better they would have been out of sight well before the 90 minutes were up

  • jrm63 says:

    Bassey was awful. He fell on his backside as well and if that attacker had taken his ground as he should have he wasn’t getting back. He gets away with a lot in Scotland and would not have the pace for the EPL.
    The issue is whether we are good enough to play 4-3-3 in Europe. Liverpool and Man City are but are we? We bought Maeda to show the kind of athleticism the modern game demands but he is not at that level in terms of football ability and technical skill.
    Do you then compromise and play an extra holding midfield player?

  • Jim says:

    Maeda isn’t a technically gifted player. And yet in just 22 games mostly playing out on the wing, he scored 8 goals and had 5 assists.

    You saw glimpses of good combination play with Kyogo towards the end of the season.

    However if there is any possibility of bringing in the Bodo Glimt lad, Solbakken, we should take it.

    My worry is midfield. McGregor, Turnbull and O’Riley are up to it, but we need someone who provides far more than Hatate. Ideguchi is an unknown quantity. McCarthy and Soro it would seem are not in Ange’s thoughts. We are thin in that area and signings need to be good.

Comments are closed.